21 ms·
Prevalence of vitamin D deficiency in adults admitted to psychiatric hospital
- yosito 9y agoTL;DR the jury is still out on whether or not you need the D for your mental health.
- TheForumTroll 9y agoNot really. Lots of research links lack of Vitamin D* to schizophrenia. *- I assume you meant Cholecalciferol (Vit. D3) with "D". If not, please go back to Reddit.
- yosito 9y agoI'm not sure if I got downvoted for the joke, or because people think I'm wrong, but near the end of the study it says "At the current time, there is insufficient evidence to draw any firm conclusions regarding an association between vitamin D deficiency and non-musculoskeletal health outcomes, including mental illness." So the jury is in fact out on whether or not you need vitamin D for your mental health.
- TheForumTroll 9y agoBoth. One is a Reddit joke and the other is wrong no matter what the linked article says. There are hundreds of studies that link mental health problems like Schizophrenia and Vit.d deficiency.
- jrochkind1 9y agoNo comparison to prevalence of vitamin D deficiency in the general population?
- ekianjo 9y agoThey had to rush to publish their paper?
- cjbprime 9y agoThey might not have the correct data for comparison -- you'd need to control for climate, so national or international rate of deficiency wouldn't be a good comparison.
- jrochkind1 9y agoSure. But I'm not sure what the takeaway is without it. I guess just another data point for future analysis. Or yeah, another paper for someone's CV and tenure promotion.
- m4burns 9y agoThis is close to the rate of vitamin D deficiency in the general population, e.g. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21310306 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/21310306
- tfehring 9y agoThe study you linked was based on a threshold of 50 nmol/L, while the originally posted study used two thresholds, 30 nmol/L and 50 nmol/L. At the 50 nmol/L cutoff, the study you linked indicates a deficiency rate of 41.6% for the general population, compared to a rate of 91.3% among psychiatric patients according to the posted study. I’d still take the posted study with a grain of salt. Vitamin D deficiency between individuals is likely to be highly correlated within a particular region and time period due to its dependence on weather, and the authors didn’t control for that. But they did say that this was just a pilot, and given the effect size it’s probably worth investigating further. Edit: fixed units
- petra 9y agoRegarding the weather: most people most often stay indoors or in cars(does the glass filter the Vitmain-D causing rays), and usually wear long pants and a shirt, so only a small body area is exposed to the sun, so it's possible that even in summer, people suffer from Vitamin-D deficiency.
- tfehring 9y agoYeah, absolutely - most regions probably have a nonzero population with Vitamin D deficiency year-round. But if I had to pick a place and time at which the overall rate of Vitamin D deficiency is high, the UK in February through April seems like a safe bet.
- mikehotel 9y agoBe careful with increased exposure to sunlight. UV is a known carcinogen. https://www.cancer.org/cancer/cancer-causes/radiation-exposure/uv-radiation/uv-radiation-does-uv-cause-cancer.html https://www.cancer.org/cancer/cancer-causes/radiation-exposu... There are safer sources of vitamin D.
- mrfusion 9y agoso you’d expect to see fewer cases the further south go. I wonder how that holds up?
- vostok 9y agoYou would need to be careful about comparing areas that are otherwise similar or do something more sophisticated than merely comparing rates of psychiatric hospitalization between two areas. Average incomes and other factors are probably important too.
- wolco 9y agoMany homeless/sick move south so rates between regions may be affected.
- dghughes 9y agoI'd say there are too many factors to guess. People sitting inside all day in offices and when people get home. Driving everywhere so barely outside at all only briefly. Various levels of skin pigmentation each would block various amounts of sun especially in northern latitudes. Clothing style covering more to block sun exposure to prevent skin damage or prevent skin cancer, or after a skin cancer diagnosis.
- smt88 9y agoSomething worth noting is that many mental illnesses cause symptoms (lack of motivation, social anxiety, fear of leaving the house, etc.) that make people less likely to go outside.
- fb03 9y agoSadly you can't affirm that to all of the affected population, that needs testing. Some mentally ill people like to go out and walk mindlessly all day long. I am sure you know some 'walkers' in your vicinity, there's always one.
- smt88 9y agoCausality needs testing, but correlation isn't a wild leap. 25% of Americans suffer from either depression or anxiety, and the next-highest disorder isn't even close[1]. Those ambulatory people are highly visible, but a tiny fraction of the overall population. 1. https://www.nami.org/learn-more/mental-health-by-the-numbers https://www.nami.org/learn-more/mental-health-by-the-numbers
- goldenkey 9y agoPrevious relevant discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16771044 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16771044
- nabla9 9y ago> It is unclear why the prevalence of vitamin D deficiency found in this study was higher compared with the general population. There are relatively large number of studies linking vitamin D deficiency and mental illness. This is not the best study to use as point of discussion. I'm sure there are review articles. edit: like this: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/the-british-journal-of-psychiatry/article/vitamin-d-deficiency-and-depression-in-adults-systematic-review-and-metaanalysis/F4E7DFBE5A7B99C9E6430AF472286860 https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/the-british-journal-... and this: https://academic.oup.com/jcem/article/99/10/3863/2836573 https://academic.oup.com/jcem/article/99/10/3863/2836573 TL;DR: There is a link but randomized trials are needed to find the causal link.
- yelloweyes 9y agomentally ill > stays inside more often not really a hard conclusion to reach
- red75prime 9y agoWhat's left is to test this hypothesis.
- DanBC 9y agoYou haven't tested Mentally ill > lives on the streets in the sun all day
- Bakary 9y agoIt's not the actual presence in a dwelling that is the detrimental to mood but the implied lack of social interaction or meaningful pursuits. A homeless person can have those same problems to a greater extent and with other health issues included.
- jacquesm 9y agoWhat about other deficiencies? Other vitamins and nutrients? You'd expect people that are admitted to psychiatric hospitals to have more than one deficiency since they might not be able to take good care of themselves.
- econochoice 9y agoSearch for micronutrient deficiencies + a psychiatric condition on PubMed and you'll get many results. Off the top of my head zinc, magnesium, various forms of B-vitamins and selenium imbalances are seen in different disorders. Zinc deficiency in depression, zinc overabundance in schizophrenia. Both zinc and magnesium seem to have roles in NMDA neurotransmission. B-vitamins play a role in neurotransmitter production.
- conorh 9y agoIf you are going to supplement your vitamin D, just make sure to monitor your calcium too. My wife sees patients taking high doses of vitamin D, because their doctor puts them on it, or they do it themselves, and they do not realize that they are doing massive damage to their bodies because their low vitamin D levels are caused by a parathyroid tumor. http://www.parathyroid.com/low-vitamin-d.htm http://www.parathyroid.com/low-vitamin-d.htm
- kenning 9y agoThis happens to your wife commonly?
- conorh 9y agoYes, several times a week. She is a parathyroid surgeon.
- frankzinger 9y agoFor those who were wondering about the "massive damage" (taken from the posted link): * Hyperparathyroidism (which could be caused by a parathyroid tumor) causes dangerously high calcium levels [1] * As a countermeasure, the body effectively lowers vitamin D (vitamin D facilitates calcium absorption) An ignorant doctor may miss the high calcium levels, seeing only low vitamin D, and put you on vitamin D supplements, which will raise your calcium levels again, thus eliminating the body's defenses against hyperparathyroidism. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypercalcaemia#Signs_and_symptoms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypercalcaemia#Signs_and_sympt...
- jrq 9y agoMost of these patients are likely exhibiting some spectrum of antisocial behavior, which means staying indoors or generally away from other people. I don't think it's as interesting as it seems. I'm rather certain there's a sensible explanation.
- ThrowawayP 9y ago> ...antisocial behavior, which means staying indoors or generally away from other people. That is not at all what "antisocial behavior" means. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-social_behaviour https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-social_behaviour
- wenc 9y agoRight. I learned that in the UK there is even an Anti-social Behavior Order (ASBO), essentially a catch-all law for people exhibiting these behaviors (which apparently spans all kinds of stuff from graffiti to littering). No comment as to the rightness or wrongness of this, but there it is.
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoIt’s in the DSM, which is published by the American Psychiatric Association. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisocial_personality_disorder https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisocial_personality_disor...
- jrq 9y agoBut you knew what I meant. In hindsight I should've clarified that my opinion originates from a layman. I am not a doctor or psychiatrist or anything of the sort. Thanks for the correction!
- samstave 9y agoWeird question: i saw an article yesterday saying that redheads naturally produce more vitamin d. So, what is the prevalence of redheads in psychiatric hospitals?
- Reason077 9y agoThose with pale skin naturally produce more vitamin D. This is because the pigmentation in your skin (Melanin), which protects skin from sun damage, also reduces vitamin D production. Pale skin is in fact an evolutionary adaptation to living in less sunny climates. That's why Vitamin D deficiency, in an un-sunny climate like Britain, is more prevalent in British Asian and Black British populations than in White British. This "redheads" association is due to red hair often being associated with pale skin, and not specifically due to hair colour. Some of the genes associated with less skin pigmentation also result less hair pigmentation (blonde or red hair).
- mark_l_watson 9y agoIf you are over 60, get your vitamin D blood levels checked! Made a big difference for me, simply increasing dose
- vinniejames 9y agoSo people locked indoors who can't see the sun have a vitamin D deficiency? Shocking...
- jimnotgym 9y agoIt says in the title that the study is talking about adults admitted to... that suggest they already had the deficiency
- RyanRies 9y agoPeople who are admitted to mental hospitals don't spend much time out in the sun or eat healthy diets? Fascinating.
- jimnotgym 9y agoAs these kind of stories are so popular on HN, I recently started curating a list at https://github.com/Jimnotgym/Hacking_Depression https://github.com/Jimnotgym/Hacking_Depression I hope it helps someone one day.
- blablabla123 9y agoDefinitely a nice idea. Although I'd strongly suggest to leave out the recommendation about supplements and drugs. The study PDF says that it's not clear why there's a correlation with Vitamin D deficiency but one explanation might be that people stay inside. Regarding drugs, actually people with a latent "sleeping" schizophrenia can get a psychosis even from soft drugs like Marijuana. Marijuana is a lightly psychedelic drugs, Magic Mushrooms even more so. At least you should put around a giant disclaimer and possibly also link to websites like erowid.org which go into a lot of detail, I guess they should also have details about complications, safer use etc.
- jimnotgym 9y ago> Although I'd strongly suggest to leave out the recommendation about supplements and drugs. I don't think there are any recommendations in the list at all, just a list of reading materials to discuss with your doctor
- emilepetrone 9y agoAn incredibly smart idea. Thank you. +1
- da02 9y agoWould you like to add this book to your list? I posted it to HN, but it never got any attention. "Nutrient Power: by William J. Walsh" https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/14603192-nutrient-power https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/14603192-nutrient-power If found it via this article: https://www.lewrockwell.com/2013/02/bill-sardi/weaning-away-from-psychiatric-drugs-finally-a-wayout/ https://www.lewrockwell.com/2013/02/bill-sardi/weaning-away-... "Dr. Walsh concludes, after years of investigation, that a gene-altering process called methylation (explained below) is involved in 70% of serious psychiatric conditions. That means it will soon be possible to molecularly reverse chronic mental problems. As brain science advances, the use of psychiatric drugs will gradually become obsolete since most mental disorders involve disturbances or imbalances of essential nutrients that alter brain function."
- tcj_phx 9y agoThe whac-a-mole [1] tendency of psychiatry is revealed by this line from this submission's link: > Assessment and treatment of vitamin D deficiency should be considered in in-patients to protect musculoskeletal health. Further epidemiological and intervention studies are needed to investigate the role of vitamin D in the pathophysiology of mental disorders. [emphasis added] The full context of vitamin D synthesis and conversion is relevant, not just "protect musculoskeletal health". Vitamin D is manufactured in the skin from cholesterol, but has to be activated in the liver & kidneys through "enzymatic conversion" [0]. Cholesterol is manufactured in the liver. If a person's liver is burdened by "stress", malnourishment, etc, it won't have the capacity to produce cholesterol for the skin to turn into vitamin D. Mental disorders are fundamentally related to stress and metabolism. Stress takes many forms; emotional stress is the most important. The whole organism's metabolic processes are relevant when figuring out the cause of "mental" problems. Just the other day I talked with my ~50y.o. Canadian friend. Her brother is dying from complications of drug addiction (opiates and everything else). She said he never had a good relationship with their father, and was devastated when their grandfather was killed right next to him in a farm accident (brother was 16 y.o. at the time)... [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitamin_D https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vitamin_D [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whac-A-Mole https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whac-A-Mole : The term "Whac-a-mole" (or "Whack-a-mole") is used colloquially to denote a repetitious and futile task: each time an adversary is "whacked", it only pops up again somewhere else. In a military context, the term is used to refer to ostensibly inferior opposing troops who keep re- appearing. In a programming/debugging context it refers to the fact that fixing a bug has a certain chance of creating a new bug which itself needs to be fixed. In a web context, it refers to the process of fending off recurring spammers, vandals or miscreants.
- internetman55 9y agoIs there any informed discussion of the value of reading articles like this versus just not and doing what your doctor says ?
- Strom 9y agoThat depends heavily on both your own and your doctor's knowledge/ability. If you're unsure if you can safely extract value from these articles then you should only listen to your doctor.
- mythas 9y agoThese kinds of studies often feel like the result of some p-hacking. Take a smallish sample size from a population of interest, record a bunch of data on them, then pick the result that is most abnormal and say “hmmm maybe this is why this population is different.” Not saying that’s the case here I’m just always skeptical until I know the methodology.
- jxub 9y agoAnd abundance of vitamin D through sun exposure is a reason why it's great to live in Mediterranean Basin, Australia or California instead of Norway, Sweden or Canada. Sun is a huge factor in both health and happiness although the northern societies seem to underplay it.
- grok2 9y ago"It has been suggested by some vitamin D researchers, for example, that approximately 5–30 minutes of sun exposure between 10 AM and 3 PM at least twice a week to the face, arms, legs, or back without sunscreen usually lead to sufficient vitamin D synthesis..." as per [1]. Maybe the quality of exposure is different? Atleast from reading articles like this, it seems like normally people at any latitude should not have trouble getting sufficient Vitamin D. 1. https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/VitaminD-HealthProfessional https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/VitaminD-HealthProfessiona...
- diimdeep 9y agoThere is massive genetic factors related to producing Vitamin D.
- cuspycode 9y agoThis is a hasty conclusion. For example, the city of Kiruna in northern Sweden (latitude 67 degrees north) has about three weeks of total darkness each winter. So there is no sun exposure at all during that time. And even south of the arctic circle, the chance of getting 5-30 minutes of sun exposure twice a week is not guaranteed in northern countries. For example, you might be stuck in an office building while the sun is above the horizon.
- TheForumTroll 9y agoThat just underlines that northern countries are happier even more.
- oliwarner 9y agoHN health posts tend to get posted without context and you'll get a pile of people [inadvertantly, I'm sure] pushing their supplement regime as a way to stave off clinical depression et al. This paper is NOT saying that low VitD causes psychiatric admission, just that patients may require supplements to bring them back to healthy levels. You get most of your vitamin D from skin exposure to sunlight so it's reasonable to suggest that these people with psychiatric issues and low VitD are likely to be shut-ins. The paper says as much... But people have a strange habit of ignoring the paper and latching their own beliefs onto the headline.
- DanBC 9y ago> This is NOT saying that low VitD causes psychiatric admission, just that patients may require supplements to bring them back to healthy levels. Yes. This study is showing one aspect of physical healthcare that needs to be addressed when people are inpatients. Other factors include (but aren't limited to) smoking cessation, exercise, sexual health, skin integrity, medication review, and food.
- INTPenis 9y agoAnother persective, which you just provided, is very healthy. I really need to see what you saw.
- tylerhou 9y agoOne way to see what he sees more often is, whenever you see something that sounds like causation, ask yourself whether it really is correlation - reverse the direction of implication, or consider if there might be a third reason that explains both.
- freeflight 9y ago> HN health posts tend to get posted without context and you'll get a pile of people [inadvertantly, I'm sure] pushing their supplement regime as a way to stave off clinical depression et al. I wouldn't say people are necessarily "pushing" their personal regimes, more often than not people are merely exchanging their personal experiences with certain issues. Personally, I've had actual relief from a really annoying issue (nightly teeth gnashing) thanks to a helpful HN comment pointing me in the direction of Magnesium. I'm still thankful and glad that happened! Btw: The headline is spot on with what the study found. I don't get what you are suggesting there with "reasonable to suggest that these people with psychiatric issues and low VitD are likely to be shut-ins". Only 8.7% of all patients were vitamin D sufficient at admission. They didn't get their insufficiency from being admitted, they already usually have it when getting there.
- grok2 9y agoA little while back, there was this submission to hacker news that didn't get much traction/attention, but which was about a research study that seemed to suggest that Vitamin D deficiency was a symptom of an underlying problem and just supplementing with Vitamin D was not sufficient as a fix and that the underlying cause of the deficiency the study said could be inflammation related to bacterial infection. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs00011-014-0755-z https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs00011-014-0755-...
- delbel 9y agoI didn't know about this study or the post, but I have also brought this up before and downvoted to hell. Bacteria that can evade the immune system can eat up all your vitamin D and wreck havoc. The solution is to eat other beneficial bacteria that eat them or their food and balance things out. This bacteria is LAB pro-biotics you can find in the store. Along with that, eating fiber to feed the pro-biotics so they don't die off. But if you eat health organic food, you get all of this. There's a GMO bacteria used as a pesticide that might be causing this. Anyway, if you bring these things up you are called a conspiracy theorist on this site. Its just common sense. Eat good non-GMO and non-gmo bacteria treated food with fiber, stay away from junk food, take pro-biotics, get sunlight.
- jseliger 9y agoThis comment is interesting but I downvoted it for one reason: "Citation(s) needed."
- delbel 9y agoif you were a professional or academic scholar requesting the citation, I feel that you would be entitled to that information. But to many people who aren't abuse this as some kind of sociopathic way of bullying people with contrarian information by downvoting, and I'm sick of it. It was a nice way to spark up a conversation a while ago but now its a toxic tool of sociopaths
- diimdeep 9y agoI live in Moscow, last winter we had only few hours of sunlight in December. Two months ago I went to test Vitamin D and got <10 ng/ml which is extremely low deficiency, currently doing around 8000ME daily. Reading: - Holick MF, Binkley NC, Bischoff-Ferrari HA, Gordon CM, Hanley DA, Heaney RP, Murad MH, Weaver CM; Endocrine Society. Evaluation, treatment, and prevention of vitamin D deficiency: an Endocrine Society clinical practice guideline. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2011 Jul;96(7):1911- 30. doi: 10.1210/jc.2011-0385. Epub 2011 Jun 6. - Guidelines for preventing and treating vitamin D deficiency and insufficiency revisited. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2012 Apr;97(4):1153-8. doi: 10.1210/jc.2011-2601. - Vitamin D deficiency: a worldwide problem with health consequences. Am J Clin Nutr. 2008 Apr;87(4):1080S-6S. - Vitamin D deficiency in the Middle East and its health consequences. Clin Rev Bone Miner Metab 7:77–93 - Vitamin D supplementation guidelines Pawel Pludowski - Treatment of hypovitaminosis D with pharmacologic doses of cholecalciferol, oral vs intramuscular; an open labeled RCT. Zabihiyeganeh M1, Jahed A, Nojomi M.
- yani 9y agoDepressed people do not go out. Vitamin D comes mostly from Sunlight. Vitamin D is not the cause. I am pretty sure that weight imballance can also be found in such individuals.
- sneezeplease 9y agoVitamin D is not a vitamin at all but a hormone. The supplement racket that sells it is actually selling you sickness. DYOR
- bipolar_throw 9y agoThrowaway account here. I started taking vitamin D supplement a few years ago. I believe it has helped improve my Bipolar disorder (less lows where I can't get out of bed). Added to my meds and I really think it helps but case study of one with wayyyyy too many variables.
- herbst 9y agoI come from a place where winters are very gray and rarely offer some sun. When I moved somewhere else, with friendly sunny winters I was surprised to learn that 'winter depression' was not even a common phrase.