8 ms·
This article is making strategies out of tactics. For example, Gmail's new autocomplete apparently helps people write email faster. It doesn't write the email
by skybrian 9y ago
This article is making strategies out of tactics.
For example, Gmail's new autocomplete apparently helps people write email faster. It doesn't write the email for you. Why isn't that a bicycle for the mind? It's partially helping you do something you could do anyway, but faster. (And maybe better, if you're still learning English?)
Maybe someday, for some emails, Gmail will be able to ghostwrite the entire body of an email for you? But that's just a matter of technical competence, not a change in strategy. Tech companies will change tactics based on what's feasible.
But maybe the big change is when you let the machine take full, mostly-unattended responsibility where safety is on the line (real driverless cars).
- hyperpallium 9y agoYeah, automation vs. amplification is a perennial issue, not sure it maps that well to companies. The difference is control, whether the task is sufficiently predictable and well-understood. Similar to how much of a task can be hidden behind an API - the specific usage determines acceptable performance metrics. autocomplete/suggest is a T9/Clippy offspring, the latter by MS, and closer to automation. BTW: to be fair, when Steve Jobs demoed the iPhone, he used it to prank a cafe for 2000 lattes. Whereas Google pranked a business automatically.
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> automation vs. amplification is a perennial issue How is that even a difference? Amplification is done by automating subcomponents of what you're trying to do. If you automate away the entire task, it means you amplify the human working one level up.