5 ms·
>What will happen is that the EU will just have access to a dramatically smaller array of sites on the Internet Let's be real here for a second, what's your de
by Barrin92 9y ago
>What will happen is that the EU will just have access to a dramatically smaller array of sites on the Internet
Let's be real here for a second, what's your definition of dramatic? I don't foresee the EU losing access to more than a handful of services, many of which as in the case above provide questionable products.
I'm very much doubting that we'll be talking here in a year and the EU somehow finds itself behind the great-GDPRwall. That's just arbitrary panic.
>Consumer choice is a good thing, and this law will dramatically limit it.
You're neglecting the fact that consumers can make collective choices about the things they do not want to put up with. Abuse of private data is one such domain. There is no iron law of the business world that consumers need to accept every product of any kind on every market. That's up for societies to decide. The law seems to be quite popular from what I can see, so any cost that we European consumers do actually incur, we are apparently happy to endure.
- downandout 9y agoLet's be real here for a second, what's your definition of dramatic? I don't foresee the EU losing access to more than a handful of services, many of which as in the case above provide questionable products. As horror stories come out and geoblocking tools become easy to use, I'd say that over the next few years, the vast majority of non-EU sites will have blocked EU traffic. Nobody wants the liability unless they make a large percentage of their revenue from EU countries. Accepting such traffic means exposing your business to instant financial annihilation at the whim of a foreign government.
- hluska 9y agoI'm sorry, but that last phrase "instant financial annihilation at the whim of a foreign government" is so hyperbolic as to border on FUD. Here is a fact. If your business complied with EU data protection laws, GDPR is only an incremental step. And, here is another fact. The EU is nowhere near as litigious as the United States. GDPR may levy some intense fines at repeat offenders, particularly those who haven't been in compliance with any data security/protection law from the last twenty years. But to claim "financial annihilation at the whim of a foreign government"?? That's just poor taste.
- downandout 9y agoTo me, $10 or $20 million would indeed be instant financial annihilation.
- throwaway-hn123 9y agoGreat. You've made your decision, can you get on with geoblocking the EU and stop your fucking whining, please?
- briandear 9y agoYou hope. Any proof in the text of the law to back that up? From a risk management perspective, doing any business in the EU is dangerous because even if you are doing it right, the potential exists that you’ll have to defend GDPR claims. That’s a real liability. Of course, as I have said before, that’s probably by design since Europe, especially France, has a real inferiority complex with foreign tech. Examples: France suing Apple over developer fees. France blocking the sale of DailyMotion to Yahoo. The war against Uber with the simultaneous promotion of BlaBlaCar, the attacks against Apple for taxes on income that wasn’t even earned in France, the collective freak-out over AirBnB while subsidizing Gites de France. My point is that exposing yourself to the risk of a European money-grab is too high. Besides, who benefits from collected fines? Governments. Those fines don’t get paid to the aggrieved party, they get paid to the government. Governments have an incentive to levy fines on foreign companies, with very little downside — European jobs aren’t at risk. The attack surface is just too great to be using “hope” as a strategy.
- hluska 9y agoSure. Read sections 58 and 83 of the GDPR. http://www.privacy-regulation.eu/en/article-83-general-conditions-for-imposing-administrative-fines-GDPR.htm http://www.privacy-regulation.eu/en/article-83-general-condi... http://www.privacy-regulation.eu/en/article-58-powers-GDPR.htm http://www.privacy-regulation.eu/en/article-58-powers-GDPR.h... Section 58 is about EU powers under the GDPR. Section 83 gets into the spirit and purpose of fines levied. Being overly punitive would only invite judicial oversight.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago>> There is no iron law of the business world that consumers need to accept every product of any kind on every market. My understanding is that "consumer choice" is a code for radical deregulation of the markets until all the "choices" that the consumer is left with are each as bad as the other. "Sure, you can go to our competitor, but they hoover up your data just like we do".