7 ms·
The environmental impact of technology devices is getting worse
- strken 9y agoMaybe a refund for consumers plus a collection fee for institutions would be an incentive to recycle, for both individuals and businesses. Your phone breaks, you take it to the supermarket, they give you $10, they send in the IMEI or some other unique code and get $12 in return.
- mehrdadn 9y agoRecycling just isn't a substitute; it's far less effective. You're supposed to reduce, reuse, and then, if neither is possible, recycle... in that order.
- icebraining 9y agoRecycling a phone can mean reusing many of its components for repairing other phones (as part of the fourth R: refurbishing).
- adrianN 9y agoIn reality recycling a phone means shipping it to some poor country where it is burned in an open fire to recover some of the metals. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/burning-truth-behind-e-waste-dump-africa-180957597/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/burning-truth-...
- icebraining 9y agoFrom your link: "85 percent of the e-waste dumped in Ghana and other parts of West Africa is produced in Ghana and West Africa. (...) In other words, Agbogbloshie is not a global dumping ground. Like most places on Earth, it’s struggling to deal with what it generates on its own."
- mehrdadn 9y agoDo you know of any place I could recycle an old phone that would give some kind of assurance (even a pinkie promise... but preferably some kind of statistic) that this would actually happen? Would love some recommendations because I don't know of any.
- icebraining 9y agoI'm not from the US, but ecoATM claims they refurbish most and recycle responsibly the rest: https://www.ecoatm.com https://www.ecoatm.com
- mehrdadn 9y agoWow thanks, I'll check it out!!
- swerner 9y agoWhat good is a refurbished but old iPhone these days when there is no more software for it? Even when you're lucky enough to have backup copies of older software versions, the web APIs most rely on have been discontinued.
- icebraining 9y agoI don't know about the iPhone, but I'm still using a Nexus 7 from 2012 just fine. It runs Lollipop (released in 2014) and in my experience, most apps support it just fine, although I'm sure their developers hate me :)
- Lafcadio 9y agoI would love to be able to just buy a new phone battery and keep mw phone going longer. But I do not want to have to go through a complex taking apart process that may result in destroying it.
- simonh 9y agoPlenty of manufacturers offer battery upgrade programmes, the one form Apple is even reasonably affordable these days. Plus there are third party upgraders that will do it for you for popular models. You do need to bear this requirement in mind when buying though.
- exodust 9y agoPhone manufacturers should be forced to provide free battery replacement on all their phones. Otherwise they should make it a simple process for consumers to swap the battery out. I still have a Samsung S5 phone with removable battery, had it for years. I don't know if there's phones on the market with replaceable batteries, I have not bothered looking for a new phone.
- samcheng 9y agoThe math is pretty poor in this article. Information and Communication Tech represents only 3% of global carbon emissions, and most of that is from giant server farms. This other article states that the embodied CO2 in a cellphone is roughly equivalent to 1kg of beef. That's like three steaks. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/green-living-blog/2010/jun/09/carbon-footprint-mobile-phone https://www.theguardian.com/environment/green-living-blog/20... The bigger emissions problems around electricity generation and transportation are where we should be focusing our attention.
- simonh 9y agoWe should bless our lucky stars the headline isn't "Apple Phones Are Killing The Planet...".
- Paianni 9y agoA decent proportion of those server farms exist to meet demand from smartphone users and serve their ecosystems.
- paulintrognon 9y agoBut manufacturing a smartphone involves a lot of transportation and electricity, doesn't it? Our focus should also be on cutting energy spendings & reducing transportation, and stop buying new phones (and laptops and tvs etc..) every now and then sure will help, will it not?
- elorant 9y agoOr we could reduce meat consumption.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoI suspect its long past the day when a marginal change in consumption will actually affect the world, even a little. The production of meat (and phones) does not change at all for small adjustments in demand - they are far too large an industry with far too large a lead time to respond to much at all. In fact, using homebrew solutions or alternative sources actually increases my environmental footprint. Now I'm not only wasting the goods that were created in preparation for me (phone, meat etc), I'm consuming more goods from an alternative source that is small and can more readily adjust for demand, which it does, by providing for me. Which has a further non-zero environmental impact. So in the short turn (year over year) its actually best to consume only the mainstream sources of goods since their marginal cost is about zero. Whether that seems tragic or efficient is up to the reader.
- sliken 9y agoSeems like the easiest fix would be to mandate the same charging cable for all phones (no dongles) and user replaceable batteries that require no tools to change. With those two simple tweaks it would be much easier to keep a phone for 3 or more years. My google pixel seems like it could easily last for many years with it's quad core, 128GB storage, 4GB ram, and 2560x1440 display. Lets be honest, for most uses that's plenty for many years to come. But already the battery is not as good as it was new and it's only going to get worse.
- xbmcuser 9y agoChinese smartphone sales have dropped dramatically this year. Mostly as smartphones have reached a point where upgrading cost vs return is no longer worth it for many. I really wanted Googles modular phone to be a successful but it died very quickly even before release otherwise that would have been a great way to upgrade parts without disposing old phones and creating waste.
- Vinnl 9y agoIf you think that's a shame, do check out Fairphone [0]. It's not completely modular, but it's trivial to replace the battery, screen and camera's without tools. See also their spare parts shop [1], all of which you can replace by yourself. [0] https://www.fairphone.com https://www.fairphone.com [1] https://shop.fairphone.com/en/spare-parts/?ref=header https://shop.fairphone.com/en/spare-parts/?ref=header
- pizza234 9y agoThe Fairphone is a great idea, however, the software support plan, which is crucial for a long-term device, is vague [⁰]. I wonder if there is a realistic plan for such devices; I'm not sure a subscription plan would work - would non-technically minded people pay? [⁰] https://support.fairphone.com/hc/en-us/articles/205504175-What-is-the-plan-for-software-updates-on-the-Fairphone-2- https://support.fairphone.com/hc/en-us/articles/205504175-Wh...
- 9y ago
- jlebrech 9y agothe planet != the environment. the planet will survive, it will just suffocate us and some other life will take over.
- Vinnl 9y agoLuckily everybody reading this article will still understand that the article is being alarming about the effect on us as a species and not about the actual existence of the planet on its own.
- jlebrech 9y agoit's just a euphemism for our own existence.
- oddeyed 9y agoYou know, that doesn't really make me feel any better or make the crisis any less pressing.
- throw7 9y agoTwo things not mentioned: 1. OS support (android at least) isn't that long. I suppose security patches are more important and might be worth fighting for somehow (extended security patch plans?). 2. i sometimes hear how repair shops have a hard time sourcing oem parts (having to go to chinese frankenparts which may be confiscated at the border). this should not be an issue and should work just like the car industry.
- swerner 9y agoI wish I could use my phones longer than I already do. Unfortunately, the lack of software updates for older hardware turns that into a security risk as even critical issues are no longer getting fixed. Likewise, the 'modern' web breaks things left and right. The heavy use of JavaScript for trackers etc makes it impossible to read even simple news web sites on an old iPad, even though the actual content is just static text. With Discourse and similar platforms gaining popularity, I'm getting locked out from more parts of the web unless I have up to date hardware. I don't understand why web forums became such complex beasts that a device capable of streaming video, realtime sound synthesis and 3D gaming is not sufficient to display what is essentially just text and some images. HN is a positive exception, I sincerely hope it remains that way.
- EADGBE 9y agoI think you're safe, HN is too hip to change.
- jimmy1 9y agoWhere is the disconnect I wonder? Your old iPad I am sure runs software that is many more times more complex, more lines of code, and more intense than the ad tracking software on a browser. Will web assembly help here?
- swerner 9y agoUnless Apple surprises us with an iOS 5 update that includes a browser with web assembly - no, it won't help. Either way, simply going to spiegel.de crashes (!) Safari in a 1st gen iPad. The Washington Post web page also would constantly get reloaded in my iPhone 4S.
- jimmy1 9y agoSounds like it may be due to Safari purposefully limiting the memory and processing resources available to a browser tab, no?
- syd_ 9y ago
- gnode 9y agoI wonder to what extent modern electronics, particularly display technologies as mentioned in the article, are dependent by necessity on rare earth metals, and couldn't be replaced with other chemicals. A change I can imagine in the future is towards organic chemicals such as in OLED displays. Although I'm aware that many of those used today are organometalics, and I have no idea what the actual metal resource impact is.