4 ms·
Well, it is about "restoring internet freedom". It's just that, except in a few large cities, Americans have very little choice about ISP. So there's no way for
by mirimir 9y ago
Well, it is about "restoring internet freedom". It's just that, except in a few large cities, Americans have very little choice about ISP. So there's no way for ISPs to compete for users who care about net neutrality.
Edit: Actually, we'd have even more freedom with an Internet version of the FERC rule for open access to electrical transmission lines.[0]
> The legal and policy cornerstone of these rules is to remedy undue discrimination in access to the monopoly owned transmission wires that control whether and to whom electricity can be transported in interstate commerce.
0) https://www.ferc.gov/legal/maj-ord-reg/land-docs/rm95-8-00w.txt https://www.ferc.gov/legal/maj-ord-reg/land-docs/rm95-8-00w....
- mch82 9y agoWhat's your definition of freedom?
- mirimir 9y agoBeing unconstrained.
- lawnchair_larry 9y agoSo you’d obviously want to ensure net neutrality then?
- donatj 9y agoNet neutrality is literally constraint on how data passing through networks can be routed and shaped. It’s exactly “constraining the Internet”. It’s not “freedom” in any shape or matter. Freedom is never constraint on others. It’s a popular constraint, and people just happen to confuse and conflate “things I like/feel positivity about” and “freedom”. It’s controversial to say here but I don’t think it gets discussed enough: Net neutrality only really helps established players. That is not to say it hurts others, but it certainly helps established players. That’s why they all love it. Facebook, Hulu, Netflix, GitHub, Tumblr, Microsoft. Unestablished unpopular players are not the ones getting throttled. It’s the ones already using tons of bandwidth getting throttled and odds are good most new players bandwidth usage is hardly even noticeable to the ISP. They wouldn’t be touting the joys of something that had the potential to displace them. The one who would be getting throttled is primarily Netflix, who literally uses over half of the bandwidth of the Internet. Literally slows everything else on the Internet down. Netflix doesn’t want to be throttled, so of course they love net neutrality. I’m not saying net neutrality is inherently bad, I just don’t think it’s as innately good as a lot of the cheerleaders attest.
- pfisch 9y agoWhen att makes it free to use their video service and not free to use everything else, that hurts unestablished players. Net neutrality also helps users. Do I really need to explain how?
- donatj 9y agoIt’s not as clear cut as “it helps users”. There are positives and negatives for users as there are in all things in life; nothing is black and white. Firstly I would hardly call demanding the end of free services on moral grounds “helping users”. As far as the end user cares, forcing them to pay for all services equally when they could previously get one for free is a net harm. The bigger problem however is that internet has been running largely at full bandwidth capacity since mid 2015, particularly the backbone. Bandwidth is being devoured faster than it is being added. Not being able to limit major hogs, namely streaming services, in favor of other smaller and potentially more important connections actually harms users with slower overall response time for the internet at large. I personally think things like medical/government services and online banking traffic getting priority over entertainment is not that controversial - but not allowed under net neutrality. It’s not as clear cut as people think.
- skate22 9y agoAverage connection speed has been steadily increasing for over a decade. I dont like the idea of a risky solution to a non problem. I spend most of my time on the internet & I have one provider to "choose" from in my area. https://www.statista.com/statistics/616210/average-internet-connection-speed-in-the-us/#0 https://www.statista.com/statistics/616210/average-internet-...
- jordigh 9y ago> Freedom is never constraint on others Of course it is, you have to constrain the powerful so they cannot take freedom away from the dispossessed. You have to restrict the freedom of Southern plantation owners to own slaves to ensure the freedom of slaves. You have to restrict the freedom of corporations to merge into a giant conglomerate so you can protect the freedom of choice of consumers. You have to restrict the freedom of corporations to charge for the origin of internet traffic so you can protect the freedom of internet users to visit any site they wish. Freedom in society is always an exchange and a compromise. Your freedom to swing your fist ends five centimetres away from my nose.
- nl 9y agoThis goes to the heart of the matter. Is freedom to build whatever you want without having to pay gatekeepers important or is freedom from rules important?