5 ms·
According to its proponents, Bitcoin is digital gold. (Interestingly it’s not an “electronic currency” anymore even though that was the original title of the 20
by pavlov 9y ago
According to its proponents, Bitcoin is digital gold. (Interestingly it’s not an “electronic currency” anymore even though that was the original title of the 2008 whitepaper. I suppose Lightning Network or something is supposed to fix that with new transaction layers backed by the Bitcoin gold.)
One aspect of gold’s historical value is that it’s traditionally recognized even in societies in collapse. I’ve never understood how Bitcoin is supposed to hold its value in such an event — something on the scale of nuclear war, or Germany in 1945.
After an EMP wipes out data centers and cell phone towers, you can probably still bribe people with Krugerrands. Who’s going to accept Bitcoin transfers when the infrastructure is either gone or under military control?
Or is the idea that Bitcoin will be valuable again when the wealthy finally crawl out of their New Zealand bunkers and reestablish the financial system?
- wyldfire 9y ago> Or is the idea that Bitcoin will be valuable again when the wealthy finally crawl out of their New Zealand bunkers and reestablish the financial system? The idea is that the transactions are irreversible and you cannot rely on any number of police officers or judges to fix a theft. The bunkers are for security's sake, not preserving-wealth-in-an-apocalype's sake.
- pavlov 9y agoThe police officers and judges can put you in jail, which is generally worse than having your assets confiscated. I’m not sure how Bitcoin helps. What I’m trying to understand is how Bitcoin advocates’ promise of it being a store of value independent from governments can be valid when the system depends on extremely sophisticated infrastructure that was built and enabled by governments.
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> the system depends on extremely sophisticated infrastructure that was built and enabled by governments. ... and which continued existence and operation requires stable governments keeping most of the planet bound by the rule of law.
- laglad 9y agoYour points are valid. IMO the key tradeoff b/w gold (analog) and bitcoin (digital) is extra resiliency vs usability. If there were a systemic collapse breaking governments, knocking off power and telecom networks etc, gold would be immediately most valuable. But more quickly than fiat, bitcoin would be useful. Power and telecom systems are more resilient to systemic collapse (& have more bouncebackability) than a functioning government and its currency. Some semblance of critical systems would come online whether put up by government, armies, warlords, cooperatives etc (See Somalia as an example). When those systems are online, bitcoin can be sent and received. In short: in terms of usability: Fiat > Bitcoin > Gold in terms of resilience: Gold > Bitcoin > Fiat Am I missing anything here?
- gwbas1c 9y agoPaper currency is often used after the government backing it collapses.
- mywittyname 9y agoNot only that, people will use anything as currency in the absence of fiat. Cigarettes, tea bags, polished rocks, etc.
- mikeash 9y agoAre miners still going to be operating in this post-collapse environment?
- blocked_again 9y agoWhoever operates is going to become rich. So someone will step up to satisfy the need.
- mikeash 9y agoYou need a hash rate at least vaguely close to the pre-collapse hash rate, or else the network will grind to a halt. Will they be physically capable of that?
- masklinn 9y ago> According to its proponents, Bitcoin is digital gold. According to its detractor, Bitcoin is digital comedy gold, so everybody agrees.
- Geee 9y agoAnd that is why Bitcoin is designed against these kinds of events. It's very unlikely that everything would be wiped out or everything would be under military control. There's always strong economic incentives to keep it running and secure.
- anjc 9y agoIf you're concerned about an EMP wiping out electronics systems worldwide then surely it'd be smarter to horde weapons, food and antibiotics, than Bitcoin OR gold.
- deevolution 9y agoYoure basing your argument on the assumption that ALL datacenters have been wiped out. Its unlikely the entire world will engage in global warfare on a scale large enough to disable the internet, which the bitcoin network relies upon. Also, historically government currencies destabalize during war, so bitcoin would probably retain or increase in value, not diminish.
- 21 9y ago> After an EMP wipes out data centers and cell phone towers If such a thing happens on a large scale there will be hundred of millions of deaths. All major cities will simply collapse. See recent articles how London can only survive for 4 days without electricity, after that there will be no food. The modern society is incredibly fragile. Everything is just in time, there are no stocks or buffers. Bitcoins will be the least of your worries in such an event. Your Krugerrands will also not be of much value. Nobody will be stupid to give you food or gas for a piece of metal.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoYes. Exactly. That's why more and more people getting involved in scams and get-rich-schemes on a platform with superlinear and unbounded energy upkeep is something that worries me deeply. Energy and climate is something that very well may break our society.
- titzer 9y ago> Energy and climate is something that very well may break our society. Unfortunately, if you run almost any process that humans are doing right now that has even 1% growth, in 1000 years, that's a factor of 21000x (.5% is 146x), and we're dead. So pretty much everything has to reach an S curve and stabilize, or we are totally F'd. Population, energy usage, land usage, food, trash, inflation, everything.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThat's another reason to invest in space exploration :). But yes, we should be minimizing wasteful growth where we can. Food will have to grow in lockstep with population, but the growth of trash is something we can reduce. And there's especially no need to add artificial high-growth energy sinks like cryptocurrencies to the mix.
- 013a 9y agoI really think this opinion is short-sighted. And it comes from a less extreme version of the same place that 9/11 deniers operate from; normal humans don't want to naturally think about loss of control and what that loss of control would look like. So its easier to just say "if this happens we're all fucked, don't even try" There is practically no evidence in history where gold had fungible value then became worthless. Nothing else matters; everything else is conjecture, opinion, and extrapolation. Yes, we live in a very fragile society. Yes, if complete collapse happened, there would be a period of extreme chaos when millions, hundreds of millions, die. But the chaos would stabilize, barring any extenuating factors like a T-Virus. And in that world, maybe US Dollars would still hold some value. History says Gold probably will. Bitcoin though? Bitcoin requires a global network of miners. It would require having access to the original blockchain that gives your wallet value. In the best likelihood, the currency would splinter into every small network that can still run miners. And when energy is so expensive that you need all of it to power your lights, vehicles, and medical equipment, why would anyone spend it on an expensive mining rig, even if all the complex computer equipment necessary to make it run were widely available? And then a guy walks into town with a bag full of gold. Suddenly Bitcoin isn't looking all that valuable as a currency. I'll sell my extra food to the guy with the gold, because the guy with antibiotics down the street would also sell to the guy with the gold, and the guy in the town over with car parts would also sell to the guy with the gold. That's what makes currency work; people, not software.