4 ms·
So it looks like someone somewhere made up numbers of played tracks, which were then passed on through the system as gospel And ... I am not sure now what. Th
by lifeisstillgood 9y ago
So it looks like someone somewhere made up numbers of played tracks, which were then passed on through the system as gospel
And ... I am not sure now what. There is a online radio station thing (tidal) that has dishonest numbers.
But why would you trust those numbers outside of tidal unless you had some independnat verification ?
Is there any such independnat verification of say Apple store downloads ?
If not how do we solve both problems?
- punnerud 9y agoDN have «verified» the data by matching payments from Tidal to music companies
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoYes, I am not disputing that they lied. What interests me is that we have so many unverified, and unverifiable sources of truth. If Apple just turned round and said "whoops, we were off by 2% for the past 5 years", would we know? If it was off by 200% there would be a lot of rumours and questions, but 2, 5, 10%?
- JazCE 9y ago> If not how do we solve both problems? hmmm i wonder if the blockchain can be used for this
- weego 9y agomaybe this is ironic and whooshed over my head but blockchains don't change human behaviour. While play count is an important metric that is shown and people bias their viewing behaviour there is no way to solve manipulating inflated numbers for profit.
- JazCE 9y agoyeah... i was being sarcastic really. should have added a \s or something to indicate that.
- Shivetya 9y agoSurely AI is an idea application for rooting out issues with data and identifying possible fraud. Since TIDAL reports its numbers to the record companies the onus should be on them to verify the numbers as realistic. Surely they also have the true subscriber numbers to go with the number of times something is played. The real sticking point here is the music industry has many untouchable characters in it, witness how #METOO barely if at all can make a dent in it especially the rap music side. so unless some other artists who have real pull can show they have lost real money this will get buried. There is a story Kayne West is after TIDAL for money but how far is he willing to buck that system?
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoI suspect that AI is not a good fit - the (public) datasets are too small here (all anyone knew previously was that one record label got charged X for Y downloads). Plus the dataset is tainted - it's not trying to spot if people have been pretend listening to beyoncé songs, and picking their trees from the forest, it's that every tree in the forest has been artificially raised up. If you don't know that how AI tell? I do agree on your second point though.
- perbu 9y agoAn important thing to take into consideration here is that both Beyonce and Kanye West own significant amounts of stock in Tidal. So there is a conflict of interest here. Tidal has marketed itself as the streaming service that first and foremost cater to musicians without trying to screw them over.