4 ms·
Would it stop absurd transportation of goods like exotic fruits all year long ? If people stopped buying things from far away that aren't really really necessa
by agumonkey 9y ago
Would it stop absurd transportation of goods like exotic fruits all year long ?
If people stopped buying things from far away that aren't really really necessary, maybe that will also reduce fuel use.
- nitrogen 9y agoBuying things from far away is the point of living in a modern, global economy. You don't get people on your side by telling them they want the wrong things. The way forward is to give people what they want in a sustainable way. If someone's feet hurt, you don't tell them to lie down for the rest of their lives. You tell them to get better shoes. Global trade reduces global warfare, too.
- jacobreg 9y agoOr at least price the unsustainable goods to reflect the harm they're doing to the environment, and use that extra money to help fix it.
- agumonkey 9y agoI'm happy about warfare channeling through economic relations but the rest is bullshit IMO. I believe more in locality rather than having constant supply of things from all over the world. And that it's "THE" point of a modern economy couldn't be more pointless to me.
- ithkuil 9y agoI'm genuinely curious about what is the right size of "local"
- agumonkey 9y agosame timezone, same latitude band ?
- emj 9y agoThat means a car economy, the question of what is local is a good one, there is a reason the world population is spread out the way it is.
- agumonkey 9y ago- grow more vegetables and fruits nearby (lots of unused space) eat them - gather local material as much as possible use them with creativity (see the wood based buildings for instance) I don't accept the "world status" anymore
- emilfihlman 9y agoYou really, really, really don't want that to happen. Globalisation and global economies are very good things for human and technological development. If you scale back economies of scale you lose their efficiencies and it becomes a positive feedback loop where shipping rates increase and cost of goods increase and volumes decrease.
- nabla9 9y agoGlobal shipping is very efficient per tonne. The fuel used to ship your fruit from another side of the world is less or equal to the amount of fuel used to move the fruit from the harbor to your home. If locally produced fruit requires refrigeration, they are very likely less ecological than shipping dried fruits or canned fruits from another side of the world.
- roywiggins 9y agoWell, which would have more impact, not shipping electronics from China across the Pacific, or not shipping exotic fruits? I don't actually know, but I'm willing to wager that global supply chains for consumer goods outweighs that for foreign fruits.
- lsc 9y ago>If people stopped buying things from far away that aren't really really necessary, maybe that will also reduce fuel use. From what I understand, shipping long distances is super efficient per unit goods transported; the ship that drags whatever it is you buy across the ocean produces less carbon (per unit transported) than the truck from the port to your store, which emits less carbon per unit transported than your car going from the store to your home. If you want to save fuel, argue for good public transit, higher density housing and mixed use zoning. Or, more controversially, perhaps look into efficient delivery services that deliver a lot of groceries to people in the same area. I mean, to be clear, I'm not saying that pollution caused by larger transport should be ignored; it's probably easier to deal with pollution on a giant ship than on a thousand little cars, but my point is just that you should go after the biggest problem, that we live in low density areas and drive everywhere. Note, people say there are a lot of economic arguments for buying local, though I personally think that is harder to analyze than simple carbon emissions, and I'm not addressing that here. http://www.cleanmetrics.com/pages/ch9_0923.pdf http://www.cleanmetrics.com/pages/ch9_0923.pdf "Figure 9.3 also shows that the most energy-intensive transit link is often the last one–driving to the store. This is not surprising, because other studies, such as those by Browne et al. (2005) and Van Hauwermeiren et al. (2007), find that this link canbe the most carbon intensive even in European countries where consumers are tra- ditionally more energy conscious than their U.S. counterparts."