7 ms·
Is It Time to Give Up on a Single Diagnostic Label for Autism?
- brightball 9y agoIt’s been time to do that for a while. The problem is without a good system for measurable diagnosis among physiology or symtoms, it’s complicated. This is also one of the biggest reasons that control groups to test anything around autism are such a challenge and why there’s such a vacuum around treatments that leaves parents researching and searching for their own.
- loceng 9y agoThe issue is that most doctors aren't good observers or critical thinkers, they're selected for memorization skills and not critical thinking. Of course people working on the field specifically of autism will have more experience and be able to spot the obvious cases, however I regularly come across people who have hyper- or hypo-sensitivities which are because of developmental blocks/disorder as well - and people won't even realize how much of an impact this is actually having on their whole system. There potentially are other causes to these hyper- and hypo- sensitivities that I observe, though there are a few questions can that be asked to increase the odds that it's correct, and then there are diagnostics that can confirm. How much an individual can be helped, if their developmental block can be unblocked, likely depends on when and how the block/disorder began - and that's where my interest lies.
- jrq 9y agoIt was time ten years ago. Autism is one of the most complex moving-parts mental disorders that I know of. I'm speaking about kids mainly, because that's what I'm familiar with, but some kids have mood swings and some don't, some have cognitive tempo irregularities, some have sensory disruptive effects, some have learning disability effects, some have communication difficulties, some have spatial permanence issues, some have memory issues, there are a million different components to the autism spectrum. The autism spectrum is often thought of as a number line, but it actually exists in several dozen dimensions, it's a very deep spectrum, with documented cases all over it. It gets worse now that there's so much medication flowing around, there are kids who don't have attention disorders getting put on attention meds, kids with normal social skills getting out on psychotic stabilizers. Autism has been affected strongly by how aggressively mobile the psychopharmaceutical industry has become. It's disgusting. It's completely demonic that mental illnesses are graphed and measured and these MEDICINE companies are optimizing for how much orange plastic bottles are being assigned to children! The article is right, DSM did call for it a few years ago, but it will take time and effort to reeducate doctors, the public, the children... It will take time before parents begin to realize the extent to which they are being manipulated and profiteered upon, and the effects of all these drugs in these kids will be profound. I feel strongly about this, but I'm so disenchanted with how America handles big pharma. It's a complete joke. Orange plastic and green paper is worth enough to violate the minds of our youth. Edits: it's my phone keyboard!
- kosma 9y agoAutism is not a mental illness. Please do not spread misinformation.
- fruiet 9y agoI don't know why this post has been voted down. Autism most definitely is not a mental illness. It's a disability.
- ythn 9y agoIts a general term people use to mean "not normal". What else should we call it? Everyone loves to play semantics and politics when it comes to categorising mental abnormalities. No one wants their affliction to be considered an "illness"
- neom 9y agoFor me, my autism is neither a disability nor a mental illness. Although it can be overwhelming to a degree, it seems to be a considerably different way of perceiving the world. I don't believe I'd be able to cope with too much more of it, either.
- akvadrako 9y agoWould you agree that too much of it could be classified as an illness, disability or disease?
- neom 9y agoI agree that much more of it would indeed be debilitating in the context of society, yes.
- fjsolwmv 9y agoIs any mental illness mental illness under this term? Depression, bipolar, schizophrenia, are all different ways of perceiving the world.
- neom 9y agoTo me, and I'm not a professional anything, illness is when a bodily function is not preforming as intended. I believe I'm functioning as intended, just that society is not geared for how I function. For me it's ok, I get by, for others I'm sure reality must feel like insanity. I'm grateful for what I am, and I'm sad for people who do not get to experience being grateful for what they are.
- lucidone 9y agoI have a close friend who is autistic and he teaches me something every time I spend time with him, and I really enjoy his company. Enough so that I always grab drinks with him when I head back home for the holidays. I want to tell you that you likely have the same effect on those around you.
- aditya5670 9y agohi your blog is very nice here i found new tutorial and social network https://www.welookups.com https://www.welookups.com
- empath75 9y agoProbably also for depression and attention deficit disorder as well.
- stctgion 9y agoIn the UK they moved to a single diagnosis in 2013. Before this it was autism and Asperger's. They found however that diagnosing people with the less extreme condition meant that they received less help from schools and local government.
- fjsolwmv 9y agoThis is 99% the answer. Politics (government funding, and also private insurance funding) is the tail wagging the dog. Medical community is assigning labels not based on relevant scientific taxonomy, but based on what opens purse strings. Until politics starts to respect science and constituents, doctors and parents and teachers have no choice but twist the scientific language in order to obtain the funding they need to care for their kids.
- UtilityDave 9y agoIt is partly what "opens the purse strings" but also what makes a given diagnostic and treatment protocol available. 30 years ago you could be what is called autistic now, and you would have probably been diagnosed Asperger's, or "mentally retarded" actual words of the diagnosis. For the Asperger's you would probably have been sent on your way, with an 80% chance of divorce, a 20-80% depending on who you trust higher chance of suicide than your neurotypical peers, and zero help. If you were "retarded" you would go on disability and into a group home if your parents couldn't take care of you until you died. With an autism diagnosis you get treatment, and if you get enough early enough, a 50% chance of being indistinguishable from your neurotypical peers by adulthood. So, you are right. It is much more about money than scientific taxonomy. But we made the rules. If doctors are following them to get best outcomes for their patients, aren't they doing their jobs? So it comes down to our medical system being a mess.
- JonathanMerklin 9y agoCurious, where are you pulling that "80% chance of divorce" statistic from?
- givan 9y agoAutism skyrocketed, we had 1 in 59 kids in 2014 in the us. https://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/autism/data.html https://www.cdc.gov/ncbddd/autism/data.html I don't want to even think about the present. Unfortunately autism cause research is governed by scientific dogma that prevents acknowledgement of the source of such rapid disastrous increase, this shows how scientific progress is controlled by corporations and government through funding and politics. Just like the church controlled it in the middle ages.
- taurath 9y agoAutism diagnoses skyrocketed - an important distinction. In US schools, frequently to get help for a child like in a 504 plan, or IEP, you generally need to get a diagnosis. The Autism spectrum as it is defined at the moment is so wide and vast that you can take a couple traits that could be normal neurodiversity but apply an ASD diagnosis to it. This leads to further institutionalization, medications and therapists being shoved down kids throats, by pharmaceutical companies promising to solve symptoms and "save" parents kids.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- glomph 9y agoI found this article slightly frustrating in the way it described high-functioning autism. The term is normally not used to describe higher than average IQ in the general population but higher than the average amongst people with autism. If that is made explicit then the usefulness of the term seems more obvious. What the article also didn't consider a widely used definition of the term high-functioning autism. It is often defined in terms of capacity to live autonomously at a level close to someone without autism with minimal support. If we think of the condition in these terms I believe it's usefulness as a diagnosis becomes far more apparent. It would also allow for explicit recognition that the way people experience autism can significantly change when they are given support that nurtures independence and effective strategies to live. I personally think that the people coming up with diagnostic frameworks could learn a lot from the The Capability Approach to well-being that has gained some prominence in recent philosophical discussions of the topic. Reading articles on diagnostics that do not seem to take into account the existence of such positions is frustrating because they seem to be missing an obvious way of being more effective in helping people as well as more descriptive. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/capability-approach/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/capability-approach/
- olliej 9y agoOverdiagnosis of autism seems to be a very American thing - basically getting support (financial or educational) is highly dependent on specific diagnosis, so previously someone with delayed learning would have been recognized as delayed learning, but now people have realized the most effective way to get support is to find a dr who will diagnose autism. Which is bad for everyone - support needs for people with autism is different than for other disorders, it fuels at least part of the increase in autism diagnoses since the 80s (and so the idiot antivaxxers)
- socceroos 9y agoSticks and stones may break my bones, but names will never hurt me. I've never liked that statement. Mostly because it's not true; it's just a reminder to stop letting the utterances of others affect you so much. Having said that, there's a point where we should set aside the worries of our language possibly being used to offend others and instead to just get on with it. Perhaps this is one of those times?