3 ms·
I do understand that it might also hit legitimate business models that many users enjoy and that it can be stressful for businesses who deal with userdata in be
by Barrin92 9y ago
I do understand that it might also hit legitimate business models that many users enjoy and that it can be stressful for businesses who deal with userdata in best interests, but on the other hand there really is no way to overhaul important regulation like this without any kind of friction.
The laws need to be broad enough to apply to everyone and have the intended effect, which means that especially in the early stages with a lack of clarity and guidelines it's goig to be a little messy.
But I look at it like I'd look at a 20th century environmental regulation. Yes, it might impact genuinely good businesses, but at some point you have to do it if you want to advance user interests. I don't really see a better point than now.
- downandout 9y agoWhat will happen is that the EU will just have access to a dramatically smaller array of sites on the Internet - like a self-imposed Great Firewall. The only services that can even afford to attempt to comply and have the necessary liability insurance against fines are massive companies - think Facebook and Google. The problem with that is that if your data is in the hands of a few large players, and you have limited choices for the services they offer, the whole concept of "affirmative consent" is pointless because you have few choices about whom you give that consent to. So it isn't businesses that GDPR hurts (except for those that rely on EU traffic, who will make up for GDPR costs somehow - at your expense), it's actually the EU itself. Consumer choice is a good thing, and this law will dramatically limit it.
- craigsmansion 9y ago> The only services that can even afford to attempt to comply and have the necessary liability insurance Liability for what? You're not going to get sued. At worst you're going to get fined for negligence, probably after after repeated warnings. I don't think you can find insurance against willful repeated misconduct. It's only if your service can't possibly comply without losing your bottom line that you have to worry, in which case the GDPR is working as intended. Find a better business model for EU costumers, or cease your presence there. It's a win-win for EU consumers either way.
- glogla 9y ago> Liability for what? You're not going to get sued. Yes, this is the most confusing thing - a lot of posters talk about "being sued because of GDPR" but that's not how it works. And it's always people with the same arguments - small companies, getting sued, crazy money for lawyers, etc. If I was paranoid, I would think this is some kind of organized campaign to spread FUD and have as many people be against GDPR as possible, perhaps as a way to make sure something similar won't happen in the US. It's probably just misinformed people.
- craigsmansion 9y ago> It's probably just misinformed people. Probably. There seems to be a real disconnect between US and EU perception of legal and business landscapes here, with the US worrying about the EU legislation more than those based in the EU, who would be far more affected by it (after all, they can't "shut out" Europe).
- Silhouette 9y agoAnd it's always people with the same arguments - small companies, getting sued, crazy money for lawyers, etc. One of those things is not like the others. I have no idea where the meme about exploitative lawyers looking for minor non-compliance came from, because the primary means of enforcement under the GDPR is regulatory action. The whole strategy of threatening legal action to prompt a profitable out of court settlement is much less viable under typical EU legal systems than in the US anyway. However, GDPR definitely can cause significant compliance overheads for small organisations, including those who have done nothing wrong. The official guidance is still terrible, and just the uncertainty around several key points is a problem for reasons we've previously discussed at length on HN. Trusting in regulators to do the right thing is also a risky strategy. I write this as someone whose business really did receive a crippling demand for monies never owed direct from an EU government tax office after the VAT changes, with very scary accompanying threats and impossibly short timescales to respond, and there were many thousands of other small businesses similarly attacked just in the incidents I'm personally aware of. From a pragmatic point of view, the regulator in my country is well known to be under-funded and under-staffed, but even that doesn't necessarily help because as with other issues within their remit, it makes smaller organisations easier targets than those with big legal departments to fight back.
- slimshady94 9y agoWhy can't databases and DBMS systems come out with GDPR-compliant integrations that automatically provide the required data-wipe services? Surely it won't be so difficult to have built-in triggers/scripts that delete data etc automatically? And if the entire ecosystem uses these tools, it'll be better for everyone, and the onboarding/integration even for startups can be easy as well - maybe as easy as simply installing an NPM package.
- drspacemonkey 9y agoThe more difficult part is deletion from backups, which is also a requirement. IMO, the best solution is per-row encryption with the keys stored in a second database. This second database can still be backed up, with backups that have a maximum lifespan, eg: 30 days. When a user deletes their account, their decryption key is deleted, and is unrecoverable after the backup max life.
- kelnos 9y ago> The more difficult part is deletion from backups, which is also a requirement. How long do you keep your backups? If you just store them for, say, 30 days, that's fine. The EU regulators aren't going to come after you for a 30-day lag for all traces of data to be deleted, as long as that process is documented. There's still one annoyance left: you do need to keep track of accounts/users who have deleted data, so if you have to restore from a backup, you can't restore any data belonging to users who have deleted their data within that window. Otherwise, this is frankly not such a big deal. If you're storing backups for longer than 30 days, why? Where I work, if we had to restore from a 30-day-old backup, it'd be catastrophic for the business given how much data would be lost.
- portent 9y agoMany regulated industries need to store data for multiple years, often in a secure format e.g. WORM storage
- 9y ago
- Barrin92 9y ago>What will happen is that the EU will just have access to a dramatically smaller array of sites on the Internet Let's be real here for a second, what's your definition of dramatic? I don't foresee the EU losing access to more than a handful of services, many of which as in the case above provide questionable products. I'm very much doubting that we'll be talking here in a year and the EU somehow finds itself behind the great-GDPRwall. That's just arbitrary panic. >Consumer choice is a good thing, and this law will dramatically limit it. You're neglecting the fact that consumers can make collective choices about the things they do not want to put up with. Abuse of private data is one such domain. There is no iron law of the business world that consumers need to accept every product of any kind on every market. That's up for societies to decide. The law seems to be quite popular from what I can see, so any cost that we European consumers do actually incur, we are apparently happy to endure.
- downandout 9y agoLet's be real here for a second, what's your definition of dramatic? I don't foresee the EU losing access to more than a handful of services, many of which as in the case above provide questionable products. As horror stories come out and geoblocking tools become easy to use, I'd say that over the next few years, the vast majority of non-EU sites will have blocked EU traffic. Nobody wants the liability unless they make a large percentage of their revenue from EU countries. Accepting such traffic means exposing your business to instant financial annihilation at the whim of a foreign government.
- hluska 9y agoI'm sorry, but that last phrase "instant financial annihilation at the whim of a foreign government" is so hyperbolic as to border on FUD. Here is a fact. If your business complied with EU data protection laws, GDPR is only an incremental step. And, here is another fact. The EU is nowhere near as litigious as the United States. GDPR may levy some intense fines at repeat offenders, particularly those who haven't been in compliance with any data security/protection law from the last twenty years. But to claim "financial annihilation at the whim of a foreign government"?? That's just poor taste.
- gerdesj 9y agoWhat will happen is that the EU will just have access to a dramatically smaller array of sites on the Internet Bollocks. I run a small (IT) business in the UK. I will have just as much internet as you post 25 May. The difference may be that my company and others in the EU might automatically be perceived as more trustworthy than those that do not comply with GDPR and hence we may benefit.
- Silhouette 9y agoI also have small businesses in the UK, so we also have no choice about complying. The abundance of caution described by downandout here seems excessive, even to me as a confirmed GDPR critic, but to good actors of the kind mentioned, the GDPR is basically just an exercise in bureaucracy, cost overheads, and uncertainty. Things might be different for B2B service providers, but if we make a single extra penny from anything to do with this whole mess in B2C world, I'll be amazed.
- gerdesj 9y agobut if we make a single extra penny from anything to do with this whole mess in B2C world, I'll be amazed. GDPR is not a money making exercise. My company has a wiki page called "Risks and Opportunities". GDPR is definitively under Opp. these days - for us and our customers. I also quite like it as a person - a private individual.
- ocdtrekkie 9y agoI will generally indeed be more inclined to interact with EU sites since I know they are GDPR compliant. I'd honestly be really tempted to VPN to Europe so that US companies think I'm an EU citizen too. The most interesting thing to me about this whole ordeal is which companies only comply in Europe, where they're legally required, and those who have gone ahead and made sure they are compliant globally: It defines the difference between people ensuring your privacy rights because they have to, where they have to, and those ensuring your privacy rights globally because it's the right thing to do. Google's AMP project just introduced a whole set of new features not just to mark whether or not an EU user has consented to tracking, but also a new feature to geolocate users, specifically for the purpose of determining if they're legally required to get that consent. Which is sad to me; they should be getting user consent everywhere.
- kelnos 9y ago> The only services that can even afford to attempt to comply and have the necessary liability insurance against fines are massive companies - think Facebook and Google. This is a gross exaggeration. I agree that truly small companies may have issues, but companies way smaller than FB and Google can and are spending the time to comply.
- godzillabrennus 9y agoShort term you are right. Long term our understanding of the law will grow and we will build solutions for the EU market.
- oneeyedpigeon 9y agoThe biggest issue for me is the punitive fines: 4% of revenue or €20 million whichever is greater. That just punishes small companies disproportionately.
- TazeTSchnitzel 9y agoThis is a maximum fine. You would not be fined that for a first, unintended offence. You would be warned.
- downandout 9y agoThis is a maximum fine. You would not be fined that for a first, unintended offence. You would be warned. You don't know that. Show me where, written in the GDPR, it says that warnings must be issued or that there are any circumstances under which the maximum fine must not be imposed. I'll save you some time. It's not there.
- egourlao 9y agoArticle 83: > When deciding whether to impose an administrative fine and deciding on the amount of the administrative fine in each individual case due regard shall be given to [...] the degree of cooperation with the supervisory authority, in order to remedy the infringement and mitigate the possible adverse effects of the infringement. https://gdpr-info.eu/art-83-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-83-gdpr/
- downandout 9y agoThat doesn't limit their ability to impose the maximum fine for a first, single violation. It says they should consider some things. But it does not limit their statutory ability to impose the maximum without warning.
- Latty 9y agoIn terms of liability insurance, which is the claim here though, the reality is the insurer knows that the EU isn't going to dump 20 million fines on every small company making a first offence. The idea that they are going to treat it like that's the likely outcome is insane.