3 ms·
I don't have an amazon link for you, but it doesn't seem that magical to me? Submarines have had inertial nav for decades. This is a simpler problem, because tr
by jessaustin 9y ago
I don't have an amazon link for you, but it doesn't seem that magical to me? Submarines have had inertial nav for decades. This is a simpler problem, because travel is restricted to rails and drift can be corrected as often as necessary. Every airbag in every automobile is equipped with a very accurate fairly inexpensive MEMS acceleration sensor, which would the only specialized component required for such a system. Hobbyist components like the ADXL345 are also cheap. It wouldn't surprise me if such a system already exists for e.g. tracking underground mining equipment, but if not it wouldn't be an impossible task for an organization with the budget of MTA. It's not as though the system would need to be incredibly precise; it's replacing one that at its best can only measure average speed over some huge distance.
- gamblor956 9y agoSubmarines also need to surface periodically to verify their navigational position as dead reckoning is frequently off by a margin. Airbags are equipped with acceleration sensors that have a very simple test: is the acceleration force greater than X? If so, deploy! The point of the system is to have a system that is accurate enough to replace the current system, which neither of your solutions achieves.
- jessaustin 9y agoYeah that's what's meant by "drift". Submarines correct every few thousand nautical miles. The hypothetical device could do so at every station. The current system is not accurate at all, and even if it were is quite imprecise by design. But you've convinced me. A much better solution would just be a camera pointed at the speedometer.