6 ms·
What is a "blockchain"? To me, a blockchain is a way of solving double-spend problems in a Merkle tree maintained by open distributed consensus, by using some
by geofft 9y ago
What is a "blockchain"?
To me, a blockchain is a way of solving double-spend problems in a Merkle tree maintained by open distributed consensus, by using some scheme to resist Sybil attacks. The scheme is not necessarily proof-of-work, but the fact that there's a double-spend problem and you're solving it is key to the idea.
If you don't have a double-spend problem because all your transactions commute (e.g., Certificate Transparency), you don't have a blockchain, just a Merkle tree. Which is great, you don't have to incur the costs of mining at all, nor do you need to think about mining incentives and structures.
If you're not using distributed consensus because you have a central coordinator, you don't have a blockchain either, and again, you get to not think about mining. Whichever transaction reaches the coordinator first wins, so double-apend becomes irrelevant.
If the Fed wants to build FedCoin, I don't see any reason why they should refuse to be the central coordinaor and instead outsource consensus to the internet. I don't see any reason why they would, if they want to influence monetary policy at all—70% of Bitcoin mining last year was in China, which meant that it would have been straightforward for China to (globally!) freeze a Bitcoin address, and a little more complicated but still possible to prioritize or throttle certain transactions.
Maybe being protocol-compatible with Bitcoin or ERC20 or something would help, but fundamentally this would be an API to transfer USD, not a decentralized system.
See also patio11's Tweet https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583698553614143488 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/583698553614143488 "Most advantages of Bitcoin which matter are captured by, and improved upon by, a LAMP app which simply holds account balances." If the Fed wants to build that app, great!
- clhodapp 9y agoIt could be reasonable to somehow have control over things like the difficulty of mining or to be able to spawn new currency at a reduced cost via some sort of master certificate while still allowing transfer without communicating with a central coordinator system. A distributed system is a lot less likely to go down or become completely compromised.
- GauntletWizard 9y agoThe properties of "unlikely to go down" don't require a trustless blockchain; the attributes of being resistant to a node being compromised don't require trust beyond consensus. git is unlikely to go down and verifiable. Copies of a git repo verified by gpg signatures and repos that only accept commits that pass verification requires only as much distribution as running three instances. The fed can do all of this without giving up any control.
- clhodapp 9y agoThere is a tremendous difference between "we have three servers so our stuff probably won't go down" and "the system could theoretically remain in use forever even if we disappeared from the world".
- wmf 9y agoAnd that difference is gigawatts of power. A system that's "only" as reliable as Fedwire or SWIFT but uses 99% less power than cryptocurrency is an interesting tradeoff.
- marknadal 9y agoThere is already a word for what you are talking about, and you used it: Consensus. So I counter your argument. It is useless to call "Blockchain" something that must necessarily have consensus. Or else we should just call it a consensus mechanism, not a blockchain. So instead, I propose the following: A blockchain, is a cryptographically signed linked list. Note, things like "a distributed ledger" aren't included in that definition. Why? Because a distributed ledger is only possible if writes are cryptographically signed. Else, it is too easy to fake, sybil, forge, exploit, manipulate, lie, or mutate the ledger in a public setting. I've done a lot of work on commutative transformations (CRDTs, at https://github.com/amark/gun https://github.com/amark/gun ), and while they are a very different (and more scalable) approach to arriving at consensus (through deterministic means), I still think it is appropriate to call such CRDT/DAG/Merkle/other cryptographically based systems a blockchain. Why? Simply because they can be used as a distributed ledger, and that is the point that most people actually talk about/intend. At the end of the day, what people intend when they talk about "blockchain" isn't even cryptography or technology, it is simply an economic model. An economic model that doesn't require institutional trust. So in that sense, would a FedCoin pass as being a "blockchain"? From a technology standpoint, sure, but not from an economic perspective. Would love to hear your counter-thoughts!
- FreakLegion 9y ago> A blockchain, is a cryptographically signed linked list. I've always assumed this definition by analogy with Cipher Block Chaining (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Block_cipher_mode_of_operation#Cipher_Block_Chaining_(CBC) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Block_cipher_mode_of_operation...), but of course where a word starts out and where it ends up can be two very different things.
- therein 9y ago> Ehrsam, Meyer, Smith and Tuchman invented the Cipher Block Chaining (CBC) mode of operation in 1976 Seriously, even the term was coined back then and the concept is actually pretty identical if you think about it.
- masterbit 9y ago
- dnomad 9y agoI would say this is a rather limited, technical understanding of a blockchain. The three most interesting aspects of a blockchain are (1) the state of blockchain is visible to all participants (2) the rules (the code) for changing the state is visible to all participants and (3) there is some mechanism to detect and punish rule breakers and aggressors who try to deform the state. Look at it this way and indeed a blockchain is really a very sophisticated collaboration model. You don't need the distributed consensus or the decentralization or the trustlessness. There are blockchains with central coordinators and without trustlessness that may still prove very useful especially in global finance. People think Bitcoin or Ethereum are complicated but really, they are nothing compared to the global financial system. Distributed blockchain databases are much more elegant than what we have today in terms of achieving consensus on a very large (global) scale. FedCoin is a crazy idea but it's not stupid. A national public ledger would open a lot of very interesting doors. (Though the republic would likely collapse, see my other comment.) Even if the Fed required only trusted nodes (ie bank-like entities) it still would provide everything from a true national ID system to real, binding peer-2-peer lending between citizens to a system where everybody has perfect, real-time visibility into the national economy (unlike the primitive system we have today where the Fed collects a bunch a data, massages it, and then announces it each month.) Lots of other problems -- everything from medical records to real-estate -- become a lot more tractable.
- Jasper_ 9y agoWhat? There is no mechanism to "detect and punish rule-breakers" in either Ethereum or Bitcoin. Bitcoin's only mechanism is to push global human-readable alerts, or to pressure rule-breakers to stop through a blog post, as in the case of SPV mining: https://bitcoin.org/en/alert/2015-07-04-spv-mining https://bitcoin.org/en/alert/2015-07-04-spv-mining. If you define "rule-breaker" as "generates invalid blocks", then the only punishment rule-breakers receive is that... their block is invalid, they're ignored, and they get to try again next time. I don't see any sophisticated collaboration model in play here. > Even if the Fed required only trusted nodes... Lots of other problems -- everything from medical records to real-estate -- become a lot more tractable. Why aren't they solved by a database and a public API? What does the blockchain add?
- thisisit 9y ago> What is a "blockchain"? I am always curious, blockchain was not defined in Nakamoto's work. So, where did the word actually originate from? And what did it meant for the word's inventor.
- codetrotter 9y ago> blockchain was not defined in Nakamoto's work However the whitepaper does use the phrase "chain of blocks". https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf https://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf, page 7. So probably the word "blockchain" came about because someone read or heard someone else say "chain of blocks" in the paper and they said "oh, so a blockchain", and thus the word was born.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- geofft 9y agoWikipedia cites what looks like a mirror of Nakamoto's original Bitcoin source, which uses "block chain" in the comments of main.h: https://github.com/trottier/original-bitcoin/blob/master/src/main.h https://github.com/trottier/original-bitcoin/blob/master/src...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- cslarson 9y agoThis really misses the picture of what's going on. Fedcoin could be coordinated by the federal but live on or be connected to a public smart contract platform where that, now digitised asset, could be used programmatically and interdependently with many other systems in a much more efficient and easy to assemble way than can now be done. This may not sound like a good idea to most on hn but it's at least new.
- comboy 9y agoThe Fed can create unlimited money out of nowhere and doesn't have to answer questions about it from anybody. I don't think they dream is a transparent blockchain and money supply limited by an algorithm.
- zerostar07 9y agoThey don't want to be seen as "not having to answer to anyone" , so they would be going the blockchain rule, i.e. semi-accountability , i.e. stealing some of bitcoin's "decentralized" fame.
- lukeschlather 9y agoThe whole point of having a national currency is that the money administrators answer to Congress, not the businesses who borrow and lend money. "Decentralization" means taking power away from Congress and giving it to Goldman Sachs and the other big banks.
- _red 9y agoThe Fed is a private entity which is owned by its "Member Banks" (ie. big banks). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Reserve_System#Member_banks https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Reserve_System#Member_... Moreover, the currency that the Fed issues is not technically a "national currency", its "Federal Reserve Notes", that is a debt instrument which is theoretically backed by "US Dollars". Where are these US Dollars?..and more importantly how do we get some?
- bufferoverflow 9y ago> which meant that it would have been straightforward for China to (globally!) freeze a Bitcoin address No. It's not like all the Chinese miners are controlled by the government. It's not some monolithic agency. And then, there are many other coins.
- dingo_bat 9y agoIt's a safe assumption that everything is under government control in China. If not today, maybe tomorrow.
- geofft 9y agoAll Chinese miners are subject to the government's laws. They don't have to be directly day-to-day controlled by the government for the government to say, "We are applying sanctions to this entity, nobody may participate in helping them move money. Mining a block that involves a transaction from this Bitcoin address counts as helping them move money. Mining on top of any new blocks that involves transactions from this Bitcoin address, and therefore causing consensus to accept that block as part of the longest chain, also counts as helping them move money." This isn't a China-specific argument: I'd expect that any functioning government could the same. The only difference is that governments without a working national firewall would probably be less willing to spend resources on chasing down miners who connect to Bitcoin peers via VPNs in other countries. It just happens to be true in this case that the Chinese government has a national firewall that they use to shut down VPNs, the Chinese government's international interests are often opposed to the US Fed's, and 70% of Bitcoin mining happened in China's jurisdiction last year.