3 ms·
> Robert Lightfoot, the former acting NASA administrator, lamented in candid terms how the agency, with society as a whole, has become too risk-averse. He charg
by carapace 9y ago
> Robert Lightfoot, the former acting NASA administrator, lamented in candid terms how the agency, with society as a whole, has become too risk-averse. He charged the agency with recapturing some of the youthful swagger that sent men to the moon during the Apollo era.
> "I worry, to be perfectly honest, if we would have ever launched Apollo in our environment here today," he said during a speech at the Space Symposium last month, "if Buzz [Aldrin] and Neil [Armstrong] would have ever been able to go to the moon in the risk environment we have today."
That is a really underhanded way to say, "Let's kill more astronauts so we can get to space faster."
The folks who risked their lives and, in some cases, gave their lives to get us to where we are today deserve better.
- toasterlovin 9y agoDisagree. We make trade offs wrt safety all the time. Driving in a car is pretty dangerous, yet many of us drive our cars every single day. Because the payoff is worth the risk. Those quotes speak to this trade off. They are advocating for a stance that is willing to take more risk, because they assume that there are tremendous benefits to be had by doing so. They are not advocating taking risks for the sake of killing astronauts.
- carapace 9y agoI get what you're saying but in this case I have to ask, can we really not get those benefits without risking lives? Would it become impossible? Or would it just take longer? Can robots do it? I hate arguing this position because I want to go to space physically in person in my lifetime. But it doesn't make sense to send humans if robots can do the job because space is inimicable to life and life support is very hard and expensive and heavy. Risk lives to stave off an asteroid but not to mine it. - - - - I don't want to get into a side-thing about driving, but I don't drive in part because I see it as a Faustian bargain: we get transportation that's so convenient at the cost of forcing people to participate in a death-and-mayhem lottery. Traffic is a meat-grinder.
- nkristoffersen 9y agoWe’ve sent many robots to space and to mars. But they are very limited in their scope and ability. Where a human can have near limitless scope and ability. Watch some of the mars rover videos and it becomes clear how frustrating it must be for the scientists on earth to do research on mars remotely.
- carapace 9y agoMore frustrating than being blown up on the launch pad!? Mark S. Miller had a site with a list of "adages", here's one I really liked: "A Computer's Perspective on Moore's Law: Humans are getting more expensive at an exponential rate." This is true, although slower, for robots. Look, if you want to risk your life to go to space, I'm fine with that. I do too. But if NASA or Musk or Bezos or whoever want to unnecessarily risk other peoples' lives to make a buck faster, or even just explore Mars, that's irresponsible and kinda fucked up, is my opinion. For example, I think Mars One is awesome! (Stupid and doomed, but still awesome.) Colonizing Mars to have a "backup" Earth is important enough (in my opinion) that it's noble to risk your life to achieve it ASAP. Mining an asteroid, although I personally would love to try it, is not quite so noble, eh? The less "risk-averse" space program was happening in a very different context: the "Space Race" [1] which was in many ways a continuation or extension of the Cold War, which was in many ways a continuation or extension of WWII. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Race https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Race