7 ms·
Those were speculative investments, not bank accounts. Nobody lost money in an FDIC insured account. The comparison is also dubious for another reason: everyon
by acdha 9y ago
Those were speculative investments, not bank accounts. Nobody lost money in an FDIC insured account.
The comparison is also dubious for another reason: everyone who did even the tiniest bit of diligence knew the mortgage and derivative markets were in a huge bubble. Phrases like “liar loan” were common, they had to invent new ways to rate derivatives which didn’t meet the traditional standards, etc. but so many people were banking on the greater fool theory lasting long enough for them to cash out before it popped. All the crash proved was that the traditional banking standards were there for a reason and the people who never abandoned them were fine.
This is relevant in the Bitcoin discussion because we see the same dynamic where people who pay attention to the fundamentals are saying it’s a bubble and the get rich quick crowd is saying that the rules are completely different now because magic.
- imgabe 9y agoIt is relevant because the mantra of "traditional financial institutions have your best interests at heart, unlike those Bitcoin scammers" is demonstrably false.
- acdha 9y agoThat’s a rather blatant strawman: it’s literally a textbook example of the value of regulation and laws which make that happen, not the goodwill of bankers.
- imgabe 9y agoYou mean the laws and regulations written by lobbyists paid by the bankers? Do you mean the regulators who leave their Federal jobs for multi-million dollar per year jobs at the banks they formerly regulated? Are those the ones you're talking about? You seem to be implying that the regulations / laws and the banks are two separate entities. They're increasingly the same. Which means that yes, it is basically their goodwill we're dependent on, or more accurately how much they think they can get away with before there's literal blood in the streets.
- emodendroket 9y agoAnd you think all the problems with banks would go away if they simply operated without any regulation at all?
- imgabe 9y agoWhen did I say that? I think at the highest levels they already do operate without any regulation. When you get to write your own regulations and there's a revolving door between the regulatory agencies and the companies they're suppose to regulate, there is no meaningful regulation. Bitcoin and other digital currencies are a threat to them because there is no central agency in charge of it that they can infiltrate and control the way the have with government-run currencies. At least, they haven't found a way to control and manipulate it, yet.
- emodendroket 9y agoInstead you just get people losing their shirts to old-fashioned scams that were made illegal a century ago, with no recourse whatsoever.
- imgabe 9y agoPeople are always losing money to old-fashioned scams, regardless of currency. It's a lot easier to learn about and protect yourself from simple, hundred year old scams than the brand new, never before seen scams the financial industry comes up with.
- mr_spothawk 9y agowrt old-fashioned scams in my sibling's comment... they've been around much longer than they've been outlawed for. arguably, we would have better herd-immunity to them if we'd never outlawed them in the first case. yes, there's no recourse to losing your BTC. it's a good thing you were only playing around, or you'd be really screwed. if you mortgaged your house, well... that wasn't very smart was it. I'm sure you won't make that mistake again, and I think/hope we as a society/culture can work to help you recover from that. whatever the case, if you lose your money/btc/shirt the banks won't be much help to you.
- mkirklions 9y ago>the rules are completely different now because magic. Currency that isnt controlled by any government is different. Previously that was limited to gold only. Gold was hard to move and expensive to keep safe. Bitcoin can be sent for free using exchanges or on a piece of paper or about 1000 other ways. Easy to move gold is almost magic.
- acdha 9y ago> Bitcoin can be sent for free using exchanges or on a piece of paper or about 1000 other ways. What about the transaction fees? Someone has to pay for all of the mining hardware and electricity.
- mkirklions 9y agoYou dont need to use on-chain for bitcoin transactions.
- acdha 9y agoSo we’re back to using a federated model with most people using trusted third parties and hoping there are enough laws and regulatory oversight to prevent them from abusing that trust? This sounds oddly familiar…
- mkirklions 9y agoFor 2 dollar transactions at Taco Bell and giving petty money to friends? But even if we are back to that model, it still uses ultra rare BTC where there are 21,000,000 BTC ever ever ever. The US currency just keeps inflating.
- chiph 9y ago> Nobody lost money in an FDIC insured account. This is true for you & I. But the wealthy aren't concerned about the FDIC insurance as their balances are far in excess of what would be covered by it. They follow the health of a bank very closely as they stand to lose a great deal of money if it becomes insolvent. Many people think what prompted the sale of Wachovia to first Citibank (briefly .. sort of) then Wells Fargo for $15.1 billion [0] in October of 2008 was the implosion of their MBS holdings in their Golden West Financial acquisition. If you recall, Golden West had the "Pick a Pay" program, where borrowers could decide how much their mortgage payment would be (potentially even less than the interest portion, where the remaining amount was lumped back in to the balance) What really happened was the wealthy depositors in Wachovia got wind that the bank was in trouble and initiated massive withdrawals, causing a run on the bank. If the sale to WF hadn't happened that weekend and restored confidence in the bank, Wachovia would likely have not opened their doors on the following Tuesday. Source: coworkers who were there at the time. [0] https://dealbook.nytimes.com/2008/10/03/wells-fargo-to-merge-with-wachovia/ https://dealbook.nytimes.com/2008/10/03/wells-fargo-to-merge...