4 ms·
The problem for Clinton, Bush and Obama is that if you put up protectionist firewalls against cheaper goods from foreign counties with cheaper labour two things
by simonh 9y ago
The problem for Clinton, Bush and Obama is that if you put up protectionist firewalls against cheaper goods from foreign counties with cheaper labour two things happen. Firstly yes you stimulate employment in local manufacturing, but by definition all of the consumers buying those locally made goods are paying more for them.
You might have a million more manufacturing jobs, but hundreds of millions of people are paying through the nose for it. Meanwhile you may not actually make any significant difference to overall employment. Most of those million people now in manufacturing will have moved from jobs in other sectors, increasing costs in those sectors too. Meanwhile none of this does anything for America’s exports, because foreigners can still buy the same goods from your cheaper foreign competitors. In fact it can hurt exports if the goods you’re manufacturing are inputs to existing American exporters. Take steel, if American car exporters now have to buy more expensive locally made steel, the price of their cars goes up hurting car exports as well as shafting American car buyers.
- mc32 9y agoWell, the problem is they let companies skirt taxes as well as foreign concerns dump goods and never called their bluff. they allowed foreign markets to retain tariffs while we happily lowered ours --how is that in any way "fair"? Glad someone is at long last willing to take a stand. Never the less, Japan and S Korea prove the claim is not true -they are protectionist but they are not paying much higher prices and their societies benefit form that. Also, I think we're coming to the conclusion that disposable consumerism is not good --maybe expensive but good with low "velocity" is better.
- forapurpose 9y agoCan the parent support any of these claims? It's just a long string of assertions. > Japan and S Korea ... are protectionist They are not except in the absolutist sense.[0] And the U.S. protects its politically powerful industries too. In fact, the last round of the WTO was held up primarily, IIRC, by the US (and possibly Europe) refusing to lower domestic agriculture protections. Finally, you are better off if you lower tariffs even if the other side does not. Whatever 'fair' means, tariffs cause goods to be more expensive for your consumers and divert economic resources from their most productive uses to unproductive domestic companies that hide behind tariffs. It breeds corruption (as the government picks winners rather than the market) and unproductive business, instead of meritocracy of competitive businesses. [0] For example, another absolute statement is 'everyone is a liar' - obviously true in an absolute sense but meaningless. Some are far more trustworthy than others; most people are not called "liars".
- mc32 9y ago>They are not except in the absolutist sense. Tell me how many foreign auto manufacturers are allowed to build in JP and SK. What's their output?
- AFNobody 9y ago> Tell me how many foreign auto manufacturers are allowed to build in JP and SK. What's their output? Which is you admitting the OP is correct btw. They are protecting a few politically important industries just like the US does. Or do you genuinely think all those IP protectionist bs the US shoves in treaties is different?
- dcow 9y agoThe massive elephant sitting in the corner is that it's more expensive to pay for American workers because we have laws and regulations that protect them and ensure they have a decent quality of life. So now it becomes an ethical problem and we all know what to do when we encounter a difficult one of those: shift liability to a corporate entity and chalk up the negative ethical aspects as economics. (I'm not the one exploiting foreign labor, that's mega corp.) The greatest feature of globalization is that it distances consumers from the source of the goods they consume. This might be "good" for the consumers in the short term, but it's absolutely not good for their s/economy/quality of life/ in the long run. What's the effect of instant gratification global capitalism? The American economy now has to compete with the foreign economy. If workers in the foreign country experience a lower quality of life in order to sustain American consumers, then the American worker gets shafted because they have to lower their quality of life to compete. If they won't or can't (because we consider those conditions too inhumane for our own workers) then they have to find new work. Globalism is the great equalizer. EDIT: I'm not necessarily saying this is bad for the world (except that human rights and quality of life regress to the mean), and one can also argue that the freed up resources might be put to more.. sophisticated.. uses. I don't know... I'm responding to the parent: the only way globalizing an economy is good for a strong country (one sitting above the mean) is if you define good in a strictly economic sense like "lowest prices for the consumer" (which is the premise of the parent's argument). It's easy for an economist to do that in isolation because that's the name of the game. A government, however, is not tasked with driving down prices for consumers (that's a market's job) but rather is responsible for roughly maintaining quality of life for its citizens and with protecting its workers, among many other things. Allowing the economy to run unchecked at a global scale essentially equates to selling out the workers. It's not just about who's consumers get the lowest price at the end of the day.
- burfog 9y agoYes, as long as you take "protect them and ensure they have a decent quality of life" to not include employment! We're telling grown adults what they can't do, supposedly for their own good. That quote from C. S. Lewis applies: “Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron's cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience.”