4 ms·
Personally, I’d rather see driving behavior normalize nationally than cater to regional differences in enforcement. The driving laws in each city & state the US
by dahart 9y ago
Personally, I’d rather see driving behavior normalize nationally than cater to regional differences in enforcement. The driving laws in each city & state the US are less different than the locally accepted behaviors, but it would be safer all around if drivers and pedestrians all expected the same things, and if we took traffic & safety laws more seriously. More enforcement of existing traffic laws will save many orders of magnitude more lives than customizing autonomous cars for various cities.
- Sangermaine 9y agoThe "reality should conform to my ideal, not my ideal to the reality" approach is and has always been a guaranteed recipe for failure. "Let's change everyone's minds and behavior everywhere" is much harder than changing software.
- dahart 9y agoThat’s an ungenerous way to paraphrase what I said, given that we already have traffic laws, and enforcement of those laws.
- Sangermaine 9y agoBut the point is those laws aren't enforced the same way in different areas, even when they're the same. Jaywalking is illegal in NYC. Come here and see if anyone, cops included, cares. But other cities seem to care much more about that. It's not as simple as having the same laws, or having them enforced, because the underlying cultural attitudes are different. If you tried to crack down on jaywalking in NYC you'd be laughed out of the city.
- dahart 9y agoIt doesn’t matter what the cultural attitudes are. All it takes to change it is a significant increase in fines, then people would, statistically speaking, break the law less often. We don’t have to convince the public to accept more enforcement, that’s not how traffic laws are made or enforced. What we have is a system of cultural attitudes that’s bad for us. People are dying all the time because of lax attitudes. What you’re advocating is status quo. Why? Is it a good thing that a lot of people in NYC who choose to jaywalk get hit by cars? I’m not on a mission to change things, I don’t care that much if people jaywalk. I’d prioritize speeding enforcement far above jaywalking. I’m just pointing out the obvious — that fretting over how safe it is for autonomous cars to obey the law is just “enculer les mouches”, to use the French term. It’s nitpicking the tiniest of margins while ignoring the primary cause of the problem.
- ams6110 9y agoSure. You be the politician who does that in NYC. And good luck on your next election. It's not going to happen.
- dahart 9y agoI'm not running for office in NYC, and your sarcasm seems to indicate you didn't read past the first sentence of my comment. Jaywalking was @Sangermaine's straw man issue, not mine. I was thinking more about speeding and aggressive driving than about what pedestrians do. Your comment seems to indicate you might not know how traffic laws are made or enforced. They are rarely touched by elected officials. I honestly don't know why I'm getting such vigorous push-back here. My original comment was about safety and nothing more. People hate speeding and seat-belt laws too, yet it's a fact that lower speed limits and mandatory seat-belts save lives.
- isostatic 9y ago> yet it's a fact that lower speed limits and mandatory seat-belts save lives. Near where I live there was a bridge that lorrys kept getting stuck under, and the local council were very confused. Then measured it, and found the warning sign wasn't right -- it said 15' but it should actually have been 14'. They changed the sign, and the accidents reduced dramatically. Having a lower limit reduced accidents. Unfortunatly someone looked at the statistics and thought "we're still getting accidents. Last time reducing the sign on the bridge by 1' caused them to go down, lets reduce it further and save even more lives!" So the sign was reduced to saying 10'. And accidents went up because people ignored the signs. Lower speed limits may save lives in some circumstances, but in the UK the safest roads are the fastest roads, which seems to contradict your statement. If you put a 30mph limit on the motorway, it will cost more lives 1) It would be ignored by many, so difference in speeds will be higher 2) People would route down more dangerous back roads rather than staying on the safest roads 3) The extra time spent on the motorway has a cost too. The average life is say 40 million minutes long. If your speed limit adds 40 minutes to 1 million people's day, that's 1 life a day you're costing You could argue that we should stop all vehicles, but then the economy collapses and you end up with civil war as we can't support this population level with an agrarian society
- c22 9y agoA massive enough influx of self-driving cars all driving with the same profile is perhaps one of the few ways reality could be coaxed into this particular ideal.
- Piskvorrr 9y agoNothing could possibly go wrong there. /s In other words, you're assuming a massive (no, even "10 000 cars" is not "massive"), coordinated, correct deployment. I'd like a pony and world peace while we're in fantasyland.
- tremon 9y ago> “The reasonable man adapts himself to the world: the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself. Therefore all progress depends on the unreasonable man.” ― George Bernard Shaw
- 0x00000000 9y agoIt can't and won't happen without significant increase in police and traffic enforcement spending which is not always a popular position and there is little motivation. Some states just can't afford it. But in Maryland for example, 55 almost universally means 75 and if an autonomous car didn't know that they will cause many accidents due to unsafe and aggressive driving even if they are technically not "at fault"
- dahart 9y agoWhy’s that? Fines are income, not expenditure.
- 0x00000000 9y agoPeople don't want more highway patrol, red light cameras, and traffic enforcement and tend to see it as a waste of resources. It also disproportionately screws lower income people and breeds contempt for police - people feel they are being persecuted when there are non-victimless crimes happening every day. I can't find a source for this, but I imagine they are not ever making net profit on tickets when a trooper makes 75k per year minimum not including overtime or benefits[1] plus 60k+ for a new cruiser[2] plus all other training and administrative overhead (dispatcher etc). [1] https://www.criminaljusticedegreeschools.com/state-trooper-requirements-by-state/california-highway-patrol-officer-requirements/ https://www.criminaljusticedegreeschools.com/state-trooper-r... [2]http://www.latimes.com/business/autos/la-fi-hy-cop-cars-20150314-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/autos/la-fi-hy-cop-cars-2015...
- dahart 9y agoFines can increase without hiring more people or buying more cars. Fines could be made proportional to income, at least one other country has already done that. Why would they need to make a net profit? That standard isn't applied to anything else the police do. We already have traffic enforcement as well as many other police services paid via taxes. The argument that it costs too much to increase enforcement in any way doesn't really hold much water. Whether people want enforcement is a different story, but the point I brought up that you responded to is purely one of safety. We can debate all the myriad reasons why we can or can't change our cultural attitudes, but it's still true that increased enforcement of human drivers would have a far greater impact on overall safety than fine-tuning autonomous cars to break certain laws in certain locales. Letting driverless cars break some laws or have "aggressive" driving profiles will never happen anyway, so it's moot. It would be too much liability for the car manufacturers. So how would you make roads safer?