2 ms·
Is this just Copenhagen Ethics[1] striking again? "Bail bonds companies are associated with something bad (the current criminal justice system), so they inheren
by SilasX 9y ago
Is this just Copenhagen Ethics[1] striking again? "Bail bonds companies are associated with something bad (the current criminal justice system), so they inherent the taint of evil."
What do they expect is going to happen when you make it harder for potential customers to find alternatives to the loudest bail bondsman? You just make it easier for the fewer, established bondsmen to offer harsher terms.
With that said, there is a right way to approach problems like this[3]: actually help the ostensible victims find a good alternative that does care about not exploiting them.
For an example of the model, here's my experience when I visited a California check-cashing place (long story): before cashing the check, on ridiculous terms, they walk you through several cheaper alternatives (no idea if this is a legal requirement).
I don't see anything in their announcement[2] that suggests they'll take this approach, which would be something like: replace the "bad ads" with ones for the superior, non-profit alternatives that they want these communities to use. It's just unhelpful moralizing from advocates with a dubious model of the harm's causation.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10367855 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10367855
[2] Warning: it will probably set off your add blocker: https://adwords.googleblog.com/2018/05/google-bans-ads-for-bail-bonds-services.html https://adwords.googleblog.com/2018/05/google-bans-ads-for-b...
[3] by "this", I mean a case where there's a bad system, and a for profit group that's offering a local improvement but seems slimy nonetheless
- inlined 9y agoMany other posters suggest that native search results (still allowed) will better find legitimate and helpful bail bond companies
- SilasX 9y agoI saw one or two other posters, and that's conjecture at best. If bail bonds companies really are exploitive and their announcement isn't just virtue signaling, they should be actively pointing people to the orgs that aren't exploitive (and have an actual model for what counts as not being exploitive), not just praying that the exploitive ones don't learn SEO.