4 ms·
Everytime you see news of a company" not being able to operate due to" or "shutting down because of" GDPR, the only actual reason is "our business model is unso
by dmitriid 9y ago
Everytime you see news of a company" not being able to operate due to" or "shutting down because of" GDPR, the only actual reason is "our business model is unsolicited unrestricted access to, processing of, and selling of personal data."
So sad to see these businesses go (not)
- megaman22 9y agoOr they are not actually doing anything shady, but the revenue coming in from the EU is not sufficient to justify the increased costs and liabilities.
- geofft 9y agoDo you have an example of this? I totally believe this is possible, but every thing I've seen in practice has matched GP's description.
- megaman22 9y agoThere was at least one that landed on the front page this week. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16954306 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16954306
- geofft 9y agoThanks. Interesting that some folks in the comments say "actually, this site was abusing your data to make money" - but I don't have a good sense of whether a similar site that didn't use Amazon ads, and either took a small membership fee or was run out of the founder's pocket as a side project, would have things to worry about from GDPR. On the flip side, does anyone know of side projects or community projects that have said "We chatted with a European lawyer, who said we don't have anything to worry about, and we'll keep doing our thing"? I know Debian is having that chat (https://lists.debian.org/debian-devel-announce/2018/04/msg00012.html https://lists.debian.org/debian-devel-announce/2018/04/msg00... - and there are some privacy things I think Debian should change, like not keeping people's support emails from years ago public) but I'm curious about projects that are smaller in scope and are basically not trying to hold personal data at all.
- y_molodtsov 9y agoThere also was some online game that did the same, I doubt they had a lot of user data.
- krapp 9y ago> Or they are not actually doing anything shady, but the revenue coming in from the EU is not sufficient to justify the increased costs and liabilities. Refusing to protect your users from your own predatory use of their personal data because the ROI isn't there is still shady.
- ben_jones 9y agoOr it's a free pass to cut out a less profitable market segment. Or it's an excuse for bad developers. Or its an excuse to shift blame from your already failing business.
- nukeop 9y agoExactly, the GDPR regulations are completely reasonable and it's actually quite odd to see them being put into practice so late. The user data selling wild west had to be regulated at some point to curb predatory practices of Google, Facebook, and many others. If your business model isn't based on exploitation and profiling, it isn't hard at all to comply with GDPR.
- Hamuko 9y agoYeah, I've wondered why everyone has been so late to the party. I mean, we have lived in a world with GDPR for two years now. Companies should have already been complying with it for two years. There was just a transitional period during which there was no enforcement. Then there's all the GDPR expert blog posts, blasting the EU for not giving any leeway or transition periods. You were in it!
- tchock23 9y agoSome of us running small businesses don’t spend our free time studying up on the latest in EU regulations. I only found out about it through a random comment on HN in March.
- nukeop 9y agoCool, then you probably don't care about EU customers anyway
- tchock23 9y agoActually, I do. They represent 30% to 40% of my business (depending on the month). GDPR compliance has cost me a ton of time and money. Wish someone could have notified me somehow before I randomly found out in March because it completely derailed our development roadmap.
- drivingmenuts 9y agoI did some work for a small game company that collects an email address as part of the registration for a contest within the mobile game. They may well be shut out of the EU now, which is sad, because I know for a fact there was zero malicious intent.
- craigsmansion 9y ago> collects an email address as part of the registration [..] they may well be shut out of the EU now Why would that be? I think there's a lot of misunderstanding and/or uncertainty about the scope of the GDPR. The fact itself that you know, for a fact, there is no malicious intent, means that the GPDR will have little to no bearing on you. If you're having a simple free e-mail raffle of goodies for a list of players that signed up for that, there's nothing that prevents you from doing that. What would change is that if someone asks you what you have on them, you have to mail back "we have your email address in a list of email addresses", and you have to really delete it if they request it. These are things any decent company would normally comply with regardless. It's only problematic if you would be harvesting data for non-transparent purposes, but that's not something that could reasonable be included with "zero malicious intent".
- ginko 9y ago>They may well be shut out of the EU now Why would you think that? Collecting email addresses for an optional contest is a legitimate use case. The company just needs to ensure that these addresses are stored securely and must give users the option to get their data deleted.