4 ms·
I've heard this sentiment being expressed by at least one person in all of these threads, but you're one of the first that actually mentions having consulted wi
by lucb1e 9y ago
I've heard this sentiment being expressed by at least one person in all of these threads, but you're one of the first that actually mentions having consulted with a lawyer. The thing I keep asking is: what is new? I have yet to hear anything non-trivial which a company suddenly has to do, which wasn't required by any EU country before.
The only new thing seems to be higher fines and aligning laws in all EU countries, rather than having different implementations of roughly the same thing. But if you don't comply with GDPR, odds are that you should never have been able to do business with a lot of European countries. To the best of my knowledge, you should have geoblocked the Netherlands long ago (the only country I know the laws well enough of, to say that there is truly only a small difference between the 2002 WBP and the new GDPR) if you have to close to the EU for GDPR.
- downandout 9y agoThe biggest 2 issues (at least for non-EU companies) are the extraterritorial reach, and the absurd maximum fines that can indeed be assessed for a first, single violation. Whether or not that is the public's understanding of the law, that is how it is written, and when it comes to enforcement, the letter of the law is the only thing that matters. So we have a foreign government (to us) that has asserted authority to reach beyond its borders and into our pockets with an absurdly complex regulation, where a single violation would financially destroy the company. Since I don't have $20 million to give to them, and the families of my employees depend on their income for things like food and housing, I have to either carry expensive liability insurance to protect against that, or block EU traffic. For us, and I suspect most other sites on the planet, that's an easy decision to make. I'll take a 5%-10% hit in revenue from the loss of EU traffic and be able to sleep at night knowing that someone in a country I've never been to isn't out there filing documents that have the ability to destroy my and my employees' livelihoods. I won't go into the minutiae of why it's so easy to violate and why most of the experts we have spoken to agree that being compliant is an uncertain endeavor at best, even if you want to comply, because that would be a very long winded comment. But if you do a Google search, you'll see the gist of the problems.
- lucb1e 9y agoThanks for responding! I was hoping someone would finally bring up concrete points after talking to a lawyer, and you have. It still doesn't sound like a big deal to me (you don't mention anything in-depth, only that the law can now actually harm you both in terms of jurisdiction and non-trivial fines), but I see where you're coming from.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago>> Thanks for responding! I was hoping someone would finally bring up concrete points after talking to a lawyer, and you have. Can you please quote the "concrete points" made in the parent post?
- lucb1e 9y agoSure, it's in the first line: > the extraterritorial reach, and the absurd maximum fines that can indeed be assessed for a first, single violation As I said in my comment, I don't think those are big issues if you comply with the law (and 99% of the law is common sense or was already in place in most countries), but they are points that a lawyer might indeed have brought up.
- amyjess 9y agoIf you don't have offices in the EU, and you don't keep your money in any accounts controlled by EU banks, then why not just refuse to pay the fines? Might be a good opportunity to make some contacts in the Trump administration too, who will be interested in asserting US sovereignty.
- downandout 9y agoAccording to the people we have spoken to, it's reasonably possible that judgments for GDPR fines can be domesticated in the US. Once domesticated, they carry the same force and effect as a judgment issued by a US court. The legal processes for this generally already exist, although there are no GDPR-specific treaties, and it isn't guaranteed that this would occur for GDPR fines - it would be up to the US court system. Like many other aspects of GDPR, it is uncertain at this time. However, I don't want to be the first test case.
- briandear 9y agoI can’t comply with HIPPA and GDPR and since HIPPA applies to any US based medical practitioners, that essentially cuts off all Europeans from using our services — so people in Europe who have a US based therapist — we can’t legally allow that anymore — assuming we want to be GDPR compliant. How can we be required to delete IP addresses in our logs yet also be required to keep access audit logs for 7 years. A bullshit law written by people that assume everyone is Facebook and data mining.
- craigsmansion 9y ago> How can we be required to delete IP addresses in our logs yet also be required to keep access audit logs for 7 years. I don't know where you got this idea, but I strongly suggest you find someone who has experience with the GDPR and discuss this with them. These two things are not even remotely close to any grey areas that could land someone in hot water.
- arthens 9y ago> How can we be required to delete IP addresses in our logs yet also be required to keep access audit logs for 7 years. IANAL but from what I read and heard (indirectly) from lawyers at work this is not a problem. GDPR doesn't apply to data that you are required to keep for other legal reasons.
- deecewan 9y agoI also ANAL, but heard this same thing directly when I asked this question at my company's GDPR briefing
- M2Ys4U 9y ago>How can we be required to delete IP addresses in our logs yet also be required to keep access audit logs for 7 years. Then you may well be able to rely on the Legal Obligation basis for processing, namely that “processing is necessary for compliance with a legal obligation to which the controller is subject.”
- FireBeyond 9y ago
- briandear 9y agoRe: geoblocking — that’s the problem with this law. Shouldn’t individuals be allowed to consent to their data being used? Shouldn’t individuals be allowed to choose what services they use? What about VPN? A Dutch citizen is still Dutch regardless of their IP address and thus they are still “protected” regardless of IP. Also discrimination based on citizenship or national origin is illegal, but to comply with GDPR, we’re going to be forced to discriminate. Europeans are going to become second class digital citizens because compliance risk is simply too high except for the Facebooks and Googles of the world. The law has a bunch of unintended consequences that are about to be unleashed. Or maybe, they are consequences that are fully indended: a de facto trade barrier against non-European companies who’s own laws conflict with GDPR.
- lucb1e 9y ago> Shouldn’t individuals be allowed to consent to their data being used? They are. You just need to tell them what you want to do with their data, and then do what you told them you were going to do. And not something additional ("oh hey look at all these IP addresses stored for security purposes, I bet we could make funny graphs about Bob's sleeping schedule too!") That is apparently too hard for many companies, so now this is codified in law and can actually be enforced. There are some additional clauses like right to view your data, correct it if incorrect, and remove it if there is no longer a need for it... but that has existed in Dutch law since 2002 and few people ever exercise it. I recently did for the first time when I found out someone was doing WiFi tracking based on MAC addresses (I didn't remember giving consent), and I got an email from them (which looked like it took 15 minutes to look my data up and type it out), so it's not such a big deal.
- s17n 9y agoThe whole concept that people have ownership of any information about themselves is new. If I take a picture of my friend Bob, or write an article about him, and upload it to your website, you now have an obligation to Bob.