3 ms·
The fact that "micropayments" weren't even mentioned in this article leads me to dismiss it. There still doesn't seem to be a "Twitter of Micropayments" yet.
by carapace 9y ago
The fact that "micropayments" weren't even mentioned in this article leads me to dismiss it.
There still doesn't seem to be a "Twitter of Micropayments" yet.
Gratipay shut down, (RIP) https://gratipay.news/the-end-cbfba8f50981?gi=54bc4ed25327 https://gratipay.news/the-end-cbfba8f50981?gi=54bc4ed25327
Patreon takes a percentage, which, to me, seems unjustifiable.
- always_good 9y agoYou suggest that the lack of even mentioning micropayments leads you to dismiss the article. But then you point out that there is no viable micropayments platform. Doesn't seem like there's much to mention beyond "yup, still doesn't exist."
- carapace 9y ago> You suggest that the lack of even mentioning micropayments leads you to dismiss the article. I didn't suggest, I stated it baldly. > But then you point out that there is no viable micropayments platform. No I didn't. I mentioned one that is defunct, and one that is popular but that I have a problem with personally. The article I linked to about Gratipay references Liberapay (https://liberapay.com/ https://liberapay.com/) and Open Collective (https://opencollective.com/ https://opencollective.com/) but I didn't want to mention them because I haven't checked them out myself. There are probably others. > Doesn't seem like there's much to mention beyond "yup, still doesn't exist." And yet this low bar is unsurmounted? Wrote a whole article about "Subscription Hell" yet won't step over to the watercooler full of lemonade. Good day sir.
- ajross 9y ago> But then you point out that there is no viable micropayments platform. Doesn't seem like there's much to mention beyond "yup, still doesn't exist." Sure there is: "Micropayments are fundamentally infeasible". Which is to say, payments are trivial to do. There have been dozens and dozens of startups doing online payments in various schemes since the beginning of the internet. But the fraud problem is not solvable on that kind of scale. Batching payments such that you buy one "thing" for at least a few dollars gives some level of assurance that one human being looked at the transaction and that the seller gave enough thought to be sure it was worth selling as a unit. That all falls apart when you get to "one article" scale. You want this to be a purchase that the user doesn't even thing about (because seriously if I have to stop and think whether I want to pay $0.13 to read an article the answer is "NO"). But without that promise of thought it becomes impossible to reasonably authenticate a transaction. Users will be absolutely flooded with fraud schemes tricking them into OKing these tiny things. This is what killed ad-supported platforms too.
- tallanvor 9y agoSo how should Patreon pay for their staff, infrastructure, and other costs if taking a percentage is unjustifiable?
- carapace 9y agoThey could add up all their expenses, divide by the number of users, and charge that? My point is they should charge in proportion to the service/value they provide, not in proportion to the size of donation/patronage. It doesn't cost them twice as much to process a donation twice as large, so: "unjustifiable". Can you justify that? (Not rationalize it, justify it?)
- tallanvor 9y agoYes, it's justifiable. Larger donations have a higher risk of fraud and chargebacks, so on average it will cost Patreon more to handle this. Additionally, it's not uncommon for credit card companies to charge a fee, even if Patreon wins the chargeback request. If a user donates $10 to a specific creator and initiates a chargeback, who should end up paying the chargeback fee and the donation amount (if the chargeback is successfull?) You can't charge the user who initiated the chargeback, especially if they were successful. The only thing you can really do is ban them from the service in the future. So, do you take those fees from the creators who received the donation, or do you spread the cost among other creators/donors? You can't realistically charge the donors. If I were to go to Patreon to try and give someone $5 but was told, thanks for donating, but we're going to charge you an extra $2 because that's the average cost per donor to provide the service, develop new products, advertise, etc., I'm not going to donate. Most people won't. So do you charge the creators? Let's say the cost per creator is $20/month. If a creator only earns $10, do they then actually owe $10? What creator is going to use the service if they might end up owing money? The answer, of course, is you figure out the average percentage of a transaction you need to take. You do this because it provides both donors and creators clear information on how much money goes to the creator, what goes to the payment processor/credit card provider, and what percentage goes to Patreon. But I mean, if you really think that's not a good justification, why not start your own competing option with a business model you think is more fair.