3 ms·
No you’re missing the point. It isn’t “trust is bad” it is that trust necessarily excludes people from different backgrounds. If a bunch of your engineers (or
by olliej 9y ago
No you’re missing the point. It isn’t “trust is bad” it is that trust necessarily excludes people from different backgrounds.
If a bunch of your engineers (or whatever) went to Stanford, they people they trust are also much more likely to be from
Stanford, because those are the people that they know. The same holds for any university.
Then as time goes by the organisation becomes increasingly dominated by Stanford(or whichever) because the follow on hires also recommend people that they know — eg Stanford and the likes.
Now you have ensured that if someone cannot - for any reason - get into one of the feeder supplies, typically because going to those colleges requires a huge amount of money, or they’re super prestigious (the fancy UCs say) which have strong correlation to wealth (if you’re poor you can’t support the costs involved in getting a successful application).
So now you end up where large groups of people, for reasons outside of their control, and irrespective of talent, cannot get a job at your company.
At no point does anyone say “I don’t trust X”, it is simply the requirement that you have to /know/ someone to get a job there. Even if people are not trying to be assholes it is required nepotism. Even if you’re trying not to be biased, your hiring pool has already shrunk to match the backgrounds of your existing engineers.
If you want you could probably make a dumbass simulation of this, and I suspect if you start with X colours it will devolve to a small number fairly quickly.
- fsloth 9y agoI don't really understand the argument that employers should recruit absolutely fairly. Humans are always biased. If there was some AI based solution that would deal jobs absolutely fairly it would negate this, but there isn't, so the only alternative to smart human based hiring is dumb bureaucracy based one. The large scale discriminatory criteria of gender, race and age should be accounted for but beyond those constraining who you should vouch for sound extremely constraining. I understand the argument, and I think the effect you suggest is plausible - I'm not just convinced it's such an effect that could or should be accounted for (mainly because I have no idea what process beyond blind bureaucracy could do this).