3 ms·
I want to see us move away from SSNs and OLNs (driver license numbers) as identifying instruments. But this comment seems a little naive. There is massive infr
by pc86 9y ago
I want to see us move away from SSNs and OLNs (driver license numbers) as identifying instruments. But this comment seems a little naive.
There is massive infrastructure built entirely around the use of SSN as the sole and final arbiter of who is who. You can change your social, yes, but many many systems ignore that entirely because it's for the part rare and something that happens 0-1 times in a person's life.
The government cannot just say "hey that whole SSN thing yeah we're not doing that anymore" without a decade or more of lead time. Companies like Equifax and other not-quite-as-dumpster-fire ones who rely on something like SSN can't just create their own and can't just use everything but.
It needs to change but it will take years if not decades to fully extricate it from the system, and that's if the government decides today that it needs to be done, which itself isn't clear right now.
- 3JPLW 9y agoMy driver license number is entirely predictable based upon my name phonetics, DOB, and sex.
- pc86 9y agoOkay. That doesn't mean it isn't used as a unique identifier.
- PurpleBoxDragon 9y agoThey can. It will be a dumpster fire and will cost businesses massive amounts of money, but I think that's a good thing. You took an easy path that makes things worse not just for your users, but for people who never consented to using your system or doing business with you to begin with. Just pass a law that has an incrementing cost associated with use of SSNs. It can be done. That rich people who don't want it to be done because they like our the current setup to nonconsensually shift risk oppose it doesn't mean it can't be done.
- pc86 9y agoWhen I say "companies like Equifax" I don't mean credit monitoring services. I mean any company which has a regulatory or business requirement to verify you are the person you say you are. They all use SSNs, and most of them require your consent to operate.
- arh68 9y ago> The government cannot just say "hey that whole SSN thing yeah we're not doing that anymore" without a decade or more of lead time. The government itself has done it, certain parts at least. It took fewer than 10 years. Do you think the private sector would be slower than the public sector? [$_] http://dpcld.defense.gov/Portals/49/Documents/Privacy/SSNReductionPlan.pdf http://dpcld.defense.gov/Portals/49/Documents/Privacy/SSNRed...