2 ms·
It's a thought-provoking comment for sure, but it makes a number of invalid inferences. > This is not to say that your particular choices are wrong. It’s just
by naasking 9y ago
It's a thought-provoking comment for sure, but it makes a number of invalid inferences.
> This is not to say that your particular choices are wrong. It’s just you are already engaged in “non-technical”, political work
A non-technical choice does not entail a political choice. In particular, such choices aren't always about managing "power", which is what politics is about.
> With limited time and resources, you will have to make tradeoffs in your code, documentation, and community about which people your software is supportive and hostile towards. [...] At the community development level, your intentional and forced choices around language, schedule, pronouns, and even technical terminology can make contributors from varying backgrounds feel welcome or unwelcome
I don't think this argument is sound. "Not supportive of" does not entail "hostile". Choices surrounding language, schedule and technical jargon does not entail how welcoming a community is.
This is an overly simplistic viewpoint that's typically indicative of a conflict theory mentality, but is not how good open source projects typically function. If you're ready and willing to be helpful:
1. if you don't know the jargon, people often help you learn it
2. if you don't fit the schedule, people will often help accommodate your efforts
3. if you don't speak the language, people who do will often assist, but if no such person exists, then that's just an insurmountable problem given limited resources
> Consider: you wish to take only the best developers, and yet your post has already discouraged good engineers from working on your project. Doubtless it has encouraged other engineers (who may be quite skilled!) with a similar political view to your own; those who believe, for instance, that current minority representation in tech is justified
This conclusion just doesn't follow. You can oppose some inclusion efforts in tech and yet not accept that current minority representation is somehow justified. The above argument blatantly begs the question that inclusion efforts a priori ethically justified, except the ethics of such efforts is precisely the dispute.