5 ms·
We support and encourage diversity. Unless it’s thoughts, ideas or facts.
by dzhiurgis 9y ago
We support and encourage diversity.
Unless it’s thoughts, ideas or facts.
- josefresco 9y ago... and then when we're criticized for it, we'll overcompensate and allow outright propaganda, lies and fear-mongering.
- ionforce 9y agoDoes the diversity of thought include things that are false? Like if we teach people that the solar system is heliocentric, but someone wants it to be geocentric, is that the kind of diversity of thought we want?
- maxxxxx 9y agoYes. The arguments for geocentricism should be published as should do the ones for heliocentrism.
- simonsarris 9y agoIt is astonishingly disingenuous to suggest that merely factually false information is the only thing censored, hidden, or downplayed in timelines and searches.
- ionforce 9y agoDid I suggest that?
- ihsw2 9y agoThe difference between censoring false information and censoring wrongthink is pretty clear, and (more to the point) there is a concerted effort to engage in the latter while claiming to engage in the former.
- bilbo0s 9y agoNot trying to anger any of the people on either side of this argument, but my interest is genuinely peaked here. How would you define the difference between false information and "wrongthink"? Is "wrongthink" just ideas which we have no ability to test in a complete fashion? So something like geocentrism is false information, but asian supremacy would be "wrongthink"? And if so, what about historical things? Slavery for instance. Is it false information to assert that slavery would be good? Or is it "wrongthink"? The answer to questions like that is going to determine how much stock the average person is willing to put into the idea that "wrongthink" is appreciably different than "false information".
- rayiner 9y ago> Slavery for instance. Is it false information to assert that slavery would be good? Or is it "wrongthink"? Here's a concrete example: https://qz.com/1271960/google-has-banned-ads-for-bail-bonds-services https://qz.com/1271960/google-has-banned-ads-for-bail-bonds-.... That's "wrongthink"--a view that seems obviously true to a certain set, only because they're not willing to think too hard about the situation.
- bilbo0s 9y agoAnd that's where people will reject the notion of "wrongthink". If accepting the idea of "wrongthink" means accepting that slavery would be good, then surely you can see where many, many people will jump off the fence onto the other side can't you? Because many, many people believe the institution of slavery is inherently NOT good. People don't think it's simply "wrongthink" or a bad idea, people believe it's a patently false assertion. (Just to be clear, I believe it to be patently false as well.) That belief today is as strong as it was during the Civil War. And there are multiple subjects out there like slavery. Is holocaust style genetic cleansing "good"? If you assert such a thing, people will not consider that "wrongthink", they'll consider it to be patently false. The list of issues like that goes on and on. I only listed the obvious examples as a sort of reductio ad absurdum.
- 9y ago