5 ms·
It's a bit odd that this would happen so soon after Cloudflare started testing & praising ARM-based server (and specifically Qualcomm's Centriq). For reference:
by masklinn 9y ago
It's a bit odd that this would happen so soon after Cloudflare started testing & praising ARM-based server (and specifically Qualcomm's Centriq). For reference:
https://blog.cloudflare.com/arm-takes-wing/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/arm-takes-wing/ where they find Centriq is mostly performance-competitive with Skylake at a significantly lower TDP/power point modulo platform support/optimisation e.g. Go's ARMv8 backend being immature and lacking optimised assembly routines
https://blog.cloudflare.com/neon-is-the-new-black/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/neon-is-the-new-black/ where they demonstrate the latter by simd-optimizing jpegtrans for ARMv8[0] leading the Centriq 2452 to reach (and even overtake) Xeon 4116's performance-per-worker and blowing its throughput-per-watt out the water (25 image/second/watt on Centriq 2452 versus under 10 on the 4116)
[0] as they'd previously done for AMD64, though starting with equivalent optimisations using SIMD intrinsics then adding ARM-specific assembly for further gains as "the compiler in that case produces somewhat suboptimal code" using intrinsics[1]
[1] because according to a commenter and SO[2] GCC inserts unnecessary register copies when involving NEON yielding to very poor machine code, Microsoft's ARM compiler is apparently stellar and Clang used to be meh but greatly caught up between 2012 and now
[2] https://stackoverflow.com/questions/9828567/arm-neon-intrinsics-vs-hand-assembly https://stackoverflow.com/questions/9828567/arm-neon-intrins...
- davidgrenier 9y agoThey were indeed doing so well... very sad.
- jsheard 9y agoIsn't it a bit dubious that Cloudflares articles don't disclose that they have received investments from Qualcomm? https://www.qualcommventures.com/companies/data-center-enterprise/cloudflare https://www.qualcommventures.com/companies/data-center-enter...
- nimish 9y agoVery much so. It undermines their value argument considerably: what kind of sweetheart deal did they get that a regular customer wouldn't?
- jgrahamc 9y agoThe value comes from the wattage and not from the price of the chip. Intel could give us CPUs for free and the Centriq chips would be cheaper overall because of the lower power requirements.
- nimish 9y agoIt's not so simple. What kind of engineering support, hardware support, optimizing support did CloudFlare get in exchange for a submarine PR piece? That can easily outweigh the performance-per-watt advantage that the blog touted. Qualcomm is not exactly known for being forthcoming with application support for any random company and that includes things like patent licensing costs. It's unethical to not disclose that QualComm invested in CloudFlare.
- jgrahamc 9y agoIt's not a submarine PR piece. It's literally the experience of a single engineer testing a piece of pre-production hardware.
- nimish 9y agoYou guys had an undisclosed (in the piece) investment from Qualcomm and then touted their products without clearly stating conflicts. It's: * a PR piece -- you guys are making the case for your/qualcomm's tech on a blog, designed for public relations for Cloudflare * you didn't disclose serious conflicts of interest that taint the conclusion of Qualcomm's tech being better You might not be the NYT, and you may not have had a PR firm pushing you, but it's not morally different. For the record, I was very interested in there being a real competitor to intel/amd in the server processing space. Now that the only real win they have is tainted, that's seriously disappointing.
- jgrahamc 9y agoI stand by my objection to you calling this a "submarine PR piece" which implies that somehow Qualcomm got us to write this.
- xmichael99 9y agoIt should also be noted that Cloudflare lies about nearly everything? Bandwidth numbers are always inflated at least 5x reality.
- baybal2 9y ago>It's a bit odd that this would happen so soon after Cloudflare started testing & praising ARM-based server Qualcomm is a "Big American Co." They play big business. If they do invest a gigaton of money into something, they expect returns fast. In other words, those types tend to give up quickly.
- dman 9y agoMicrosoft is a notable exception.
- phkahler 9y agoLooks like Qualcomm is a platinum level founding member of the risc-v foundation. Maybe they've decided to quit moving in this direction with ARM ISA and will revisit in a couple years with something they have more control over. Just me speculating or hoping.
- aseipp 9y agoNo offense but, hoping... for what? That Qualcomm will produce locked down RISC-V based chips with their own cores, without open documentation or support, backed by their patent portfolio, with difficult to use BSPs and various proprietary extensions requiring SDK licenses (Hexagon)? The same Qualcomm we love? For software programmers, you might as well replace 'aarch64-linux-unknown-gcc' with 'riscv64-linux-unknown-gcc' and they won't notice much else, but that was never the real issue. Qualcomm already has control over their products. The value offering from them has never been an ARM chip on its own. That is kind of the problem, in a sense. The distinction between them using RISC-V and ARM is one without a difference, more or less, especially in a market like servers (where margins are plentiful as opposed to razor thin, so BOM conservatism and paying for an ARM ISA license isn't as much a pain point.) If they don't feel they can enter the market at this point -- a point where ARM and they definitively have real competitive silicon offerings, if Centriq is to be believed -- the issue almost definitely has nothing to do with an ISA, and everything to do with business/their market outlook. If they re-enter later, even with a different ISA -- it won't be the reason. And even if it came true, won't change the reasons people hate Qualcomm.
- walrus01 9y agoThe ARM-based servers have never been viable yet, because you can't buy affordable/standard sized motherboards from any of the top ten Taiwanese motherboard manufacturers yet. It's a chicken or egg problem for whitebox server platform adoption. It's all custom order stuff. Nothing like where you can buy a $400 Supermicro, Tyan or MSI dual socket server motherboard, put two $350 Xeons in it, add RAM, etc.
- IntelMiner 9y agoARM development is also pretty tough if you want to use real hardware, and don't have deep pockets On one end there's the low-end gear. The Raspberry Pi and its clones. They'll run up to about $50 USD on average. But they're utter agony to develop on due to resource constraints Then there's the other end of gear with proper ITX or server formfactor that typically runs in the thousands of dollars, things from Gigabyte and others The least agonizing one to purchase seems to be the https://softiron.com/development-tools/overdrive-1000/ https://softiron.com/development-tools/overdrive-1000/ Though that's based on AMD's ARM CPU's, which as far as I'm aware, are no longer in production? So they may not have much stock left
- __d 9y agoI just use the cheapest Scaleway ARM VM: quad-core ARM8, 2GB RAM, 50GB SSD for EUR3/month.
- kakwa_ 9y agoThere are several issues with ARM based servers: * 99% of developers' laptops are still amd64. Cross compiling is a pain. Cross arch VMs are a pain (emulation vs para-virtualization). Unless one big brand of professional laptops makes the switch (Apple? Lenovo? Dell?), it will still be more convenient to have servers with the same architecture as your developers' laptops/stations. * Servers cost a ton, and only a fraction is due to the CPU(s). Those sweet ECC RAM modules still cost a ton. This redundant power supply is expensive. Those fast SSD/NVME disks will put a dent in any bank account. The gains seems only marginal, a bit less expensive to buy and operate in term of electricity bill but that's all. Also there is already a huge fleet of amd64 servers already deployed. switching is kind of a pain: * you land on a less tested architecture, so it's likely that you will encounter issues. * you could be stuck if you have off the shelf proprietary software with no support from the editor aside from amd64. * you have to recompile all your binaries, including this old one that was statically compiled in 1999, and for which you have lost the original source code. Unless there are clear incentives to switch, like for example an internal FPGA in the CPU, or the ability partition the hardware (VMs at the physical level, like LPAR in IBM Power), or a real cost decrease. It's unlikely that people will switch massively. But maybe cloud providers for services that hides the underlying hardware could be a market. RDS/Aurora/Route53/ELB/lamdba (to a lesser extent for the last) don't need to be amd64.