4 ms·
> "Net Neutrality" is nothing more than an Orwellian named, amorphous and vague idea that nobody really knows what it means. What are you talking about? Net Ne
by danShumway 9y ago
> "Net Neutrality" is nothing more than an Orwellian named, amorphous and vague idea that nobody really knows what it means.
What are you talking about? Net Neutrality isn't complicated at all, it's just saying that Internet providers need to deliver Internet connections without prioritizing or blocking certain sites/connections.
The only complication is that telcos and businesses have different ideas about how far it should go (ie should zero-rating content be included). This is like arguing that because we have disagreements about the extent of free speech that the entire concept of free speech is just poorly defined government propaganda.
This is nothing like GDPR, this not a government created oligopoly, you're thinking about this completely backwards. Net neutrality decreases government control over the Internet; it enshrines that businesses, states, and governments aren't allowed to control access or play favorites in a freely competitive online market.
There are valid reasons why someone might oppose legislated net neutrality, but "the government taking over" isn't one of them. You lose a lot of credibility when you use words like 'Orwellian' to describe a policy that explicitly makes it harder to censor things.
- ppf 9y agoThe concept of "Net Neutrality", like "free speech", is very simple, and both do not allow any latitude. You cannot have "free speech" if some speech is not allowed. There is no "how far it should go" - if you support that ISPs must treat all connections equally, then how can you possibly support zero-rating content? The idea that some people get free access to some sites and others do not is exactly the kind of situation that Net Neutrality is supposed to stop. "Net Neutrality" should also stop ISPs prioritising video and audio streaming, and also prevent ISPs blocking content you find morally or politically objectionable. If you admit that there is some latitude to the implementation of "Net Neutrality", then you don't have Net Neutrality, you have some guidelines on what is and what isn't allowed. This is precisely the (uniquely US) problem of codifying theoretical constructs - they cannot work in practice, so time and effort is spend justifying why exceptions to the rule still conform to the original rule. See "hate speech" vs "free speech".
- sudoke 9y ago>Net neutrality decreases government control over the Interne WOW, this might be the most flawed thinking in all of HN.