2 ms·
I’ve been a member of this community a very long time. When content like this makes it to the homepage, it suggests the community thinks it’s good. Part of my r
by whalesalad 9y ago
I’ve been a member of this community a very long time. When content like this makes it to the homepage, it suggests the community thinks it’s good. Part of my responsibility as a member of this community is to try and point out when that is wrong. This post is full of misleading information.
I never said I didn’t respect the person. I said I didn’t respect the information in the post. I really can’t imagine how my remarks suggest that I’m a jerk.
Until I got flagged this was the top comment on the thread. The community seems to agree with my remarks.
I stand by them.
- dang 9y agoThe issue isn't the corrective information in your post (sentences 2 and 3). That's great. The issue is the snark and name-calling (and borderline personal attack) in the rest, which is what I referred to as being a jerk. I'm not saying and don't think that you're a jerk; it's an unintentional side effect, but one we all need to guard against. As you know, HN is trying to be a forum where people post civilly and thoughtfully. You can't judge this by upvotes. Indignation and snark often get heavily upvoted. That's a bug in the voting system, not an indication of comment quality. HN can't live by upvotes alone.