4 ms·
Interesting that popular perception is that it is hard to be a woman in STEM because you get so much unwanted attention, but in this case it was exactly the opp
by jandrese 9y ago
Interesting that popular perception is that it is hard to be a woman in STEM because you get so much unwanted attention, but in this case it was exactly the opposite. She wasn't able to find lab partners for projects in male majority classes and felt lonely.
- throwaway84742 9y agoI just don’t see how that could be. When I was studying, we had 2 girls in a peer group of roughly 90 people. All they had to do to find a lab partner is have a pulse. Interestingly, both have graduated, and neither is using her degree now.
- slimshady94 9y agoWhat is this phenomenon called? I've seen it plenty of times; there must be some research etc on this.
- throwaway84742 9y agoThe word you’re looking for is “chivalry”. An outmoded concept in these modern times, but alive and well back then.
- chrisseaton 9y ago> I just don’t see how that could be. I'm not sure what you mean? Why would the women be inherently attractive as lab partners? Many men in the lab would probably think that the women would be weaker, or wouldn't know how to interact with them, so wouldn't want them as lab partners. And the men may have a higher chance of knowing each other already from outside the class in sports teams and fraternities, so they would team up with people they already know rather than someone they didn't.
- throwaway84742 9y agoWhy would they be “weaker”? I don’t get what you’re trying to say.
- chrisseaton 9y agoI don't think they would be weaker - where do you think I said I thought that? But lots of men definitely do think women are likely to be weaker in computer science. I don't know why they think that - you'd have to ask them?
- always_good 9y agoBut you're making the claim that men think that. You can't just pass the buck to your own premise with "dunno, you'll have to ask them."
- chrisseaton 9y ago> You can't just pass the buck to your own premise with "dunno, you'll have to ask them." Yes I can. It's completely reasonable to be observe something even if you can't offer an explanation. I don't know why some people are racist but I can see that they are. I don't know why some people are sexist but I can see that they are. I don't know why some people think women are inherently weaker at computer science, but I can see that they do think that by what they say and do.
- leshow 9y agoWe have no evidence that people do think that though. I have never heard that women are 'weaker' in computer science than men. My guess is most people think that competence in computer science is independent of sex. If you're presenting that they don't, where is that information coming from?
- chrisseaton 9y ago> My guess is most people think that competence in computer science is independent of sex. I don't know how to break this to you... but a lot of people in this world unfortunately discriminate against people based on gender, either consciously or unconsciously. > where is that information coming from To give you a concrete example, I was at a conference just recently where the speaker took questions from the audience and when a man asked a question the answer was highly technical, and when a woman asked a similar question the answer was patronising and non-technical as if he thought the woman wouldn't understand like the men did. It was really obvious, and there was no other variable. I see this kind of thing all the time. I don't know what more to tell you - if you can't see any evidence of men making assumptions that a women isn't going to be as competent in computer science just based on her gender then I think you must be blind to what is happening around you.
- princekolt 9y agoI have a hard time believing your anecdotal data point about a third person is enough to claim a person exposing their own experiences is wrong.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- rectang 9y ago> All they had to do to find a lab partner is have a pulse. Eh, that sounds a bit like those lab partners may have had dubious motivations. I figure it's on those of us who strive for the highest degree of professionalism to take the lead on inclusion.
- smsm42 9y agoSo, summarizing the comments here: A: Dudes, go befriend a girl, include her! It's not creepy! B: My anecdata experience suggests girls in my lab, where they were in minority, had no problem being included if they wished to, dudes were very eager to do it. C: Motivations of those dudes sound very dubious and creepy! Yup, yup.
- mikeash 9y agoYou left out the creepy “have a pulse” part.
- throwaway84742 9y agoNo, creepiness exists in your mind only. Believe it or not, we valued the fact that those women were there and we tried to help them out in whatever way we could. My field of study back then (guidance systems, weapons design) is even more male dominated than CS. All male peer groups are not a fun thing to be in. To preclude the question, yes those girls did get asked for a date every now and then. If that’s wrong, I don’t want to be right.
- mikeash 9y agoI read “have a pulse” as “it doesn’t matter how qualified or pleasant these women were, the men were eager to have any contact with a woman and would have taken them on just for that.” Does it mean something else?
- throwaway84742 9y ago
- Rotdhizon 9y agoAlso notice that even though she had the option, she didn't approach anyone to try an secure a lab partner. She posted her own position opening and waited until all spots were taken. She could very well have clicked on anyones post and that would have been the end of it.
- as1mov 9y agoThis seems to be a common symptom in most of these 'women-in-tech' articles. Each one of them has advice for men who are in the industry, but never for any women trying to get into it.
- peoplewindow 9y agoBecause the idea that gender disparities are due to the choices men and women make is some sort of ideologically impure heretical thought, for some reason. If it's not to do with oppression/awful men then where's the fun? Where's the virtue in fighting for it?
- jandrese 9y agoOr if you generalize it all the way, the advice is "men should be more like women" but never "women should be more like men".
- Jach 9y agoYeah, this is what bugs me with the advice to "Go befriend a girl". How about they come and befriend me? Like with dating, there's the expectation that the men need to make the first move. (Whatever, it's not necessarily a bad expectation, but when it's implicit like this I'm not always sure it was intentional...) Of course in the friend case I think it's more of a function of your local environment than anything else. At the same company I've experienced a large difference in the local atmosphere between the Seattle and Vancouver offices, the Vancouver office was quite a bit more welcoming and more people would randomly introduce themselves.
- TACIXAT 9y ago
- rectang 9y agoThere are lots of opportunities for outreach, if you look for them. From the article: "Include her, ask her for advice, introduce her, learn about her work and her life in the same way you would with any male friend or coworker. If you’re an investor, professor, journalist, or manager, take it on yourself to sponsor a young woman’s career." I've done a number of those things over many years, and found it very rewarding -- both in the interactions with my individual colleagues, and in how it affected the wider teams.
- kazinator 9y agoMaybe the chilling effect of several decades of gender politics put a damper on the unwanted attention. Boys are hammered with messages about sexual misconduct, and so even ones without any such intentions want to avoid the mere perception that anything is going on.
- saint_fiasco 9y agoIt puts a damper on attention in general, but the attention that is less dampened is precisely the unwanted attention. Think about it. A considerate well intentioned person might mistakenly overcompensate and give too little attention to female colleagues, while an inconsiderate person who doesn't care about gender politics will keep doing what they were doing all along. The result is that the ratio of unwanted/wanted attention goes up, even as total attention goes down. This general principle is called "the asshole filter"[1] and it applies to all sorts of social interactions, not just sexual harassment. [1]http://siderea.livejournal.com/1230660.html http://siderea.livejournal.com/1230660.html
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jrs95 9y agoA lot of us probably wouldn't immediately approach a woman in this situation because we don't want to be perceived as being "creepy". In professional settings I generally keep my distance until I've had enough brief casual interactions with someone that they seem comfortable enough with me not to assume something like that. Do I seem like I'm being a dick sometimes? Maybe, but I'm just genuinely trying not to make people uncomfortable (although in part because I've definitely got a bit of social anxiety).
- cimmanom 9y agoOr maybe it's just that you don't get normal human "let's hang out and shoot the shit" or "let's work on this together" interaction; and the attention you do get is disproportionately (and awkwardly) sexual or romantic "I like ogling your boobs" and "I won't stop asking until you agree to go on a date with me" interaction?