4 ms·
So, on the one hand one approach is to replace the mind (take it out of the loop and "let the robots take over". The other is to "augment the mind and enable i
by mc32 9y ago
So, on the one hand one approach is to replace the mind (take it out of the loop and "let the robots take over". The other is to "augment the mind and enable it to do more". One sounds better then the other.
The robotic choice unfortunately has a very authoritarian or centralist vibe. That is, it's taking over for the person with but with central tutelage. The other the tutelage is in the person using the augmenting tech.
Obs it remains to be seen how things pan out.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoBoth approaches are really equivalent on the technical level. Augmenting the mind is done by automating and abstracting away lower-level stuff - taking the mind out of the loop and letting the robots take the details over. And the problem with all those companies is agency. It seems they all try to minimize user's agency, by making it purposefully impossible to control or dig into underlying automation. They differ by the effort put into taking control away from the user, with Google being the leader in blatantly dumbing down and isolating everything.
- mc32 9y agoThanks for framing the issue more succinctly. Yes the issue is removing agency from people coated in the sweet nectar of convenience.