4 ms·
Hacks Into Hackers
- dmor 16y agoimagine the increased quality of news coverage for technical products if more journalists could code, it would be awesome and they could validate firsthand a lot of things that have be fed to them by PR agencies (who also struggle a ton, and would benefit from being more technical)
- lachyg 16y agoInteresting article, and a great concept. I'd imagine that reporters / journos would be quite adept with technology, but I wonder if a lot of them have the ability to be good hackers / programmers. It sounds like their professor has two very complimentary skills.
- LeBlanc 16y agoThis same logic could apply to everyone; everyone should be hackers. I really believe we should be educating middle and high school kids about how to use computers for more than the internet and document processing. Given the way computers and the internet are everywhere and are used for so much, computer use / programming / scripting should be a required class like history and science are.
- kiba 16y agoI thought of "hacker academy" to teach kids how to hack electronic and computers to do really cool stuff. There could be classes in automotive hacking, welding, electrical engineering, programming, and a full battery liberal education program oriented around hacking. So half would be centered around epistemic/instrumental rationality and science, and another half is engineering.
- lachyg 16y agoTotally agree, it would enhance all other classes; being able to create maths applications, filtering through historical data, the list is pretty much endless.
- TGJ 16y agoI had a teacher tell me that math classes in the future will not contain more math, but instead computer classes to learn how to get computers to do the math for us.
- edanm 16y agoCompletely disagree. That's like saying mechanics classes should be required, since everyone has a car and other machines. Most people can't, or are incredibly not interested, in being at the level of even simple scripting. There is only one solution to letting more people do more things with computers: make things easier. Things that were once impossible are now incredibly easy for a lot of people, because interfaces are getting better all the time. That's the way to get more people comfortable with computers, not forcing them to spend time learning a skill they're not going to learn anyway. And as a nice side bonus, making interfaces easier to use ends up saving everyone time, even people who are technically inclined, and makes much cooler things possible. So everyone comes out a winner.
- avar 16y agoThat analogy doesn't hold up. If you learn mechanics you can repair and maintain your car, and even build a new one. But you'll never get your car to drive your kids to school without you sitting behind the wheel. But you can do the equivalent of that if you're programming literate. We're moving to a digital culture, and if you don't know how to program you'll increasingly only become a consumer of other people's solutions, without the ability to solve your own problems. Some people are calling this "procedural literacy". As an aside I'd argue that computer interfaces have actually gotten somewhat worse while getting more friendly to newcomers. I think the last major leap in computer interfaces was cron(1). Unlike most modern interfaces being produced today you can use it to tell your computer to produce periodic reports and things like that. That's where we should be headed with UI's, not aiming to have a monkey banging at the terminal at all times, but giving the monkey the ability to dictate things to the computer so he doesn't have to bang at the terminal. Real computing power is being able to say: "Computer, I'm feeling under the weather today and I think I'll sleep in. At 9am please start playing 'Daddy's sick, get up and go to school!' on a loop in the kid's bedroom at 75 dB, and continue producing noise until they get out the door, engage!". You can implement those sorts of things if you're a programmer.
- jonsen 16y agoThere sure is some truth in that procedural awareness should be higher. But I think the analogy holds. You should not teach mechanics, but you should teach natural sciences in a way that principles are transferable to mechanics, and to building, and to a lot of other things. I think it's deeply wrong to try and raise procedural awareness by forcing the technicalities of state of the art programming on the common man. You should find a way to teach algorithmic principles so that they are generally applicable.
- cperciva 16y agoQuoth the article: People used the left elevator more than the right one This makes me wonder: Did people choose the left elevator; or was there a single-elevator-call button which they pressed, upon which the elevator-control program preferentially dispatched the left elevator? I wouldn't be surprised if the elevator-control program always handled the situation with two equally close available elevators by dispatching elevator #1 rather than elevator #2. Is anyone here familiar with the Tisch School of the Arts?
- thristian 16y agoThe office building I work in has three elevators; my observation has been that when I call an elevator at high-traffic times such as lunch-time or 5PM I might get any elevator while at lower-traffic times I tend to be allocated the left or middle elevator. My mental model is that an elevator with scheduled destinations (buttons pressed inside) is 'allocated' and an elevator travelling to service a call is 'allocated', while other elevators are 'free'. If you press 'down' and there are no elevators above you going down, or if you press 'up' and there are no elevators below you going up, the left-most free elevator will be dispatched. It makes sense to wear out elevators unevenly: If two or more elevators were evenly used, it's more likely they'd break down at the same time, leaving your building with no elevators at all.
- agentultra 16y agoThe Knight News Foundation has been trying to stimulate this market for hybrid programmer/journos for years. I think it's a great idea. Too many stories have gone to print without any facts to back them up. Many more haven't even been reported because nobody has the skill to discover them. The Foundation is funding a sector that the industry has been largely ignoring much to its detriment. Most of the information out there is largely electronic. The volumes of it are too much to handle by a single human. Why not use a computer to parse, munge, and analyze it?
- bdon 16y agoThe Medill School of Journalism at Northwestern offers a scholarship with goals similar to the new program at Columbia: http://www.medill.northwestern.edu/admissions/page.aspx?id=58645 http://www.medill.northwestern.edu/admissions/page.aspx?id=5...
- gabrielroth 16y agoAm I the only one who was struck by the unqualified use, in a general-audience publication, of 'hacker' to mean 'programmer' rather than 'one who breaks into other people's computers over a network'?
- zwetan 16y agoa "hacker" is closer to a programmer that think "out of the box" than to a "cracker" that "breaks into other people computers" the media has given this defintion to the word "hacker" and I always rejected it!
- whimsy 16y agoYes, but it's rare seeing it used in the media as we use it outside the media.
- SkyMarshal 16y agoThat was his point. The MSM generally uses your cracker definition for hacker, but here's an article actually using your first definition. Signs and wonders...
- otrooso 16y agoThe elevator fallacy follows. If you put a lot of sensors in a city you find many weird things, as there is not a prior hypothesis about what you are testing what you see as weird is not so much. In order to say that "people use the left elevator more than the right one" you should start a new experiment for testing it not using your data for making the hypothesis.
- danohuiginn 16y agoTrue, but it's no worse than traditional journalism based on press releases or people you meet.