6 ms·
We live in a society where all the actors in the system need to virtue signal about how much they care about safety, usefulness of the system be damned. That's
by dsfyu404ed 9y ago
We live in a society where all the actors in the system need to virtue signal about how much they care about safety, usefulness of the system be damned. That's why the draconian speed limit policy in the first place.
The union wants the trains to go slow so they can say they're fighting for policies that protect workers. The MTA wants signal enforced speed limits so they can say they're preventing crashes.
If we could just have an adult discussion about the damage of marginally (if at all) increased risk compared to the benefits of a more functional subway system this wouldn't be as big of a problem.
This isn't even a resources issue, changing policy is close to free.
- gamblor956 9y agoThe union wants the trains to go slow so they can say they're fighting for policies that protect workers. Have you ever performed maintenance literally inches from a train going 40mph? The union has valid safety concerns for wanting trains to slow down in the vicinity of workers, and this particular safety measure only applies to late-night routes when they are performing maintenance on closed lines that share tracks with operating lines. The problem is that the MTA introduced a number of other "safety" measures that did nothing to affect the safety of workers or employees, such as increasing the distance between cars or introducing speed-limiting signals, and these other measures apply 24-7.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoTrains don't need humans to steer them and the humans there are being paid to (presumably) operate them safely. Cops and tow truck drivers have more exposure to worse traffic going faster for less pay and nobody is in a hurry to bring back the national speed limit. I'd take working on tracks over changing someone's tire on the side of the highway.
- bobthepanda 9y agoTrains also have really long braking distances. If you can see a track worker in the way, it's already too late. Hence the declaration of these work zones. In my areas, they usually close a lane next to the accident in addition to the lane where the accident occurred. This is basically the exact same thing.
- slededit 9y agoThey close an entire highway lane for the towtruck moving a stalled car off the shoulder? Not all towtruck work is related to accidents, in fact most of it isn't.
- dmckeon 9y agoMany US states require drivers to move over, leaving an empty lane next to emergency workers. Specific state laws vary for law enforcement, fire and emergency medical, highway workers, tow truck operators, and disabled vehicles, but while all states appear to at least nominally require moving over for law enforcement. California does not seem to notify drivers on the road much, but other western states do notify/advertise much more, and Indiana and Ohio are fairly vehement about it. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Move_over_law#In_the_United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Move_over_law#In_the_United_...
- fusiongyro 9y agoI imagine if it were my job to perform maintenance inches from a train going 40mph, I would grow accustomed to it before long. While we're at it, feeling safe and being safe aren't the same thing.
- crocal 9y agoAnd ‘tis why it’s super dangerous...
- fusiongyro 9y agoEvery time I drive my feet are mere inches from a roaring engine that works by exploding toxic fuel, reaching temperatures high enough to give third degree burns, other cars flying past mine in the opposite direction with a combined speed difference of 60 to 150mph. Clearly we need to change the way cars are laid out so that there are ten additional feet between my gas pedal and my engine and an additional thirty feet between cars going opposite directions. For safety.
- crocal 9y agoYou are not conscious of this, but your car certifications, the driving rules and the road design constraints precisely achieved that, after now nearly 100 years of continuous trial and error. And it will not stop.
- fusiongyro 9y agoMy point is that it is easy to make safe things sound dangerous using first-principles arguments absent any in-depth knowledge of the actual situation.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> The union wants the trains to go slow so they can say they're fighting for policies that protect workers If it results in increased funding, for problems mistakenly blamed on overcrowding, that can result in more money for the union leadership, too.