4 ms·
He might not be the maintainer, but he is the BDFL. It's about respect. See what happened to Drepper who violated his respect. I like the joke, and I sympathiz
by rurban 9y ago
He might not be the maintainer, but he is the BDFL. It's about respect. See what happened to Drepper who violated his respect.
I like the joke, and I sympathize with RMS to let it in. In any case he opposed it so there is now a power struggle about the control of his project. I would love to see a better maintained glibc btw. Too much politics, not enough competence.
- DandyDev 9y agoThe dictator in question certainly doesn't seem Benevolent to me in this case.
- Tepix 9y agoIt's not like he is not benevolent either.
- rurban 9y agoHe certainly is. He tries to protect the project from morons, which invaded most bigger projects which are not cultured in technical discussions anymore. Compare that to the education of doctors. They need to persist on proper terminology and are hardened in a long process. PC is absolutely counterproductive there. Many obviously did not get the reference in this paragraph, but it still relevant, as this episode showed. Abort vs kill is loaded by a long fight, hence the reference about future censorship attempts.
- keiyakins 9y ago> PC is absolutely counterproductive there A. No, the terminology used by medical professionals is constantly shifting to do things like acknowledge that people with issues are still people. B. Your reasoning is presumably about confusion and lack of clarity, yes? How exactly is a reference to a law that has never been proposed serving that?
- geezerjay 9y ago> The dictator in question certainly doesn't seem Benevolent to me in this case. I don't see the point. RMS directs the organization and establises the policy it follows. I fail to see how a maintainer could feel entitled to dictate that policy just because he has access to the repository. That would be like a printing press janitor feeling entitled to censor what he feels a newspaper should not publish.
- SEJeff 9y agoWell see what Drepper did. CTRL-f for "Stallman" in these glibc release notes: https://sourceware.org/ml/libc-announce/2001/msg00000.html https://sourceware.org/ml/libc-announce/2001/msg00000.html While I agree with Ulrich, it is pretty brutal.
- rurban 9y agoYes, that was what I was referring to. It backfired big time. See what Drepper is doing now: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ulrichdrepper https://www.linkedin.com/in/ulrichdrepper He went from Technical Director at Redhat (i.e. glibc maintainer), to VP at Goldman Sachs (i.e. booted and being called an asshole), and now he is Engineer at Redhat.