3 ms·
NASA insistence on the human-rating for their own commercial crew spaceflights greatly increases the cost. If I recall right two falcon 9 have been lost to acci
by walrus01 9y ago
NASA insistence on the human-rating for their own commercial crew spaceflights greatly increases the cost. If I recall right two falcon 9 have been lost to accidents, one on the pad, another 150 seconds into the flight. But the overall ratio of rapid unscheduled disassemblies to successful flights is looking promising.
Compare the predicted likelihood of fatalities with how many FAA licensed amateur/kit built "experimental" airplanes crash each year, killing their sole occupant pilots...
The FAA seems to be relatively OK with that fatality rate, on an ongoing basis, but spacecraft are held to a much higher standard.
If there had been a human in the very first Dragon flight carrying a wheel of cheese, years ago, they would have survived and had a nominal flight.
- octorian 9y agoI also wonder how many of NASA's own human launch vehicles would have actually passed the "human rating" requirements they're now applying to everyone else.
- walrus01 9y agoFew, considering the 1+0 lack of redundancy for major life support systems on the Mercury, gemini and Apollo. Their test method seemed to be "fly it unmanned a couple times, if it didn't explode or lose pressure, put some people in it".
- dvdkhlng 9y agoAnd don't forget the space shuttle which had a lot of possible single-point-of failures during launch and landing (e.g. no way to do a survivable launch abort during the first phase of flight; no way to survivably compensate asymmetric thrust when one booster were to fail; no way to shut down or eject boosters until burned empty; no way to perform ballistic reentry and landing when orbital control thrusters damaged).
- ekianjo 9y agoPretty much zero since the NASA cant even launch humans in space anymore.
- ubernostrum 9y agoDepends. Do you want to rule out NASA ever being allowed to evolve its requirements based on what it's learned from past failures? Or out of a sense of fairness, do you demand that what we knew about safety at the start of the 1960s is all we're ever officially allowed to know?
- walrus01 9y agoNeither, I do think they should have extensive safety qualifications for new craft, but the process should be faster. I just find it interesting that the us agencies responsible for road+highway safety and small aircraft safety will "accept" up to tens of thousands of fatalities a year, mostly due to operator error... While something like the dragon that has the low risk of killing 4 or 5 people (who have willingly signed up for the risk), takes such a long time to qualify.
- baq 9y agoCars are even worse, but crashes with fatalities don't show up in the news.