3 ms·
Thank you for the follow up. I have a better sense of what you mean now. Part of me still thinks "professional" means "don't upset the status quo", but I will
by eesmith 9y ago
Thank you for the follow up. I have a better sense of what you mean now.
Part of me still thinks "professional" means "don't upset the status quo", but I will continue to think about it.
You mentioned "irrelevant commentary". That made me think of what US employment law refers to as "bona fide occupational qualifications" where employers are allowed to discriminate based on gender, race, religion, etc. It is not workplace harassment to see pornography in the workplace if one works as a video editor in a pornography studio. Pornography at the workplace, therefore, is not an unambiguous sign of unprofessional activity.
Now, some software is designed such that the humor will offend some people. The first one that came to mind is Leisure Suit Larry, which is a mild example.
Can something like Leisure Suit Larry be developed as a public FOSS project, in a professional sense? Absolutely.
But in that case I think there is a bona fide requirement that participants understand that certain jokes are acceptable.
My view is that since 'professional' seems so contextual, it seems better to explain the specific context (as you did - thanks again!) than to say something isn't professional.