2 ms·
It's interesting to read this first hand account after having read some more science focused stuff. >The power of war, like the power of love, springs from man
by tim333 9y ago
It's interesting to read this first hand account after having read some more science focused stuff.
>The power of war, like the power of love, springs from man's heart.
Both actually almost certainly arise from evolution. Love helps reproduce the species, wiping out the adjacent tribe and grabbing their resources helps also and if you are too nice they may wipe you instead. See 'Demonic Males' and the like for how chimps and early man did much the same kind of thing with of the order of a third of males dying in war like activities
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demonic_Males https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demonic_Males
Now we're getting quite good at not having wars (see Pinkers stuff or https://medium.com/future-crunch/the-decline-of-war-8760f9a5b5ce https://medium.com/future-crunch/the-decline-of-war-8760f9a5...)
through things like the UN, EU democracy and so on but the warlike instincts remain and come out in football, political battles, video games and the movies. Also I've found things like high altitude mountaineering have some war like aspects - bunch of mostly blokes fighting the mountain with some risk of death - and are quite fun.
- MrBuddyCasino 9y agoPinkers theory about how we have become more peaceful are apparently not backed by sufficient statistical evidence. I always take NNT’s statements with a grain of salt, but the pure stats/math stuff seems solid.
- tim333 9y agoTaleb seems to be criticising stuff Pinker didn't really say. Pinker's arguments are mostly look at this graph / dataset, haven't the numbers gone down, maybe this is why and he isn't really trying to do sophisticated statistical analysis generally. Taleb then attacks and says he hasn't done sophisticated statistical analysis but that's not really Pinker's point.
- MrBuddyCasino 9y agoBut isn't Taleb's core criticism precisely the lack of rigorous statistics backing Pinker's claims? I mean you can't just write a book with claims in it backed by pretty graphs and data and then go "sorry, was never meant to be hard science lol". Because then we're in bullshitting territory, unless I missed your point?
- tim333 9y agoYou're dealing with the sweep of human history over centuries and there isn't really a clear data set to do stats on. So given that I think Pinker's approach is about as good as you can do. But none of it is 100% conclusive - it's more a bunch of fuzzy data pointing the same way. You can get his argument in about 10 mins in his talks - here's one https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sjT4HlNJNgI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sjT4HlNJNgI The book is much the same argument but with more data. Taleb has an argument that purely doing stats on war deaths we could be in a quiet patch before carnage as usual. The arguments against this are qualitative stuff like the spread of democracy, the internet, cellphones, the global economy etc which Pinker deals with and Taleb kind of ignores. As an aside https://www.theguardian.com/books/2018/feb/25/skin-in-the-game-by-nassim-nicholas-taleb-digested-read https://www.theguardian.com/books/2018/feb/25/skin-in-the-ga... is quite funny on taleb/pinker if you like that kind of thing
- MrBuddyCasino 9y agoYeah that Guardian article nails it. Taleb can't do nuance - its all black and white. I believe this is both his strength and his greatest weakness.