11 ms·
Earth’s carbon dioxide levels reach highest point in 800,000 years
- Pilfer 9y agohttp://earthguide.ucsd.edu/virtualmuseum/climatechange2/07_1.shtml http://earthguide.ucsd.edu/virtualmuseum/climatechange2/07_1... On a geologic timescale, CO2 levels were many times higher than they are today. >In very general terms, long-term reconstructions of atmospheric CO2 levels going back in time show that 500 million years ago atmospheric CO2 was some 20 times higher than present values. It dropped, then rose again some 200 million years ago to 4-5 times present levels--a period that saw the rise of giant fern forests--and then continued a slow decline until recent pre-industrial time. CO2 levels over the past ~5 million years are at the lowest point in over 200 million years. On a geological timescale, CO2 levels are returning to normal, not going away from it.
- lifeformed 9y agoBut it's just talking about the past 800,000 years.
- Diederich 9y agoCan you expand on that?
- Paraesthetic 9y agoDo we even know what happened in the last 100 years? The problem with predictive analysis is that it presumes things have always continued along a trend line. This is always unlikely and basing predictions off this minute piece of the picture is like doing a 5000 piece jigsaw guessing the picture from one piece of the puzzle.
- Ancalagon 9y agoNo, the article says the CO2 levels are at their highest in the last 800,000 years. Its literally right there in the title of the post.
- tim333 9y agoYeah but Pilfer's point is the levels in the last 800,000 years are abnormally low in the last 200 million year period.
- nixpulvis 9y agoFrom the same site: > All we can say is that, over the last 400,000 years, there seems to have been a positive feedback at work: whenever the climate became warmer, carbon dioxide and methane rose and helped make the climate even warmer.
- Pilfer 9y agoFair, but that doesn't detract from the point that CO2 levels maintained 1000-2000ppm for over 100 million years. This was during the Jurassic and Cretaceous periods, when life was thriving on earth. Present CO2 levels are low on a geological timescale.
- graeme 9y agoHow well would that work for humans? 2000 ppm is well above the threshold when we start to find negative cognitive effects. And I imagine CO2 in buildings would be more like 3000-4000 ppm. This is leaving aside sea level rise hurting infrastructure, crop failures due to shifting weather, and areas becoming regularly above 35 degrees wet bulb.
- pharrington 9y agoThat is a true statement. Another true statement is that Earth's greenhouse gases are basically a trace compared with Venus's. Another true statement is that the current human causal rate of CO2 emissions will rapidly change our environment to one unsuitable for human life.
- pharrington 9y agoYes, the Cambrian explosion indeed was an even wilder change in environment and ecosystem than what we're going through now. A hypothetical human time traveler, however, wouldn't survive a hypothetical time travel back to that.
- Pilfer 9y ago>A hypothetical human time traveler, however, wouldn't survive a hypothetical time travel back to [the Cambrian explosion]. I assume you are referencing about CO2 levels. Yes, around ~500 million years ago, CO2 levels reached 10,000ppm, which would be hazardous (but not fatal) to a human traveler. However if you pick a point between 300 million years ago and today, when CO2 levels were at 1000-2000ppm, a human traveler would have no problem surviving in that environment. Heck, it is even possible to hit those CO2 levels in a modern day warehouse or office that is poorly ventilated. Increased CO2 levels are very survivable and do not mean the end of the human race.
- epistasis 9y agoThe question isn't whether some humans will survive or not, but where they will survive, and how expensive it is to adjust to that change.
- Pilfer 9y agoWhich is moving the goalposts and changing the question. He's asking if a "hypothetical human time traveler" could survive hundreds of millions of years ago, and based off historical CO2 data, it could be possible.
- gameswithgo 9y agoobtuse levels are high here. goal posts moved on a goal post already moved. goal post was being moved back
- dwaltrip 9y agoYou are picking pedantic arguments instead of focusing on the actually important themes, which isn't productive or useful Let's get everything on the table. Are you actually okay with dozens of millions to hundreds of millions of people dying -- and many others suffering immense drops in quality of life -- as a result of human-caused climate change? Despite the fact that we have the capacity to heavily mitigate such risks?
- eloff 9y agoThe article talks about this being the highest point in the last 800K years, but you're right that geologically speaking the levels are quite low for our planet. The problem is life takes a long time to adapt, including us silly humans who build our cities on the coast. Just because CO2 levels have been higher before does mean the process will be a pleasant one. It may well involve the extinction of large numbers of species, and large numbers of humans (never all humans as some people seem to be fond of saying.) It could even possibly trigger collapse of civilization in extreme enough scenarios where methane from the oceans and tundras is released in a feedback loop. So yeah, you're factually correct, but missing the point.
- thaumaturgy 9y agoOkay, this comes up sometimes in climate-related topics, usually because of a combination of misunderstanding and a need to be the clever contrarian that's thought of something nobody else has. The question isn't whether Earth will survive these CO2 levels. Earth will (probably) be just fine. It's common knowledge, especially among the scientists that publish claims about rising CO2 levels, that Earth has had much higher levels of CO2 and other greenhouse gases in the past, and that at those times, there was lots of life. The question isn't necessarily even whether humans will survive much higher CO2 levels. We're resourceful, we have the ability to shape our environment. Some people will survive. The question is how much we're going to enjoy all of the adverse effects of this global climate change. It is going to cause or contribute to a lot of natural disasters: hurricanes, tornadoes, extreme storms, droughts, flooding, massive wildfires. There are going to be migrations. Wars. There are some solid arguments that climate change contributed to the Syrian civil war [1]. Many species are going to disappear as they fail to adapt quickly enough to the changing environment; it will take much longer for new species to take their place. We will see, for example, an environment with fewer butterflies and more mosquitoes -- many more. Nobody is going to get out of this unscathed. It's going to cause widespread political and economic instability and unrest. Even if you manage to find yourself a nice little spot untouched by the most direct effects of climate change, it's going to cause enough suffering in enough other parts of our globally interconnected human society that you'll see the costs somewhere. The US spent a record $306 billion on disaster response last year. Where do you think that money comes from? [1]: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/climate-change-hastened-the-syrian-war/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/climate-change-ha...
- Pilfer 9y ago>It's common knowledge, especially among the scientists that publish claims about rising CO2 levels, that Earth has had much higher levels of CO2 and other greenhouse gases in the past, and that at those times, there was lots of life. This isn't common knowledge at all among non-scientists. Most people have no clue that CO2 levels were many times higher than today, and that earth and the ecosystem in general were just fine. Scientists may be aware of this fact, but why don't they inform the general public of this? Take the submitted article for example. Instead of publishing an article stating, "CO2 levels are higher than 800,000 years ago; but are likely lower than they were at any point from 20-200 million years ago" they only leave in the scary, doomsaying first part and neglect to inform the second part. It is the equivalent of looking at a 24 hour geological clock and only telling people about the past minute while neglecting datapoints from minutes or hours ago. Why aren't scientists informing the public of the historical data? I understand why the climate change community may not want to bring up this point (it detracts from other issues) but people should be aware of this fact. Humanity, and life in general, will survive increased CO2 levels. >The question isn't whether [X], it's whether [Y]. I am paraphrasing, but that's largely what your comment is saying. The article premise and its title, is about [X], where [X] is CO2 levels. It seems like the response to historical CO2 levels is to change the topic. Edit: I don't want to reply to several comments, so I'll respond here. Why do I believe the discussion should inform people about historical CO2 levels? Largely because I firmly believe CO2 emissions will not decrease through 2040. The incentives to cut emissions are just not there. Petroleum is simply too useful as a resource. The current projections I have seen predict 500ppm by 2050, and likely 600ppm by 2100. Given those numbers, I ask myself the question, how likely is it that humanity will face extinction in the next century? How should I interpret these numbers? Given the geological data, I find it reassuring that biology and life on earth survived for hundreds of millions of years with CO2 levels between 1000-2000ppm. It means that increased CO2 levels will not cause the extinction of humanity.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 9y agoIf I’m interested in the survival of human civilization, which has been around for less than 10,000 years, how is it useful to consider that CO2 levels were much higher 200 million years ago?
- tim333 9y agoI think that's true although it's also true that rapidly increasing CO2 now seems a dangerous experiment with our only planet. As an aside noting the downvotes on the above comment I sometimes question if that stuff is a good idea. I can see the point that mentioning high CO2 levels may not be a problem could be dangerous as the masses will keep burning CO2 but trying to drum up panic isn't working that great as illustrated by the "highest point in 800,000 years" thing. From an engineering kind of view point I feel you should look at things as neutrally as possible though I guess from a political view point maybe not.
- graeme 9y agoI thought this bit was interesting: "As a scientist, what concerns me the most is not that we have passed yet another round-number threshold but what this continued rise actually means: that we are continuing full speed ahead with an unprecedented experiment with our planet, the only home we have," Katharine Hayhoe, a climate scientist at Texas Tech University, tweeted Thursday" We really are going ahead full speed. Global emissions have been rising in recent years, not falling.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 9y agoAnd even countries like Germany who say they take climate change seriously are revising their CO2 goals because they are having trouble meeting them due to their abandonment of nuclear power. https://euobserver.com/environment/140475 https://euobserver.com/environment/140475 At this point if you are opposing nuclear power, you aren't taking climate change seriously, even if you say you are.
- abenedic 9y agoI have a feeling that one of the biggest blockers to actually doing something about climate change is how easily the conversation gets derailed. Almost everyone agrees on clean energy, but once you get into specifics people lose their cohesion(people are pro- or anti-nuclear power, or for or against wind energy(birds, off-peak power, etc.)). I think people get too focused on any one particular solution, and cannot see that a mixture of things probably is best. Nuclear for places that can tolerate it plus wind or solar for peak times. Hydro and solar/wind for places that can't. I have heard for years, and at various times expounded myself, of the virtues of nuclear. But the public in most industrialized countries cannot stand the thought of it near them, so looking at a more balanced approach makes sense.
- btrettel 9y ago> I think people get too focused on any one particular solution, and cannot see that a mixture of things probably is best. Nuclear for places that can tolerate it plus wind or solar for peak times. Hydro and solar/wind for places that can't. I agree that a mixture is necessary. With that being said, the examples you give are entirely technological, which I think is likely insufficient to solve climate change. I think we need a combination of technological, psychological, and political approaches. For example, as a cyclist, I'm continually disappointed by the reasons people tell me they'd never be able to adopt cycling for transportation. I'm told that they wouldn't be able to do X, Y, or Z, or that they'd feel very restricted, etc. But when I tell them that most cyclists do X no problem and they could rent a car if they wanted to do Y and Z (which are done infrequently), they aren't convinced. It seems to me that many people face a false dilemma here because they see cycling as far more difficult than it actually would be. If you design your life to make cycling possible, it's perfectly acceptable, even preferable in my case because I want the exercise. Most people pick where they live based at least in part on their driving commute, so it would only be fair to do the same for a cycling commute. Population reduction is another area which you could mention as part of a combination of solutions. In my experience those conversations are often counterproductive. But it seems clear to me that population can't keep increasing if we only have one planet, and we might prefer to have less people with a higher quality of life. (My views on population ethics are not fully formed for what it's worth.) My view is that climate change is a lost cause, so instead I'm focusing on adaptation to the new normal.
- shmerl 9y agoIs there a way to build a closed loop system that would suck CO2 and make methane from it for example? Methane can be used for further energy production but again with closed loop, capturing all produced CO2.
- fulafel 9y agoPlants and algae convert co2 to hydrocarbons such as starch and cellulose, which can be used as fuel or further refined into biogases, ethanol, or biodiesel etc. Industrial processes also exist and can be solar powered , but probably are less efficient.
- ars 9y ago> and make methane from it That part's easy. Where's your energy source? The whole issue is not Co2, it's energy.
- shmerl 9y ago> That part's easy. Where's your energy source? Solar + methane itself fed back into the loop.
- rocky1138 9y agoOn an unrelated note, I'm impressed that the Waterloo Record's webiste is surviving the HN hug.
- digitalsushi 9y agothe only thing that stresses me out more than the story, is the likelihood that someone very smart is working on something that will take 99% of us all out in a last ditch effort to save the planet.
- timb07 9y agohttps://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/xwvgeq/an-incomplete-timeline-of-what-we-tried https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/xwvgeq/an-incompl...
- digitalsushi 9y agoThat is haunting.
- anonoholic 9y agoAnd that, sadly, as a last ditch effort, would be a very good thing for humanity, but probably not for the planet.
- Brockenstein 9y agoIf I know anything about humans it's that a "last ditch, requires 99% participation in an all out effort" isn't doable. 99% of people can't agree on anything especially if the results aren't immediate and miraculous.
- newintellectual 9y agoCO2 levels reached their lowest level in earth's history a mere 25,000 years ago, at 180 ppm. At 150 ppm, RuBisCo, the enzyme in photosynthesizing plants which fixes CO2 to usable carbon, basically stops working. Translation: the earth avoided the biggest extinction event in its entire history by a very slender margin of 30 ppm of CO2. Without plant life, animal life would die off as well, including humanity. The fanatical environmentalists keep attacking humanity for "destroying the earth", when the reality is that human release of CO2 into the atmosphere has probably pushed back that final extinction event by millions of years. The reality, unsurprisingly, is the polar opposite of their propaganda harangue.
- xupybd 9y agoDo we have a good grasp on what that means? I'm not trying to deny climate change but if I'm honest I don't know what it means for the carbon dioxide levels to by the highest in 800,000 years. Is the temperature response linear? Are there other dangers involved in changing the composition of our atmosphere? Is the response likely to self regulate or avalanche out of control? Is being the highest in 800,000 actually a significant point or is it just a bad sign?
- shusson 9y agoMy concern is that we are experimenting with a precious and unique system.
- zaarn 9y agoAnswers in order: We dont' know. 5 times. The rapid and huge increase in CO2 is to my knowledge unprecedented. We did have similar CO2 levels in the past but never in such a rapid incline, only after thousands if not millions of years time for everything else to respond. We could be causing a The-Day-After-Tomorrow-Scenario. Or something like 2012. Or Mad Max. We simply don't know but considering the parts we do know, it's likely that whatever happens is not good. A 400ppm Level of CO2 was considered a symbolic point of no return and we have passed it a while ago.
- z3r0_v 9y agoOh and I thought climate change was a conspiracy theory perpetrated by the chinese to sell us more PlayStations or something. Turns out this stuff is more complicated.
- Paraesthetic 9y agoCan someone do something about China? 1.7 billion and rising people with no real effort to curb emmissions because it would stiffle investment. Hence why their cities are cesspits of filth
- stevensonbaines 9y agojust last year i was in some deep mess with my credit report after crashing my car while i was trying to avoid collision with a dog rushing to the bank to apply for a loan to cover my twin children college tuition fee. this almost changed everything for us as the auto crash had a very terrible effect on my credit score and credit report. i was in need of a miracle then i reached out trying to seek for a possible solution. my colleague at work introduced me to this excellent hacking firm which i emailed at QUADHACKED(at)GMAIL(dot)COM , they helped me remove negative listings from my credit report,i wasn't heading foreclosure any more, my credit card was topped and so was my credit score in weeks after application submission and final approval by credit bureau , i was already having a score of 735 , it felt like a miracle, i'll just say you reach out to them and see for yourself QUADHACKED(at)GMAIL(dot)COM.