>Does a human being have the right to contract with whomever he wants to sell his labor to? Yes, a person does, but I don't think that question really gets to

>Does a human being have the right to contract with whomever he wants to sell his labor to? Yes, a person does, but I don't think that question really gets to crux of the matter. I think the question is whether these companies were forming a cartel of sorts. Not a cartel of widget or oil production, but a cartel of jobs production. Its actually not clear to me that existing anti-trust law covers this case, and, from the DoJ's actions, it isn't clear to them either. If the Justice Department was confident of its case, we'd be seeing a lot more publicity in order to put pressure on the companies involved. The fact that DoJ isn't raising a ruckus over this means they think they have enough to go to trial, but not necessarily win. In circumstances like these, where the law isn't exactly clear on the topic, both sides seek to settle because neither wants to be proven wrong in open court.