2 ms·
Yes, the solution to "Unwanted Expansion" is simply "because we assume that math works". It's begging the question. If you don't know what he's assuming, you d
by gowld 9y ago
Yes, the solution to "Unwanted Expansion" is simply "because we assume that math works". It's begging the question. If you don't know what he's assuming, you don't know what proofs are "interesting".
You could just as well say, "Because it's a finite" expression.
"Boxes in Boxes" doesn't really fit the theme. It's a complicated elementary math problem that's hard to solve, but not "tricky" in way that makes it seem impossible.
- ezrast 9y agoThe unstated observation made in Unwanted Expansion is that if every variable is equal to 2, then every operation in the expression must increase the total by at least 2 (note that only addition and multiplication are allowed, not subtraction or division). In other words, an expression with n terms or factors will always evaluate to at least 2n. This puts an upper bound on how far any finite-valued expression can be expanded.