2 ms·
> ... gmail - because it's centralised, it can use ML to filter out spam much better than any other mailing services. For me, GMail is worse than useless as a
by ColinWright 9y ago
> ... gmail - because it's centralised, it can use ML to filter out spam much better than any other mailing services.
For me, GMail is worse than useless as a spam filter. I don't know if I have especially unusual email or what, but there's so much ends up in the spam bin I need to wade through it all anyway, so it costs me time.
At least, it did. I've given up on it.
- ColinWright 9y agoI'm baffled - I have no idea why this would be downvoted. I know that 88k karma and $5 will buy me a $5 coffee, and to that extent karma is completely irrelevant, but it says that somehow, to someone in the HN community, this comment is of negative value. As I've said elsewhere[0], as an engineer at heart, a model-maker and problem solver, it's like sandpaper on the brain when people act in ways that mystify me, and for which I have no effective, working model. Baffled. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17007328 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17007328
- avar 9y agoI usually don't comment on these sorts of comments, but since you're a very active user I'l bite. I downvoted you because this type of commentary is the least useful thing you can read on HN. Nobody learned anything useful from knowing that some guy with a GMail account isn't pleased with the spam filter. What was this supposed to achieve? Some long side-thread with people sharing anecdotes about whether or not GMail worked for them? This is the sort of thing that gets made fun of at n-gate.com. Also: Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading. -- https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- ColinWright 9y agoThank you for the response! That gives me something useful to be going on with. In contrast to your comment, I've always found the personal experiences of HN users to be incredibly valuable data points, which is why I shared my own. I'll re-evaluate that. WRT the guidelines, I'm painfully aware of that one. While I appreciate its wisdom, it means that one can never learn from the otherwise anonymous downvotes, so to my mind it's worth taking the risk. In this case I really have learned something. Again, thank you.
- nitrogen 9y agoAs a personal anecdote, I've also noticed that people around me are less interested in personal anecdotes in general. It seems more pronounced over time. I could hypothesize that Facebook and Twitter give people all the anecdotes they need, or that my anecdotes have become more poorly worded over time, but I really have no idea what the cause is.
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> Nobody learned anything useful from knowing that some guy with a GMail account isn't pleased with the spam filter. I didn't, because I'm already aware through personal experience that gmail's spam filter is much too strict, consigning legitimate emails to the spam folder despite the fact that any idiot could tell you they were real. But in general, I don't see why one user's comment that the spam filter is terrible should be viewed as less "useful" than another user's comment that the spam filter is great.
- avar 9y agoThat's not the difference between the two comments. The positive comment claimed that GMail's filtering was good because they can do it at scale with ML. Yours and the comment I was responding to just assert that it's still bad. Maybe it is, but no amount of people showing up in the thread asserting that it sucks will make for interesting reading. What would make them interesting is an educated guess about why it's bad.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoMaking an interesting-and-wrong comment is not obviously better than making an uninteresting-and-correct comment unless you're here purely to be entertained. To me, the uninteresting-and-correct comment is much more valuable.
- bahmboo 9y agoWe are well OT but it is interesting to hear the different experiences with Gmail spam filter. I never look there except for curiosity. False positives are extremely rare...for me.