3 ms·
Most modern gui toolkits bother me in ways that I can't adequately express. All the more so because most fallback to thinking CSS is the answer. Often complet
by taeric 9y ago
Most modern gui toolkits bother me in ways that I can't adequately express. All the more so because most fallback to thinking CSS is the answer. Often completely ignoring what you can easily accomplish if you are willing to use absolute positioning, oddly enough!
Seriously, I don't think CSS is the worst answer. However, trying to get everything to work with some default flow behavior is borderline insanity. More, it is completely unnecessary. My favorite example lately has been http://taeric.github.io/cube-permutations-1.html http://taeric.github.io/cube-permutations-1.html for how you can layout using absolute positioning perfectly fine. (I similarly did sudoku with minimal effort using similar markup.)
But the worst sin is the sheer instability of what we are building as our foundation. The box and glue methods of TeX might not be the most intuitive method, nor the most powerful. However, it is nice that they have been stable. And not just in the "doesn't crash" sense of the word. In the, "I would feel comfortable building on top of it" sense.
So, let me be clear that I'm skeptical, but I would be delighted to be proved wrong.
- mmjaa 9y agoI've been into GUI's and so on since before the birth of the web, and I've always had this deep discomfort with where we have arrived here and now, today. The Web and its UI is such a disastrous, convoluted mess of abstractions and significance and conceptual complexity - yet, it works "well enough" that a majority of the world can deal with it. But this doesn't mean we can't think outside the box. Yes, I concur - TeX's box and glue is another kettle of fish - but then so too are things like Box2D's physics forces and contact mechanisms, which I personally believe, were it integrated into a forward-thinking GUI framework, would open the doors to very interesting and versatile interfaces - as has been demonstrated by its application towards making those most intuitive interfaces of all times, games. I would love to be able to say "[ the context of this independent element has a gravity of -1. ]", and then watch as my sentence floats away to the top of the screen, to function as a daily "Todo list" which, once I press the '.' period at the end of the ToDo item, then sets the gravity to 1, and the whole thing lands at the bottom of the screen, away from my attention. There are many abstractions like this out there which could be applied to human/computer interaction - we've selected a set of words, symbols, concepts that are granted us by the designers of modern OS's, but I truly believe that the effort of producing interaction symbology is far, far from where it could be. As do many other people of course (http://worrydream.com http://worrydream.com) .. there seems to be a plethora of views about this. Almost as many views, as symbols in the world there are to be read ...