13 ms·
Sounds like there could be large benefit from A) removing the punishment for tripping the signal, that causes drivers to go extra extra slow (well under safe an
by jrochkind1 9y ago
Sounds like there could be large benefit from A) removing the punishment for tripping the signal, that causes drivers to go extra extra slow (well under safe and officially regulated speed) cause they know there are faulty unpredictable signals which they'll still get punished for tripping; and B) fixing faulty signals (which they probably don't even know about when all the drivers are slowing down so much in case of faulty signal that they don't even know which ones are faulty).
Contrary to the article saying "And there’s no easy fix", it seems like this would be a fairly easy fix?
- WhompingWindows 9y agoWon't you have to convince the union to do this change? They seem particularly intractable from my outsider's POV. If they accept culpability here and make one change, maybe they would consider that as bending and inviting future concessions. It's a shame that overall efficiency and rider satisfaction count for much less to the union than their own politics.
- rohansingh 9y agoFrom a moral standpoint, it's definitely wrong to punish drivers for signal issues, and we should stop doing that. However, if drivers all started going at the normal speed and regularly tripping broken signals, it would absolutely destroy the system. When a train's emergency brake is tripped, it takes tens of minutes to reset it and get the train going again. If that was happening at every faulty signal on a daily basis, the system would grind to a halt. Really the only fix is dealing with the signals. But that's extremely difficult because they haven't been regularly maintained and are very old. Most of them use mechanical timing systems and other insane things that nobody has built parts for. There's no particular reason to believe that "changing them back" would go any better than the botched rollout of the initial change.
- jrochkind1 9y agoAh, I see your point, yes, thanks.
- bluGill 9y agoSometimes if something is hard you should do it more often so you get good at it. That is workers should be rewarded if they trip a system and after investigation it is proven the system was wrong. That worked just found a real bug and it needs to be fixed.
- gamblor956 9y agoContrary to the article saying "And there’s no easy fix", it seems like this would be a fairly easy fix? It's a very easy fix. The problem is that it's a very time-consuming and expensive fix to repair and/or replace all the signals. (Doing A doesn't accomplish much since the faulty signals will automatically slow down the trains anyway, and then impose an additional delay while the train's brakes are reset.)
- nisa 9y ago> The problem is that it's a very time-consuming and expensive fix to repair and/or replace all the signals. There must be some period of time with low traffic - put a few managers and signal-guys in the train and rock the line at maybe +5% of regular advertised speed. Count where and how often the train stops. Fix that. Do that for all lines. Honestly if that is the real problem that would probably take them a few weeks at most.
- jrochkind1 9y agoIt sounds like the signals may not really be _fixable_, from rohansingh's comment nearby. They are very old fully mechanical devices, you could send someone around to reset them, but there's no guarantee the reset would actually _work_, they might remain unpredictable. After all the problem is that they _tried_ to set them to a new value, and it didn't work. Perhaps they were working fine in the same configuration they were in for decades, but once they were touched to change the settings, they are just entirely unreliable. I dunno, but ancient mechanical parts can be like that.
- nisa 9y agoWe are talking millions of dollars. There must be someone who can figure that out - even if the failure is kind of random it follows probably a distribution and you can set it to a value that has enough margin to stop the train and not trip on slower trains. But you are right - easy to look and comment from the outside, there is probably a reason it is how it is.
- untog 9y ago"fix the faulty signals" is not an easy fix - it's something the MTA has been trying to do for a very long time, and taking forever to do it. The reasons are systemic. They need to be fixed, but they won't be easy.
- jrochkind1 9y agoYeah, I guess that's so. I want a followup article explaining why it's so hard to fix the signals, the OP didn't really go into it, heh.