6 ms·
> As you browse the web, that list changes as Chrome learns and enables autoplay on sites where you play media with sound during most of your visits, and disabl
by koolba 9y ago
> As you browse the web, that list changes as Chrome learns and enables autoplay on sites where you play media with sound during most of your visits, and disables it on sites where you don’t. This way, Chrome gives you a personalized, predictable browsing experience.
Predictable in a user application is the same result from the same action every time. UX changing based on opaque logic and heuristics is anything but predictable.
- jrochkind1 9y agoeh, as a user, it's not really predictable to me whether any given click will result in something autoplaying or not, it already feels like a crap shoot.
- jadedhacker 9y agoI think it depends a lot on how stable the learning is. If it converges and becomes harder to unlearn, eventually you'll be working from a stable platform... but it doesn't carry over to another browser unless you use the sign in feature. So you'll get a stable experience within a browser but not between browsers of the same make/model.
- rtpg 9y agoyeah, this seems like such an intense thing to do My bet is that they did this to not break Youtube. I mean it makes sense (you don't want video sites to not work) but it's also such a hacky sort of thing I don't get why they couldn't make this a permission thing like a mic. Ask the website to allow autoplay.
- Vinnl 9y ago> I don't get why they couldn't make this a permission thing like a mic. Ask the website to allow autoplay. ...because then it's not autoplay anymore?
- arijun 9y ago"Allow this website to automatically play videos in the future" sounds exactly like autoplay to me. Just not the first time.
- pryce 9y agoI have developed an instinctual reaction to automatically deny permissions like remotely that for any website, and I think most people have. Websites asking for permission to send notifications provokes the same irritation. I think - "I am in the middle of doing something, I don't want to stop and think carefully about permissions for some vague and abstract future encounters, I want the annoying dialog to go away and the site to get out of my way." Notably though: If some dialog like this came up even on a specific site like Youtube where I would almost invariably benefit from granting those permissions, I think there is a huge percentage chance I would knee-jerk deny the permission even when if I stopped to think about it, denying that permission would probably make my user experience worse. Lastly, there is an almost infinitesimal chance of me ever seeking out the settings to re-evaluate my choice on this.
- Macha 9y agoThe only websites where I have allowed notifications are discord and slack. I can't see any reason why a news site should be allowed notifications. I know why the site wants to send me notifications - alert on new articles loaded, draw me back in, keep my traffic, just like why they want me to install a native app - but I can't see the benefit to me. Still, if I've managed to allow notifications to slack/discord I'm sure I could figure out allowing autoplay on YouTube/twitch.
- giovannibajo1 9y ago
- gcb0 9y agohi, it looks like you are writing a web browser. I can help with it. (hope kids still remember clippy)
- ebbv 9y ago100%. And it’s like they have forgotten anybody ever shares computers in a family. Google has lost the plot lately.
- hammock 9y agoGet used to it, based on recent communication from Google one of their big new goals is using ML to improve... everything.
- local_yokel 9y agoOf course they threw the word "learn" in there to make it sound like advanced new tech, but this seems like something that can be done with simple heuristics (as opposed to machine learning).