3 ms·
> the government approached the families that lived there—some of whom had owned their farmsteads for generations—and “summarily evicted” them. [.. They descri
by dmix 9y ago
> the government approached the families that lived there—some of whom had owned their farmsteads for generations—and “summarily evicted” them. [.. They described the project as a “demolition range,” so any possible holdouts could be scared off with the threat of near-constant explosions.
I'm curious how this was done legally in the US, given the strong property rights there and especially given it was the south? Sounds like a very soviet style beginning.
But I guess they bought some land or had some existing public property, then scared the other nearby landowners away by saying it would be used for 'demolitions'... with offers of money for their property?
Or was it a straight up legal order / eviction that the federal government has some ultimate power to do?
- boomboomsubban 9y agoFederal and state government have the right of eminent domain, though it does not sound like it was used here. Just sounds like they offered to buy the land, and told any potential hold outs that their land would lose value if they refused. Though, in 1943 the "ultimate power" of the military and Federal government was virtually limitless.
- tanderson92 9y agoThe article did not say that owners were compensated. The wikipedia page (if you trust it) for Oak Ridge makes mention of the fact that not everyone was compensated: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oak_Ridge,_Tennessee#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oak_Ridge,_Tennessee#History
- ajdlinux 9y agoThe Wikipedia article only implies that some people were removed from their properties before compensation was paid, not that compensation was never paid.
- rdl 9y ago"Forced out before receiving compensation" just means it was done quickly; it doesn't necessarily (or even likely) mean they weren't paid. Not paying would lead to far higher risk of security compromise for the site (from legal challenges, etc.), so it seems unlikely they wouldn't pay.
- jessriedel 9y agoThe US has always had eminent domain, and critical wartime projects are just about the least objectionable usage I can imagine. Unlike other situations where people dispute whether the taking is in the public interest, the only contentious issue would be assessing the fair-market value. And the price of the farm land compared to the immense financial resources available for the bomb make it likely the farmers were paid well.