2 ms·
It can't, really, without creating the bureaucracy that leads to all that waste in the first place. $130B is 13,000 $10M chunks. No single person can find, ve
by nostrademons 9y ago
It can't, really, without creating the bureaucracy that leads to all that waste in the first place.
$130B is 13,000 $10M chunks. No single person can find, vet, decide upon, and measure progress for 13,000 small organizations. That means you have to hire a staff to manage and give away the money. A staff means that a.) it's not your imagination that matters b.) money is allocated via horse-trading among the people who have been hired to manage the money and c.) suddenly you have a strong incentive for potential recipients to game the system and focus on making things look good for donors rather than providing the services to the ultimate beneficiaries. Organizations that previously were all about the mission become focused on the money, because there's a lot of it available and they're competing with lots of other organizations for it.
- ascorbic 9y agoIf he wants to deploy it efficiently, without needing to build a bureaucracy around it, he could do what Buffett is doing: donate it to the Gates Foundation. It's not great if you want vanity projects, but if he really wants to do good then it's hard to think of a better way.
- occamrazor 9y agoThe Gates Foundation is also a bureaucracy facing the same problems described by GP. Moreover I guess that economies of scale are not so significant after a certain point. I would prefer five different 100B foundations, rather than a 500B one, to encourage diversity in the donation strategy and goals.
- ascorbic 9y agoYes, and any organisation of that scale will have bureaucracy. My point is that he could avoid needing to build another one by using a fund that already exists and has a proven track record.
- occamrazor 9y agoI agree with you on that. My counterpoint is that marginal economies of scale are small, if not negative, at the size of Gates Foundation, and that having some diversity among foundations may be itself an advantage.
- sametmax 9y agoHaving worked in a mission financed by the Gates foundation I can tell you that a LOT of money leaves between the moment it's donated and the moment it's used in the field.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nl 9y agoThe Pineapple fund seems intent on trying this (although it is easier at $86M rather than $130B. Good problems...)
- notahacker 9y agoIt's equally impossible to create a space program without a lot of middle managers and dubious allocations of funds. As others have pointed out, Bezos has already got one organization which distributes money to relatively poor and needy people called Amazon, just one which happens to be known for its lack of generosity in doing so. It's also a demonstration that a sufficiently motivated Jeff Bezos is very, very good at devising ways to allocate resources amongst huge numbers of competing needs...
- arseraptor 9y ago> It can't, really, without creating the bureaucracy that leads > to all that waste in the first place. Oh please. The Gates Foundation has donated > $20 bn to-date and has done it more efficiently than any other philanthropic organisation on the planet.