3 ms·
What I said was that if Microsoft cared about users, they'd recommend they switch to OSX. You replied that Apple hardware comes at a premium. I replied that th
by pg 19y ago
What I said was that if Microsoft cared about users, they'd recommend they switch to OSX. You replied that Apple hardware comes at a premium. I replied that this premium is less than the difference between new and used hardware, and that using OSX only costs about $500. Could you find a laptop capable of running Vista for significantly less than that? If not, how am I mistaken?
- plinkplonk 19y agoto be fair though, when someone says "you should switch from X to Y" there isn't an implicit "you'll have to use second hand / used versions of Y" attached to that message. e.g the statement "you should switch from [cheap car] to [expensive car] because expensive car is much more comfortable" does NOT carry the "I meant a used [expensive car]" implication. Most people would understand that the first statement implies you should pony up the price differential because the extra comfort is worth it. It is bad enough that Windows has a monopoly and uses it to gouge customers. Why would anyone want to replace a software monopoly with a software and hardware monopoly?
- deleted 19y ago[deleted]
- SwellJoe 19y agoAs plinkplonk pointed out, you're suggesting it is good for consumers to choose a single supplier solution for both hardware and software. Not just any single supplier, but very nearly the highest cost supplier (you can spend more, but you get better quality hardware if you do). I just think there is a very clear comparison to be made between IBM in 1983 and Apple today, and it seems that your enjoyment of Apple products (and/or dislike of Microsoft products) has blinded you to that very clear comparison. Apple isn't quite in the position of dangerous strength that IBM almost had, but IBM also had competitors (Commodore, Apple, Atari). I merely think that a Mac system (even a three year old one) is not the ideal computing option for the average consumer. Additionally, I think an Apple monopoly would be every bit as dangerous as a Microsoft monopoly. Apple has a long history of taking advantage of the dedication of their users. I come down on the side of Open Source solutions to this problem, though Linux also has problems of its own, it does solve the problem of having a single supplier for any element of the system. With things like the Asus eee lowering the price of a laptop dramatically, while avoiding reliance on Microsoft (or Apple), I think things are looking up. In short, I think your IBM vs. Microsoft as Robin Hood analogy should be applied equally to Apple, though Apple has managed to hold tight the reigns such that no Robin Hood can spring into existence to bust up the control Apple has over the Mac market. Note that I don't have a problem, in particular, with Apple or Mac machines or Apple making money...just like I didn't have particular problems with IBM back in the day. I just think it's amusing that Apple gets a pass, while Microsoft is Robin Hood for cleverly thwarting the IBM monopoly on the PC. Pot, kettle, yada yada yada.
- pg 19y agoI just think there is a very clear comparison to be made between IBM in 1983 and Apple today The comparison is clearer between Apple in 1983 and Apple today. Not surprisingly. I never said that it was better for consumers to have a single supplier of hardware and software. All I said was that users would be better off running OSX than Vista. It happens that OSX is made by a company that also makes the hardware, but that wasn't the reason I was saying people would be better off using it. I wasn't saying that Apple won't, if they get dominant market share, turn into an evil monopoly, or that a company who broke said monopoly wouldn't be Robin Hood. All I was saying was what I actually said.
- SwellJoe 19y agoMy understanding of what you considered the benevolence of Microsoft was that they allowed a low-cost IBM PC compatible computer market to develop, which allowed people who wouldn't have been able to afford a PC to do so. Apple has never been accused of being a low-cost, or even affordable, computer supplier (and the existence of a used market doesn't invalidate that--a used PC running Windows XP or, better in my opinion, Linux is going to be even cheaper and within reach of more people). If the dramatically lowered price point for a personal computer was not the benevolence of Microsoft, according to your argument, and the price of a personal computer doesn't matter to your argument, then I will humbly stand corrected. Though I think I'll need some clarification about what the benevolence of Microsoft was, if not that, as I'm drawing a blank on anything else good that came out of Redmond. But, all that I actually said to start with was that I was amused that you praised Apple...the earlier criticism of IBMs abuse of power and the benevolence of Microsoft in breaking down the IBM monopoly made for an amusing contrast to me, an outsider who generally uses neither Apple nor Microsoft products and doesn't really consider Mac OS X a significantly superior OS to Windows Vista or XP. I don't really care which is "better" in this discussion, as "better" wasn't a qualification for Microsoft's benevolence. I found it amusing, that's all. I really didn't mean to stir up so much argument about it. If I were the type that used smileys, I would have included one in my first post...but I figured "amusing" would cover it. ;-)
- 19y ago
- tx 19y agoIf Microsoft cared about users, they'd recommend they switch to OSX. If Microsoft cared about programmers, they'd recommend they switch to Debian-based Linux. For $500 I'd rather be working on 1 year old ThinkPad T60 (2MB of RAM, Core Duo 2) with Ubuntu on it.