4 ms·
However, digging a hole in the ground and then filling it up is horribly, soul crushingly demotivating. Even if someone is working in a job that de facto amoun
by PeterisP 9y ago
However, digging a hole in the ground and then filling it up is horribly, soul crushingly demotivating.
Even if someone is working in a job that de facto amounts to doing just that, it should be covered up so that this fact isn't obvious and that a person can reasonably choose to ignore the truth and convince themselves that their job has some real value. Which is actually done, all kinds of internal propaganda, glorious mission statements, etc.
- mentalpiracy 9y ago> However, digging a hole in the ground and then filling it up is horribly, soul crushingly demotivating. Ah you see, this is why you have one person doing the digging, and another doing the filling! This way, each man goes home satisfied.
- sametmax 9y agoThis is not only clever, but actually a good metaphor of the activity of numerous entities.
- bitL 9y agoOne company does the digging, another the filling, and they are both owned by the same person in order to conceal that.
- sorokod 9y agoFor a second I thought this was a metaphor for software projects...
- Faark 9y ago> soul crushingly demotivating Probably a motivator to get a better / real job? I certainly prefer that over UBI
- thanatropism 9y agoEither HN is decaying into downvoting-who-you-disagree with (which is not my recent experience), or the UBI hype train is out of control.
- ghostbrainalpha 9y agoI think the downvotes are because the comment doesn't appear to be logical. We have a lack of real productive jobs that makes a difference. This results in the rise of the pointless job which is soul crushing. The answer is not to just get a real productive job. Because the lack of those is the source of the problem. It would be like if someone said they don't want to have chemotherapy because its painful. And you said... easy, if you don't want chemotherapy don't get cancer.
- bitL 9y ago> digging a hole in the ground and then filling it up is horribly, soul crushingly demotivating. Europe can start reconstructing all the ruins of castles, monasteries and cathedrals; for example Napoleon destroyed quite a lot of them and most didn't recover. Or just tear down all the ugly buildings built between 50s-70s when architects were out of whack like some German cities are doing right now (Frankfurt) and replace them with some 3D printed aesthetically pleasing ones. Should be a plenty of work and those jobs could be opposite of soul crushing.
- jeffreyrogers 9y agoAnd then we can repeat the process in 50 years when we decide 3D printed buildings look ugly and aren't functional :)
- megaman22 9y agoWe've got a lot of holes that need to be dug anyway. The state of infrastructure in the US is pretty deplorable in some places. You could keep a few million people busy rebuilding roads and bridges that are crumbling away - more if you leaned on manpower instead of machinery. I'd like to see something like a reincarnation of the CCC. There's so much relatively unskilled labor out there that goes undone.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> However, digging a hole in the ground and then filling it up is horribly, soul crushingly demotivating. Further, being forced to spend time doing that makes it much harder to gain skills for, or search for, another job. Make-work non-training jobs (though ideally real beneficial work that just has market value less than what is paid by government for it rather than obvious waste of effort) may be a same policy solution to short-term private sector dislocation where demand for work with basically-similar skill profile has dropped but is expected to rebound, but beyond that it is fairly obvious counterproductive and a trap that impedes the ability of a labor force to adapt to new needs compared to conventional means-tested welfare, which itself is not very good at that (which is one of the motivations for UBI.)