3 ms·
If it were "brain dead obvious" we wouldn't need to argue about it. It's not actually obvious whether personal observations are representative of what's going
by skybrian 9y ago
If it were "brain dead obvious" we wouldn't need to argue about it.
It's not actually obvious whether personal observations are representative of what's going on in other parts of the country that you've never visited. Even if you're well-travelled, you can't see everything. Reporters can't see everything either, and newspapers give us a very biased view of the world.
That's why we rely on statistics, and they're notoriously difficult to get right.
In the end, I'm like: "Studies? You can prove anything with studies." Each study is part of a conversation among economists, and I doubt this will be the last word.
- atom_arranger 9y agoAbove comment is saying people don't trust studies and economists. Studies and economists can be bought.
- forapurpose 9y ago'X can be bought' can be written about anything. You can be bought. But what does it mean? We live in a world of uncertainty, but it's not at all true that everything is equally uncertain. An MD is more reliable than a guy in a bar when talking about medicine. An economist is also more reliable, as are certain economists and economic institutions, as are the consensus of economists.
- weirdstuff 9y agoAlchemists were experts on alchemy, but now we know their insights weren't all that useful for what they intended. (Although they were some of the smartest minds in their day.) Same might be true for many economists. We like to think we've got the right experts, but it turns out we really don't know if the so-called experts have the most useful perspective on matters.
- atom_arranger 9y agoYeah, you're right. I think I just particularly mistrust economists. It's partially that if these new studies are correct it's just amazing how so many economists could be so wrong about something that seems so obvious. I can't even fathom it without imagining they were paid off. Funny thing is I know people who will bring up talking points of economists in real life while ignoring the "reality on the ground", and I know they aren't paid for. They won't even consider that the economists might be wrong. Maybe there's just been a lot of groupthink in economics.
- forapurpose 9y ago> how so many economists could be so wrong about something that seems so obvious My experience is that with very rare exceptions, if I think experts who study an issue are all so obviously wrong, then I'm the one who misunderstands something (about the facts, the experts, or who knows what). The 'everyone's an idiot and missing the obvious' theory rarely holds up. The study is interesting. Let's not get carried away with the interpretations of a bunch of HN users, of one news report, about one economic study, by a small research institute in Kalamazoo MI.
- atom_arranger 9y agoExperts have been wrong about a lot of things in the past. In this case I'm not saying "everyone is an idiot and missing the obvious", I'm saying "politicians and economists are idiots and are missing the obvious", because this is a case where the average non-academic person would intuitively believe outsourcing would be bad for American industry in the long run. I'm not saying that more research shouldn't be done into this, but if it's correct than the incorrect conclusions of economists helped to decimate the American manufacturing industry. If this is the case then how did things go so wrong, and how do we avoid something like this in the future?
- jschwartzi 9y agoIt's pretty hard for me to trust economic information that isn't produced by boots-on-the ground data collection. To that point, if the manufacturing sector were booming in the US, how would you explain the countless anecdotes about Americans being laid off and their jobs being outsourced? Where is the analysis that shows these are isolated anecdotes and not stories reflective of a larger trend?
- mistermann 9y ago> Where is the analysis that shows these are isolated anecdotes and not stories reflective of a larger trend? You've just stumbled upon the secret to how corporatists have taken over the west. It seems to me, most any Westerner with a university degree will believe any story they're told, provided the story fits a general narrative, and the person telling the story has a degree or it is printed by one of several accepted "authoritative" sources. Whether it matches what they see when they leave their desk and walk around in the real world seems to make utterly no difference.
- skybrian 9y agoThe info described in this report is produced based on that kind of data collection (government statistics, etc). The problem is, nobody noticed a mistake in the analysis. We should distinguish between our suspicions (hey, this looks weird) and investigation. Gut instinct and anecdotal reports are a good source of suspicion, but suspicion without investigation mostly just generates lots of online blather. So, it's great that some economists were not only suspicious, but did something about it. Too bad it didn't happen sooner! But maybe there are more mistakes?
- IkmoIkmo 9y agoYeah this article just presents a recent narrative from a recent study, it doesn't mean it's right. Fact is, the social sciences have completely opposite theories with completely opposite causal mechanisms or even opposite ideas about outcomes and conceptualisation. These studies can't even agree on the dependent variable, let alone the independent variable. And they're all championed by top ivy league scholars. Take the article's theme for example, globalisation and job security. In public administration there's two hypotheses about the way the welfare state responds to job insecurity from globalisation. One is the efficiency hypothesis which expects the welfare state to retrench and become smaller, assuming increased competition forces a sort of race to the bottom effect in order for a state to stay competitive. The other, the compensation hypothesis, expects the welfare state to expand in order to compensate the losers of globalisation (e.g. factory workers in the US). A whole range of studies exist that show evidence for both hypotheses. They keep getting better, moving from correlation to causation, from aggregates to specifics, towards clearer conceptualisation and a semblance of a consensus. But for decades, this is a field where articles were getting published which could easily be written about in newspapers in an incendiary manner like OP's article about how 'we used to get it all wrong', and linking it to some recent populist movement, explaining how it all wasn't so crazy after all. It's silly. Studies are valuable, but anyone who spent any time in academia, even as a student, should notice studies never translate well to journalism. It's particularly apparent reading about a field he/she is familiar with. The number of times I cared to look into the research underlying news articles and came out thinking 'this article is nonsense' is tiring. And it's no surprise, I'm guilty of the same behavior of journalists. Either it's ignorance because I'm not a specialist in my field, or I just don't care. I've written a bunch of school assignments taking positions that were blatantly false, ignoring a whole range of literature that didn't agree while making it appear as if I was being nuanced, just to get the essay out of the way. Journalists are likely not much different.