3 ms·
Well there isn't a solution because the metrics for "failure" and "success" are fuzzy. In my mind, someone is a "success" if they accomplish the challenge of be
by AndrewKemendo 9y ago
Well there isn't a solution because the metrics for "failure" and "success" are fuzzy. In my mind, someone is a "success" if they accomplish the challenge of being the person they see themselves as/want to be. It's way harder than it sounds.
So while there are certainly some people who, as Pickard said "made no mistakes but still lost," there are others who didn't put in sufficient effort and failed as a result.
I'd imagine that there are more in the latter camp than in the former. In your example, the professor is only a failure if their goal was something other than moderately successful academic.
- tonyedgecombe 9y agoI suspect the whole goal thing is a problem, setting some specific outcome you expect to reach when you have no idea what obstacles you might face on the way is setting yourself up for failure.
- AndrewKemendo 9y agoIndeed! Goal setting is one of the most complex tasks we do. Doing it successfully, defined as a measurable outcome, requires that you have a pretty accurate assessment of both the landscape, your abilities and the path to achieve the goal - with some factor considered for deviation from the charted path. Depending on the scope of goal, the confidence interval on probability of success probably decreases exponentially with respect to time.
- danieldk 9y agoDoing it successfully, defined as a measurable outcome, requires that you have a pretty accurate assessment of both the landscape, your abilities and the path to achieve the goal - with some factor considered for deviation from the charted path. I agree, but for longer term goals, an extremely large amount of luck involved. Sometimes the right opportunities and persons just line up. I often realize that I'd be in a completely different (and probably worse) place if my 22 and 26-year old self didn't encounter the right persons and opportunities. My current career path was largely unplanned, but is better than I hoped for or planned when I was in my early to mid-20ies.