6 ms·
Someone always brings up this inflation argument in these threads, where does it come from? It does not increase the amount of money in circulation. It's just l
by fulafel 9y ago
Someone always brings up this inflation argument in these threads, where does it come from? It does not increase the amount of money in circulation. It's just like other forms of income transfers.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> It does not increase the amount of money in circulation. It does, in the sense that money circulates faster. This is known as the velocity of money, and increasing the velocity of money does cause inflation.
- fulafel 9y agoWell, it's just taking money out of circulation with taxes and paying it out again. It's not inherently speeding anything up - if anything, slowing it down, since it spends some time in the governments pockets. There can be a second order effect of having well off people kick out some money to taxes that would be otherwise going to investments. It might cause a temporary inflation bump in consumer prices and a corresponding deflation in investments/assets. But that's a much smaller effect than what the amount of income transfers is. And causing this kind of increase in rate of economic activity is normally not considered negative, indeed politicians normally try to make them happen. And anyway central banks regulate this with monetary policy. There is no feedback loop of inflation.
- chimeracoder 9y ago> Well, it's just taking money out of circulation with taxes and paying it out again. It's not inherently speeding anything up - if anything, slowing it down, since it spends some time in the governments pockets. This is completely wrong. The principle I'm referring to is a standard component of basic macroeconomics and is completely uncontroversial among economists. There's lots of literature about this effect if you'd like to learn more.
- fulafel 9y agoAre you referring to "velocity of money"? Yes, it's a thing and economists agree it's a thing. But it does not follow that UBI causes runaway inflation - as we covered above. And there is certainly no consensus among economists about runaway inflation from UBI. (Unless you care to provide references..? I just did a search and came up emty) Do you think that UBI is qualitatively different from normal tax financed income transfers, from inflation POV, or do you think that just bigger income transfers cause runaway inflation?
- mercutio2 9y agoI’m a proponent of UBI, so I suspect we’re on the same side of this argument. Still, it seems to me you’re arguing a straw man. You claimed, “It does not increase the amount of money in circulation”, and that was all chimeracoder was arguing with. You’re responding as if chimeracoder was arguing increasing the velocity of money will automatically cause runaway price inflation. That’s not what chimeracoder was arguing, though. As it happens, I think you’re both right, the relevant value for economic activity is the money supply times velocity of money, UBI would likely modestly increase velocity of money but not money supply, the increase in their product would likely cause a modest inflationary shock. That shock would probably be somewhat offset by dramatic increases in geographic mobility and changes in the distribution and supply of low wage labor for unpleasant jobs. Sensitivity to housing costs would change in unknown ways, with landlords reaping somewhere between modest and huge windfalls in low housing supply areas, and likely smaller windfalls in areas closer to supply/demand balance, which would tend to make areas with good housing supply more appealing.
- _rpd 9y agoMonetary inflation is not the only source of inflation. There is also cost inflation. If renters suddenly have additional disposable income, landlords will raise the rent to absorb the additional disposable income. And the same with housing buyers and sellers. Unless there is a mass migration from urban to rural areas, there will be a cost inflation that exactly equals the additional disposable income. Cost of living adjustments will just make things worse. Annual increases in the basic income adjusted to inflation will cause an inflationary spiral and eventually hyperinflation. This is not a minor concern.
- mercutio2 9y ago“Unless there is a mass migration from urban to rural areas” -> I expect this to happen, and it would be great. I also disagree with your premise, because elasticity of demand for housing isn’t zero, even if you assume zero regional mobility.
- _rpd 9y ago> “Unless there is a mass migration from urban to rural areas” -> I expect this to happen, and it would be great. UBI does open up possibilities for rural communities, but the cultural trend has been the opposite for a long time. I don't see it reversing quickly. > I also disagree with your premise, because elasticity of demand for housing isn’t zero, even if you assume zero regional mobility. It isn't zero, but it is very low. Existing house owners fight tooth and nail to prevent higher density zoning. And new construction is slow to respond even to very strong pricing signals.
- fulafel 9y agoOf course some prices will rise and some will fall, because the new taxes will reduce income from different consumers than the biggest beneficisries are. If we want to prevent any price rises of poor people's products, this same argument could be used again any improvement in poverty / income equality, whether market based or income transfer based. If this is the wrong direction, should we make opposite changes - concentrate wealth in fewer hands? Anyway, in general it is not the case that prices would rise to consume all citizens' disposable income, foreastallyng all improvement in living standards. Your comment seems to conflate localized price changes with total real change stopping inflation, without justification.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]