2 ms·
I hate the graybeard need to say $NEW_THING is actually $OLD_THING but with a silly name because these silly kids don't know anything new, while both glossing o
by pc86 9y ago
I hate the graybeard need to say $NEW_THING is actually $OLD_THING but with a silly name because these silly kids don't know anything new, while both glossing over the bleak hellscape of $OLD_THING (WCF service development, anyone?) while grossly misunderstanding $NEW_THING.
As other have pointed out he's ignoring key failings of SOA and critical differences between SOA and microservices.
Overall I like the article but I think he's misstating a few key things.
And maybe a nitpick but:
> It lends itself to the Continuous Integration/Continuous Deployment (CI/CD) model of developing large, complex applications.
Really? Because I thought CICD was the standard way to deploy any application more complex than a spike or proof of concept (which probably doesn't need to be deployed anyway).
- Clubber 9y ago>As other have pointed out he's ignoring key failings of SOA and critical differences between SOA and microservices. Can you describe the fundamental differences?
- arcbyte 9y agoThe thing you're missing though is that as $NEW_THINGs get more popular and more people try to implement them, they do it badly, spread their bad implementation as gospel, and that actually changes the popular definition into something barely recognizable that becomes $OLD_THING. A few smart non-graybeards eventually play around with $OLD_THING enough that they actually stumble upon the original definition of it, but don't realize that they are really just rediscovering the original definition. So of course they (re)name their discovery as the next $NEW_THING. Then cue the graybeards. SOA is really just object oriented programming. Microservices is really just object oriented programming. Object oriented programming is really just dependency management.
- pc86 9y agoSorry but trying to boil everything down to "dependency management" shows a basic lack of understanding of software architecture and is objectively wrong.